Social Promotion

1614 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Effect that causes poor education

Social Promotion: An Excuse for Not Educating a Child

When it comes to students failing a grade level there has always been two options, either a student can be socially promoted or they can be retained. The choices for a failing child are limited and both situations have stigmas attached. Both options have positive and negative effects this I concur. While, presenting both sides of the argument I will note that retention is not always the solution to a failing child’s future, however, promoting a student without the skills or knowledge to proceed to the next grade level only paves a future of destruction.
What is Social Promotion?
“Social promotion is the practice of promoting students to the next grade when they have failed to master part or all of the grade-level curriculum.” Social promotion is considered to keep a student’s social and psychological well being intact by allowing them to stay with their peers (social promotion). Social promotion reinforces failure, ignores students’ problems, and sends a message to every student that achievement and effort do not matter. (#1 pg. 1)
The Alternative…Retention
Retention is often viewed as the only alternative to social promotion, it is a policy that holds back students who have failing grades at the end of a school year (#2 pg. 3). Retention allows students to have an additional year to repeat a grade and to master the core curriculum for that grade level. However, when a child repeats a grade level they are often taught the same skills in the exact same manner from the previous year, thus leading them through another unsuccessful year.
While most teachers know that educational research indicates that retention can be ineffective, if not harmful, they feel there are insufficient educational alternatives (#2 pg. 4). It is estimated that between 15 and 19 percent of students are retained each year and as many as 50 percent of students in large urban areas are usually retained at least once before they graduate or decide to drop out of school (Starr pg.1). The American Federation of Teachers reports that very few studies have ever documented any appreciable long-term academic gains with retention (Starr pg. 1). The AFT also notes that with retention come problems such as, student alien...

... middle of paper ...

...ly intervention, and a determine and well prepared staff.
It is so easy to pass a child off by just promoting them to the next level. One might think it is not my problem anymore. By socially promoting children by just one grade level can effect that student’s performance for a lifetime. Students are in school to learn not to be passed off. They have right to a proper education and they must master all skills before being promoted. There is no hope for a child who has not met the standards or mastered the skills to be constantly promoted from one grade to the next. A student with an immeasurable amount of unmet skills and standards will never be able to function on “normal” level within society. If school systems, teachers, and parents do not hold each child responsible for the set standards then they are depriving these students of an education and a chance to ever have a successful future. When the question asked what is to be done with a failing student the answer is not social promotion. Social promotion is an excuse, a scapegoat, or a way out of taking the time, extra effort, and responsibility of educating a child.

Show More
Related

  • Mike Nolan's Ethical Decision

    820 Words  | 2 Pages

    Larsen, D. E. (2002). When students don't "make the grade": A qualitative study of educators' ethical reasoning and decisions about student retention. (Order No. 3086307, Washington State University). ProQuest Dissertations and Theses, , 152-152 p. Retrieved from http://ezproxy.library.unlv.edu/login?url=http://search.proquest.com/docview/305537121?accountid=3611. (305537121).

    Read More

  • Carl Singleton's 'What Our Education System Needs Is More F'

    738 Words  | 2 Pages

    Our education system is failing and in his essay “What Our Education System Needs Is More F’s” Carl Singleton writes that nothing else will right the ship or fix this issue except for his proposed solution which is to simply fail more students. As a matter of fact “by the dozens, hundreds, thousands, even millions” (Singleton 1) is how he describes the failing grades should be distributed. He claims that illegitimately passing students has existed for the past two decades and even implies that it stems further back than that with many teachers in the school system today “who never should have been certified in the first place.”(Singleton 1).

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Prussian Education System

    1311 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to Gatto, "School are meant to tag the unfit-with poor grades, remedial placement, and other punishments" (37). As an example, schools let students who had poor grades throughout the year to pass the grade only by going to summer school. I have a friend whose dreams were shattered thanks to the system we have now. Andrea 's eleventh-grade year was very difficult for her because her mother died at the beginning of the school year. She struggled with depression, and after being in honor classes for the past three years, she started to struggle with her classes. When she reached twelfth grade because of her low performance in her junior year, she was put in medium level classes. She felt discouraged and she did only what she needed to do to graduate. One of the consequences was that she lost her opportunity to get a scholarship to a university that she always dreamed of going to. I want to ask the school board and teachers, why wait so long to bring attention to a student 's bad grades instead of warning your students at the start of their failing grades? The school system should focus on students like Andrea to provide counseling support to help them cope with their personal problems. Teachers should be working with the parents and those specific students to give them a wake-up call to help them get back on track as soon as

    Read More

  • Holding Back A Child Is Not The Answer

    765 Words  | 2 Pages

    If deciding to hold back a child for not successfully completing their grade, it would result in low self - esteem, hinderance and humiliation, nada problem child. As a result of this child becoming a hinderance, gaining low self - esteem, and becoming a problem child. Reach out out and help these students that are struggling and are being left behind. Help them to understand what's happening better. Make these children feel as if they are the future, and they are not a hinderance nor a problem child. Help these children to gain something they lost, their self - esteem along with courage, pride, and mainly confidence.

    Read More

  • Pros And Cons Of No Zero Rule Essay

    1059 Words  | 3 Pages

    Giving students a grade that they have not earned hinders the youth’s future educational success. A number of schools are no longer giving a grade of zero on assignments, tests, and exams completed by students. While other school districts continue to give students the grade that is adequate for the work they have done or have not completed. Giving students the grade that equals their work is designed to show students where they need to improve. Many school boards want to stop giving out zeros for work that hasn’t been turned in and give a grade that rages around the “D” area keeping children from falling behind in their classes. By allowing student to pass through the school system the educational board is raising their graduation and success

    Read More

  • The Pros And Cons Of Grade Retention

    2255 Words  | 5 Pages

    Grade Retention is linked with a child’s socio-emotional difficulties. Certain Studies have discovered that children who had repeated a grade, in comparison to matched non-retained students, indicated poorer social adjustment, more harmful attitudes towards school, more problem actions, lower achievement, and a lesser amount of frequent attendance, even though other studies have established fewer transformations.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of The Blind Side By Michael Oher

    1678 Words  | 4 Pages

    Michael Oher was from an all-black neighborhood located in the third poorest zip code in the country. By the time he was a sophomore, he’d been to 11 different schools, he couldn’t read or write, and he had a GPA of 0.6. In his first-grade year alone, he missed 41 days of school and ended up repeating both the first and the second grade; he didn’t even go to the third grade. Oher was one of the thousands of children that have been identified as having four or more of the at-risk factors mentioned by the National Center of Education and Statistics (NCES). According to the NCES, poverty and race are high on the list of things that negatively affect students’ ability to succeed at school. Other risk factors include changing schools multiple times and being held back from one or more grades. Oher’s biography, The Blind Side by Michael Lewis, proves how socioeconomic status impacts a child’s academic success because placed in perspective, education is not as important as the hardships of reality.

    Read More

  • The Consequences of Grade Inflation

    647 Words  | 2 Pages

    When students arrive at university, professors expect them to understand the material to an exceptional standard. The problem is that grade inflation is occurring more regularly in secondary schools and universities across the country and when these students’ marks are sent to universities or colleges, the student may be given multiple scholarships for something that he/she should not have earned. Grade inflation is conceived between both students and teachers, meaning that the students are given higher grades when they have inadequate learning, reading, and verbal skills, while the teachers do not have to grade as many papers as they should in the real curriculum. There have been multiple examinations that have confirmed that grade inflation is very real and still occurs today. Students seem to think that they do not need to put forth much effort in school to do well and grade inflation encourages this thought.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Community College Retention

    833 Words  | 2 Pages

    Retention issues is an aspect that plagues many colleges and universities today. Despite all the incredible advantages that come along with having an associate’s degree or bachelor’s degree, but retention rates remain high. As provost of the college, it is time to redesign and incorporate at least two retention programs.

    Read More

  • The Importance Of College Student Life And Successment In College

    1145 Words  | 3 Pages

    The college landscape has changed a lot in the past decade. The stakes are higher as it pertains to cost, competition, potential benefits to the students themselves and society. This day in age to become successful and economically self-sufficient, a post-secondary degree is a must in a lot of cases. Research has backed up this statement and has consistently documented a positive relationship between education and economic stability (e.g., Day and Newburger 2002). In 2008 the U.S census bureau collected data that showed that bachelor’s degree recipients earn about $26,000 dollars more than high school graduates. The importance of postsecondary education and obtaining a degree are at the forefront of concerns right now and colleges are constantly trying to conquer the ever widening topic of student success and retention. Not many college students think about the ramifications of not having any supplemental experience to go with a degree and not utilizing opportunities of engagement that most colleges offer to help them inside and outside the classroom. We therefore need to ask what else we need to do to further improve the effectiveness of our research on behalf of increased student retention and success. Are there other questions we must ask and issues we need to further explore in the continuing problem of student attrition in post-secondary education?

    Read More

  • Grade Retention Argument

    1610 Words  | 4 Pages

    Grade retention seems like a reasonable solution to a serious problem. A child is significantly behind their peers, maybe they are emotionally immature, or they cannot quite grasp what is being taught to them. The first thing to do is make sure the child does not have a learning disability, after that, it is determined that since this child is falling so far behind there is no other option than to hold them back a grade. This will ensure that they have time to catch up with their classmates and move on to have a successful school career. Schools implement this every year, despite the research proving how unsuccessful grade retention is. There is no clear cut way to help a struggling child. Children learn in such diverse ways. It is a challenge to help someone falling behind, it takes time, effort and research to realize what is going to be effective for a struggling student. Grade retention is harmful to the student, it negatively impacts the child’s academics, it leads to early dropout, their self-esteem suffers, and it is not a cost effective way to help a child succeed.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Every Kid Needs A Champion By Rita Pierson

    1116 Words  | 3 Pages

    It would have been helpful for a future educator to know what worked and what did not so the past does not end up repeating itself. When Pierson stated, “We know why kids don’t learn … We know why” (Pierson), she was only talking about how the effect of poverty, attendance, and the influences of student’s peers had on the students. What about the students with learning disabilities, the ones that are in the foster system, or the ones who just don’t care? Don’t they matter too. Only pinpointing a certain group makes her argument seem one-sided.

    Read More

  • Grade Retention

    3003 Words  | 7 Pages

    Grade retention, better known as “staying back”, “being held back” or “repeating”, has been the topic of much debate within the educational system. The controversy which surrounds this long-standing issue has been reinforced by such topics as the recent endorsement of academic standards. Research indicates that “the rate of retention has increased by approximately 40% in the last 20 years with as many as 15% of all American students held back each year and 30-50% held back at least once before ninth grade” (Dawson, 1998). These discouraging statistics pose copious problems within a school system. The difficulties can be appreciated at the organizational level, as well as inside the classroom and, most troubling, within the individual students. The consequences, both positive and negative, reverberate throughout the school system. Grades retention is an issue which requires a prodigious amount of examination and should be considered carefully and thoroughly.

    Read More

  • LITERATURE REVIEW: Theories on Student Attrition

    1259 Words  | 3 Pages

    Since the early 70s theorists have pondered the causes of college dropout. Generally referred to as “student attrition,” this problem has spurred numerous causal theories and theoretical models. Vincent Tinto led the research with his revolutionary 1973 study, which he later revised (1987) amid criticism from other luminaries in the field, most notably Bean, Astin, Terenzini, and Pascarella. It is on the work of these scholars (including also Tinto) that all modern research in the student attrition field is based. I found and will review in brief some of the extensive research from Tinto to the present, including the basic criticisms therein. I will further explain the steps some colleges are currently taking to counteract this increasingly important issue.

    Read More

  • Transactional Leadership Essay Examples

    770 Words  | 2 Pages

    Teachers routinely teach you the standardized things you need to know to get promoted to the next grade. In my experience, throughout high school, once you acquire the knowledge to pass the test, high school teachers believe you have reached your potential and no longer push you to accomplish more. Unlike, high school teachers, professors are willing to provide an abundance of support to any student sincerely trying to improve. Not only do college professors help students recognize their potential, but become the driving force behind them exceeding their personal expectations. Professors continuously clarify what matters and why it matters; therefore, instilling a sense of pride in their work, as well as in themselves.

    Read More

More about Social Promotion

Open Document