Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Trait leadership theories limitations
Leadership trait theory paper
Trait leadership theories limitations
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Trait leadership theories limitations
Recommended Leader Behavior
Generally, authentic leaders are positive people with precise self-awareness. Linda is an example of an authentic leader. She is a leader with great virtue. She is not only a role model for her followers, she also shares information with her staff, encourages open communication, and engages her subordinates in the decision making process for the unit. Her genuineness and openness create a virtuous circle, and it turns out that people come to have faith in her. According to the theory, authentic leadership is all about the leaders being the person they know in their heart and they have always been strived to be. Authentic leadership does not origin from their title or their wealth. Instead, it comes from the
…show more content…
Obviously, she was not a good leader, but according to Trait Theories, she was not a born leader, and she, as an individual, has nothing to do with her awful leadership. She was chosen to step on the position, and she just did things in her ways. If the test of Big Five for personality or tests for emotional intelligence quotient were done before starting her leader position, Rose may found she was not a suitable person for the leader position, and she might give up at the beginning. She did not want things to end up in that tense situation, either.
The view is different, when I look the scenario through the lens of Authentic Leadership theory. The Authentic Leadership focuses on the moral aspects of being a leader. As a leader, Rose was not authentic and ethical to her staff. She tried to use the power to manipulate her staff by threaten to fire them. She did not know that the leadership did not come from the title you had or from the money you could make. Instead, the leadership comes from your being and the person that you
…show more content…
In our real life, we can give out many vivid examples of people who seem have no such leadership attributes, but they still succeed in their leaderships. The Behavior Theories can explain the phenomenon and help Rose to become a successful leader. In contrast with the Trait Leadership theory, Behavioral Leadership theory implies people can be trained to be leaders. There was several factors contributed to Rose’s failure being a unit director: 1) Rose was appointed to be the unit director directly from the other hospital without previous experience being a leader; 2) she was not assigned a mentor who could guide her through the transaction period; and 3) she was not familiar with the work environment and colleagues. According to the behavioral Leadership theory, if Rose has had the access to the proper training for being a good leader, she might be an effective leader, too, if not
Authentic leaders are honest, ethical and practical. An authentic leader develops their own leadership style, but this leadership style should not be overly tough. An authentic leadership style is one that can adapt to different situations and circumstances (Magloff). Coach Saban has five core values that he preaches every chance he
Roselily knows that she does not want to stay in the sewing plant, she knows that she wants to move on to something better, but she does not know what better is, and she certainly doubts if what she has chosen will be better than what she had. Her divided personality is like the different groups of Blacks in the civil rights movements. Some Blacks wanted segregation, some wanted their own nation, some wanted to be more African, some wanted to live like the White Americans, some were Muslims and some were Christians. They all agreed that their current situation was not acceptable, but they did not know how to improve it.
First, trait theory of leadership development holds that a person is either born with, or without leadership qualities. According to this approach, it is the inherited cognitive ability that will enable
They have profound convictions for for their leadership; Their behavior always reflect their core values and they view themselves as individuals that “lead with their hearts as well as their heads while also building enduring organizations” (George 2003). Leaders are encouraged to maintain the perception of authenticity but making sure that their words are consistent and reflect their action or intentions. They should not be so pompous and arrogant that they cannot relate to or find mutual and common ground with their staff. (Goffee & Jones 2005)
The leadership is a result of a combination of traits, with special emphasis on the personal qualities of the leader, which he should possess certain personality traits that would be special facilitators in leadership performance. This theory shows that leaders are born as such, there is no likelihood of 'making' them later with personal development techniques.
Evidently, Rose is submissive, powerful, caring and very nurturing. This is how women were anticipated to be in this era. Although Rose is submissive at the beginning of the play, she becomes a powerful woman at the end. Rose proves this when she decides to raise Raynell and by becoming involved in the church.
In an effort to understand the questionnaire, one must first understand the definition of an Authentic Leader. Genuine, trustworthy and reliable are a few words that are interchangeable with the term authentic. Authentic leaders exhibit qualities of confidence, transparency, and high moral standard and are usually very confident (Gardner, Avolio, Luthans, May and Walumbwa, 2005). A person that is considered to be authentic is one who taking account for their behavior and a person who is true to themselves and what they think. A quality of an authentic leader is that he/she exudes the level of authenticity through their actions that encourage others to want to behave the same way. The leader who acts in this manner believes that all individuals have something to contribute to a goal and
Leaders, an individual that people look up to for direction, inspiration, and guidance in life. Passion, influential, reliability, a vision, etc. These traits along with many more, are the things that make leaders great and successful. Everyone has different personality traits that make us capable of being leaders in this world and I learned that throughout this course. Everyone is different, whether good or bad, ethical or unethical, everyone has a leadership style all their own. “If your actions inspire others to dream more, learn more, do more and become more, you are a leader (John Quincy Adams).”
I haven't gone all week. " ( 197 ) This is very clearly her acting rebellious toward Rose by doing the opposite of what Rose told her what she had to do. She was explicitly told she was not allowed to get a job, but she got one anyway. As the story moves forward, she continues to act disrespectful toward Rose by complaining about the way she is being treated and acting rebellious by getting a job when Rose tells her not
The Trait Theory points out that there is a certain type of person making a good leader, with the decisive factor being: having or not having distinctive qualities of being a leader. Despite that, being an effective leader can still be a challenge. External and internal influences impact the effectiveness of the program and must be considered in order to succeed. Which leads us to the Behavioural Theory, thinking of what a good leader actually does. Kurt Lewin developed three leadership types, such as the autocratic leader who is a maker, someone who makes decisions without consultation with others.
Later in the novel, Ma’s authority reveals itself once again when she makes the definitive decision to move the family to dry ground during a flood. During this time, Rose of Sharon rises to a position of leadership by feeding a starving men with her life-filled milk, proving that she too has transformed from a follower to a leader within the family. Although these achievements may appear revolutionary for the women in the novel, the triumph is in fact trivial due to the fact that during this time it is the women’s responsibility to care for and preserve the family. So when Ma and Rose of Sharon voice their opinions and show leadership, they are not rising to a position of respect, but instead just merely fulfilling their familial
To become an authentic leader means to bring “people together around a shared purpose and empowers them to step up and lead authentically in order to create values for all stakeholders,” (xxxi). Bill George has identified the following five dimensions every authentic leader should encompass:
Leadership can be defined in many ways, but one thing all leaders have in common is the determination to get a task done. Although leaders may carry out this action in many different ways, they all do what needs to be done in order to reach their goal. Florence Nightingale was willing to gather a group of women and pick up and leave her home to tend to the wounded soldiers of the Crimean War. In order for Florence to be successful in leading these women ultimately into a place of war, she needed to have trust and a good reputation for herself. Something that shows the reputation of Florence Nightingale was the fact that at the time there were no female nurses in the Crimean War.
Leadership can be shown through any person in any type of situation. In a classroom discussion, on the playing field, or in public a sign of a leader is evident. A person is born a leader. Certain humans know what to do when the time calls for it. Many people in positions can be entitled a leader such as basketball players. Even a famous movie star can be given this title. These people are not true leaders. True leaders are the belaboring teachers and the intellectual speakers. These are the people who show that leadership is an action, not a position.
The learning obtained from the Leadership and Organizational Behavior course has been valuable. From this course, I have learned that while someone can be a manager or a leader, it is better to be both. The various topics discussed throughout the eight week course have provided the unique insight necessary to be an effective leader. The insight gained allow for the identification of the behaviors that an effective leader must possess and continually develop. By identifying these behaviors, I am better able to shape my leadership style and goals so that I can achieve my full career potential as a leader within my organization. Ultimately, I realize that it is important to both do things right and do the right things in all my actions within an organization.