Why Talking to the Dead Is Not Fact

945 Words2 Pages

When it comes to the subject of psychics or "mediums" such as John Edward, most people want only to prove or disprove its existence. However, to prove or disprove this would be impossible because there is no scientific way to achieve either. When approaching such a sensitive subject as this, one should keep in mind a single question, is it reasonable to accept this as fact?

According to Peter Kor's third principle (2), such an extraordinary claim as being able to communicate with the dead makes us "question our understanding of ordinary events" and "such an extraordinary claim or view requires proportionate revision of conventional wisdom"(2). For example, if a friend in Florida calls to tell me that a polar bear was in his backyard, eating the wheel off his car but has since left, I should not simply accept this, because it questions what I already know to be fact. What I already know as fact in a situation like this is that 1) polar bears do not live in Florida because they are not comfortable in the heat, 2) polar bears certainly do not roam free in suburban areas, and 3) just because he said this happened doesn't make it real.

In order to accept this scenario as fact would cause us to have major revisions of our knowledge of polar bears, it would challenge us to question everything proven by the scientific research of polar bears. We thought polar bears could not comfortably survive in warm or hot climates, how could researchers have missed something as key as polar bears liking to live in warm (or hot) climates? That is one of the reasons why it is not reasonable to accept being able to talk to the dead as fact, it questions what we already know, and the revisions of our thinking and knowledge would be as great as the claim. It would change the grieving process, the need to "say goodbye" to loved ones, our entire concept of death and what happens after death would all have to be revised to support this great claim.

In the case of John Edward, a "medium" who says that he is able to communicate with the dead, because his claim is so significant, we should have a more meticulous inquiry than that of his claim. To follow Kor's fourth principle

Open Document