ENG1020 – ENGINEERING STRUCTURES
Project 3
Investigation of Alternative Overhead Pedestrian Bridge
Sandani Manjana Jayaratne – 24848352
Eranda Sampath Kulatunge – 24717150
Muhammed Akif Mazlan – 25849034
30th May, 2014
Summary
This report goes through the calculations performed to make an informed decision about which design is better suited for an Overhead Pedestrian Bridge. The bridge is to be constructed between Building 5A and Building 4 in Monash University Malaysia. The client has requested an alternative beam design for the bridge as opposed to the initial truss design. This report shows an overview of the calculations, plans and methods involved in designing the overhead pedestrian bridge.
Table of Contents
Introduction 4
Overview of the Bridge 4
Calculating Loads 4
Calculating Reactions 5
Checking For Failure (Initial Design) 8
Optimization 9
Checking For Failure (Final Design) 10
Design of the Middle Column 11
Conclusion 12
References 12
Introduction
The pedestrian bridge is to be constructed between Building 4 and Building 5A of Monash University Malaysia. The initial design for the bridge was a truss design. However, the client has requested an alternative beam design. The report explains in detail the two designs and which design is better suited for the purpose.
Design 2 (beam design) is to be constructed by steel beams, with a column in the median strip. Due to this, the beams were optimized before designing the column.
Safety was considered a top priority among other vital factors carefully planned when designing the bridge. To ensure safety, the initial beam self-weight estimate of 50kg/m was iterated several times until a suitable value was obtained. The beams were checked for...
... middle of paper ...
...ion is less than the maximum allowed deflection of 0.048m so the beam does not fail
Design of the middle column
Force/Area < σ stress
(102.37 x 〖10〗^3)/A < 350
A > 292.48mm^2
To check buckling effect :
F < (ELπ^2)/L^2
I > (FL^2)/(π^2 E)
I > (102.37 x 〖10〗^3 x 〖5400〗^2)/(π x 200 x 〖10〗^3 )
I > 1.90 x 10^6 mm^4
Hence, 114.3 x 3.6 CHS was chosen
Conclusion
The final conclusion was reached by calculating and measuring which beam would be most appropriate to support the bridge. The suitable beam was found to be 310UB : 32kg/m while the middle column is found to be 114.3 x 3. 6CHS Overall, the final conclusion we reached was that using a truss bridge is a more suitable design for the link bridge.
References
Lecture notes: Sunway and Clayton
Appendix 1 – I-beam sections
Appendix 2 – circular hollow sections
Appendix 3 – square hollow sections
ENG1020 Study Guide
Without a concrete reason for the bridge's failure, every suggested reason was researched until proven incorrect” (Silver). There were many reasons that were suggested, but could not be proven correct due to the collapse. Wikipedia states that “A small crack was formed through fretting wear at the bearing, and grew through internal corrosion, a problem known as stress corrosion cracking.” The failure of the bridge was caused by a defect in one of the eye-bars on the north side causing the other side to collapse as well. “Stress corrosion cracking is the formation of brittle cracks in a normally sound material through the simultaneous action of a tensile stress and a corrosive environment.
Bridge efficiency is important as it helps reduce cost of building while maximizing the strength of the bridge. Many things can influence the bridge’s strength and weight, but the two main things that can cause a bridge to be a failure or success is the design of the bridge and construction of its joints. In order to build a potent balsa truss bridge, it is crucial to know how the layout of members and style of gluing can help increase or decrease strength.
At the time of its construction in 1929, the Ambassador Bridge was the largest spanned suspension bridge at 564 meters until the George Washington Bridge was built. It was an engineering masterpiece at the time. The total bridge length is 2,286 meters and rises to 118 meters above the river. Suspension cables support the main span of the Ambassador Bridge and the main pillars under the bridge are supported by steel in a cantilever truss structure. In total, the McClintic-Marshall masterpiece is comprised of 21,000 tons of steel. The immense socio-economical impact that the Ambassador Bridge has on transportation and trade is imperative for daily interaction between the Un...
Following the collapse of the I-35 Bridge, other bridges in the country, with similar construction designs, were scrutinized. According to federal statistics, more than 70,000 of the 607,363 or roughly 12 percent of the bridges in the United States are classified as “structurally deficient.”
According to Suspension bridges: Concepts and various innovative techniques of structural evaluation, “During the past 200 years, suspension bridges have been at the forefront in all aspects of structural engineering” (“Suspension”). This statement shows that suspension bridges have been used for over 200 years, and that people are still using them today because they are structurally better bridges. This paper shows four arguments on the advantages of suspension bridges, and why you should use one when building a bridge. When deciding on building a suspension bridge, it has many advantages such as; its lightness, ability to span over a long distance, easy construction, cost effective, easy to maintain, less risk
Joseph B. Strauss, a famous designer of movable spans became interested in building a bridge at the Golden Gate so he submitted a proposal. His design was a hybrid structure that included a suspension span of 2,640 feet long along with a cantilevered truss span of 685 ft. on each end. However, his design was rejected by the public because they thought such a bridge would ruin the beauty of the area. Therefore, Strauss had to work with Othmar Ammann, Charles Derleth Jr., and Leon Moisseiff, consulting engineers, who together created a new design. They created a suspension bridge with a length of 4,000 ft. Their new design was approved by the U.S. War Department in 1930 and construction proceeded.
Compare with other types of bridges, suspension bridge can span the longest distance without using lots of material. However, if the issue of stiffness was not fully cosidered, vibration would be occurred on the bridge deck under high wind. A few week after the Tacoma Narrow Bridge was operated, the bridge start oscillation and its oscillation kept increasing day by day. Therefore engineers tried to build more cable between the bridge, but it is still unsuccessful. After four months the Tacoma Narrows Bridge was build, the bridgre which normally vibrated in a vertiacal motion, began to oscillate with the opposite side out of phase (torsional model), under the wind of 68 km/h. Due to the extremely violent oscillation, the failure bagan at the mid-...
This all iron design made the bridge a lot heavier than it was designed for, which added more stress to the truss. This fact, by itself, wouldn’t cause any alarm. However, the bridge itself, was very poorly constructed. The members of the bridge were all different sizes, and they were not connected together properly. Due to the poor construction and eleven years of use, members of the bridge had started to bend due to the stress. Despite bridge engineers inspecting the bridge for eleven years, no one noticed these faults with the bridge. However, the ultimate cause of this collapse, was so tiny, only one of the investigators, after the collapse, noticed it. A tiny air hole was left during the construction of the bridge, “and grew with repeated stress over eleven years” (Escher, 2009). This hole would develop in a crack, due to the changing temperatures and the trains crossing it for over eleven years. This would weaken the overall strength of the bridge. The cold winter air and the weight of the train would ultimately prove to be too much, and the whole bridge came crashing
Quebec Bridge is a riveted steel truss structure with 3,239ft long, 94ft wide and 340ft high. It was built on the main goal of connecting the lower Saint Lawrence River to the west of Quebec City, and Levis, Quebec in Canada. The bridge accommodates three highway lanes, one rail line, and a pedestrian walkway. Before the Quebec Bridge was built, taking a ferry or use the winter-time ice bridge is the only way to travel from the south shore of St. Lawrence in Levis to the north shore in Quebec City. The St. Lawrence River was the main channel of trade for Quebec City during the summer, but it filled with ice during the winter. This situation cut off all the trades entirely between the city until the river iced over and travel was possible again
To test the load handling capabilities of the structure, two separate loads were applied independently. First, a standard brick with the dimensions of 3-5/8” x 2-1/4” x 8” and an approximate weight of 4.5 pounds was place on top of the structure to observe the effects. The structure was able to support this distributed load with ease, causing no visible bending, breaking, or failures. The brick was then removed before performing the second test. To perform the second test, the structure was suspended across two tables, with a string attached to the center of one side of the truss systems. The standard brick was then attached to the rope to create a vertical load. After carefully attaching the brick to the string, the structure began to bend before eventually failing, causing the structure to break in
Green, D., & Unruh, W. G. (2006). The failure of the tacoma bridge: A physical model.74(8), Retrieved Feburary 23rd, 2010 from http://scitation.aip.org/journals/doc/AJPIAS-ft/vol_74/iss_8/706_1.html.
According to the theory of consequentialism, “an action is morally required just because it produces the best overall results” (Landau, 2015, p.121). In this view, an individual’s action is deemed moral only if it produces the optimific result in any situation. In the article “Framing Effect in the Trolley Problem and Footbridge Dilemma,” the authors introduced the “Footbridge Dilemma”, wherein an individual is given the option to save the lives of five workers by pushing an innocent man towards an incoming trolley (Cao, et. al, 2017, p. 90). In this dilemma, consequentialism suggests that it is moral to push the innocent man and save the workers. Even though pushing the man would kill him, the action would yield the optimific outcome in that
This was done to accommodate future additions that might be added to the bridge as this would add weight and increase the bending moment and shear envelope. The final design uses 70 kip per square inch steel for all girders with the 450-foot span girder having both flanges sized at 45 x 3 inches with a web of 144 x 0.75 inches (Figure 8). The 150-foot girder has both flanges sized at 18 x 2 inches with a web of 62 x 0.5 inches (Figure 8). The design moment and shear resistance for both girder sizes is shown in Table 1.
Vancouver, British Columbia has become an emerging leader of urban innovation for metropolitan centers all around the globe. Vancouver’s incredible array of vast natural and urban landscapes incorporated throughout the city, makes it distinctive among western urban centers. This unique aesthetic could possibly be attributed to Vancouver's lack of a multi-lane highway running through the city's downtown core, a popular practice during the urbanization and automobile boom after the Second World War (Kenworthy). The City of Vancouver decided to find a compromise in the form of a viaduct system on the streets of Dunsmuir and Georgia. The purpose, to move eastbound and westbound traffic flow efficiently in and out of the swelling downtown core(Kenworthy).
The idea of constructing the airport parkway pedestrian bridge was figured out when the pedestrians of the community that was built on the east and on the west of the parkway wanted to cross from one side to another as well as to the transit way and south keys mall and these pedestrians were exposing themselves to the danger of being hit by fast moving vehicles on the highway that was built in 1972. The city of Ottawa came under pressure after DAGENAIS, Kenny “citizen of Ottawa” died with a car accident on Monday October 22, 2007 where his afflicted mother started pushing on the city of Ottawa to have a safe path for crossing the parkway from the community to the transit way which eventually lead to the initiation of the project by the city transit committee where they issued a statement of work approved for the Environmental Assessment and finally they concluded that the best way for having a safe way is building a pedestrian bridge. The project started in 2008 and it was expected to complete by 2011 with a cost of $ 6.9 million but it was delayed till 2013 with a cost