When discussing immigration it is very hard to talk about the emotions immigrants had when entering the country because no one knows their experience first-hand except them. Essays like “Coming and Going: Round-Trip to America” by Mark Wyman and “Permanently Lost: The Trauma of Immigration” by Victor Greene give readers a better insight on the mindsights of immigrants by telling the why and how of their journeys. In “Coming and Going….”,Wyman talks about immigrants entering the United States for the sole purpose of making a steady income to support themselves and their families at home. In “Permanently Lost…”, Greene goes in depth about the mistreatment faced by immigrants and how music and dance became an outlet to the oppression. Both essays …show more content…
are vastly different, yet in the same aspect very similar. Both arguments can be looked at as a path that breaks away into two paths. The common path or argument is that immigrants went through severe mistreatment, but Wyman and Green break away after that. Wyman argues that the hardships immigrants faced were necessary in order for them to have better lives in their home countries. He also argues that immigrants took all of these obstacles into consideration when beginning their journey to America. Greene on the other hand argues that the hardships immigrants faced came at a price and often cost them and their families. To support their claims, both authors used different types of evidence.
Wyman used first-hand accounts from immigrants through the form of letters and interviews. Wyman also uses facts and statistics like the data on immigrant success rates. In that statistic from a 1934 study he states that, “40.3 percent (255 persons) reported good results in America, 17.3 percent (109) had “quite good” results and only 16.4 percent (104) had fair results.” This strengthens his argument that the “labor was essential” in order for the immigrants to be stable and successful in their homelands. In Victor Greene’s essay, he goes in depth on what obstacles the immigrants faced and what topics they decided to sing about. With that being said his main form of evidence is song. For example, he talks about the journey of Jewish immigrants and how in most circumstances only the men traveled to America. With the men being out of the home, wives were left in charge of the home and the family and most fell into a for lack of a better word depression because their families were separated. To support this idea, Greene includes the lyrics of “Shlof Mein Kind”, the emotion is especially felt in the first few lines were the song says “Sleep my child/By your cradle your mother sits/Sings a song and weeps.” This strengthens his argument that the obstacles of immigration ruined not only the immigrants, but the families of the immigrants. Many wives were left unable to support themselves and their
children. As stated before both essays talk about the hardships of the immigrants. Although they say similar things, these essays contradict each other. Wyman perpetuates the idea that immigrants came into America knowing that they would have to struggle in order to make ends meet, saying that “They [immigrants] agreed: you worked hard in America” and saying that Italian immigrants went as far as calling America “the workshop”. But Greene argues that the oppression immigrants faced came as a surprise. Wyman also makes the arguments that immigrants made the decision to travel to the U.S. Greene’s entire essays focused on the idea that families were ripped apart. Giving off the idea that immigrants had no choice in the situation. Which is obviously false because immigrants were condemned when arriving to America, meaning that no one went to get them. Both essays give valid points, but Mark Wyman gives the better argument because immigration was a decision that these people made.
Mark Wyman, the author of the brief essay known as Coming and Going: Round-Trip to America, had a different perspective about immigration to America from the various counties during the 1880’s through the 1930’s. A common belief, regarding the immigration to America, held that immigrates stayed in America during the massive shift of population, due to the enormous creation of factories and cities that erupted in America. The past day literature entices readers to believe that all immigrates came to America to work and eventually settled down to create their own families. It’s taught that all of these families stayed in America for their entire life span. Although despite the common belief, Wyman held to his own thoughts on the controversial debate and pioneered a new way of thinking. He believed that countless immigrates, which came from all over the world, actually only
John Steinbeck does not portray migrant farm worker life accurately in Of Mice and Men. Housing, daily wages, and social interaction were very different in reality. This paper will demonstrate those differences by comparing the fictional work of Steinbeck to his non-fictional account of the time, The Harvest Gypsies.
According to Coming to America: A History of Immigration and Ethnicity in American Life, between 1880 and about World War I, the vast majority of Eastern European Jews and Southern Italians came to the United States populating neighborhoods in New York and the Lower East Side is the best example. One thing, which was common to the immigrant experience is that, all immigrants come to the United States as the “land of opportunity”. They come to America with different types of expectations that are conditioned by their origins and families. But every immigrant comes to America wanting to make himself/herself into a person, to be an individual and to become somebody. In this case, the author showed in Bread Givers, Sarah’s desire to make herself into something and bring something unique to America, which only she can bring. It is an effort to understand the immigrants, particularly Jewish immigrants, from a woman’s point of view. The book shows that it was a challenge for Jewish immigrant children, particularly females, on the account of the intensity of their family’s connections and obligations that was so critical for the immigrant communities. This was true for the immigrants who came to settle in the neighborhoods like the one Sarah and her family settled in.
Recently illegal immigration has become a very pressing issue among people. Many people around the borders are being greatly affected by the issue and think immediate action needs to be taken to put a stop to the issue. The Documentary Border War: Battle Over Illegal Immigration takes a stand on the issue using many examples of pathos, ethos, and logos to try and persuade people that illegal immigration is a very serious issue and we need to put a stop to it. This documentary follows the lives of people who have been affected by illegal immigration, and explains how they feel about the issue. Another way that people can look at the issue of illegal immigration is through the eyes of the immigrants, and the reasons why they might be trying migrate to another country. The documentary Wetback: The Undocumented Documentary focuses on the issue from this point of view. This documentary uses pathos and logos to show the lives and hardships of those people who are trying to migrate to a new country. Although Wetback used many examples of pathos and logos to show the struggles of the migrants, Border War did a better job showing pathos by following the lives of people who were affected by the illegal immigrants they were also very persuasive with ethos by following credible people.
Islas, Arturo. From Migrant Souls. American Mosaic: Multicultural Readings in Context. Eds. Gabriele Rico, Barbara Roche and Sandra Mano. Boston: Houghton Mifflin Co. 1995. 483-491.
America is a land filled with immigrants coming from different corners of the worlds, all in hopes of finding a better life in the country. However, No one had an easy transition from his or her home country to this foreign land. Not every race thrived the same way—some were luckier than others, while some have faced enormous obstacles in settling down and being part of the American society. Many people have suffered
In a country full of inequities and discriminations, numerous books were written to depict our unjust societies. One of the many books is an autobiography by Richard Wright. In Black Boy, Wright shares these many life-changing experiences he faced, which include the discovery of racism at a young age, the fights he put up against discriminations and hunger, and finally his decision of moving Northward to a purported better society. Through these experiences which eventually led him to success, Wright tells his readers the cause and effect of racism, and hunger. In a way, the novel The Tortilla Curtain by T.C Boyle illustrates similar experiences. In this book, the lives of two wealthy American citizens and two illegal immigrants collided. Delaney and Kyra were whites living in a pleasurable home, with the constant worry that Mexicans would disturb their peaceful, gated community. Candido and America, on the other hand, came to America to seek job opportunities and a home but ended up camping at a canyon, struggling even for cheapest form of life. They were prevented from any kind of opportunities because they were Mexicans. The differences between the skin colors of these two couples created the hugest gap between the two races. Despite the difficulties American and Candido went through, they never reached success like Wright did. However, something which links these two illegal immigrants and this African American together is their determination to strive for food and a better future. For discouraged minorities struggling in a society plagued with racism, their will to escape poverty often becomes their only motivation to survive, but can also acts as the push they need toward success.
The novel uses immigrant labor to form its foundation for the story and then recounts personal memories from Jim’s life about the immigrants to show the hardships they face coming into a new world for the first time.
After reading The Book of the Unknown Americans, I realized how difficult immigrating to the United States can be. I am an immigrant also, so just reading the story makes me relate to many problems immigrants experience relocating to a different country. Immigrants often face many issues and difficulties, but for some it is all worth it, but for others there comes a point in time where they have to go back to their hometown. Alma and Arturo Rivera came to the United States to better their life, but also so that Maribel could attend a special education school. While Arturo had a job things had gone well for the family, but once Arturo lost the job and passed away the two of them had to go back because they felt that that was the best option for them. Reading this book made me realize how strong an individual has to be to leave their own country and relocate somewhere else not knowing if this will better your life or cause one to suffer.
In “My Two Lives”, Jhumpa Lahiri tells of her complicated upbringing in Rhode Island with her Calcutta born-and-raised parents, in which she continually sought a balance between both her Indian and American sides. She explains how she differs from her parents due to immigration, the existent connections to India, and her development as a writer of Indian-American stories. “The Freedom of the Inbetween” written by Sally Dalton-Brown explores the state of limbo, or “being between cultures”, which can make second-generation immigrants feel liberated, or vice versa, trapped within the two (333). This work also discusses how Lahiri writes about her life experiences through her own characters in her books. Charles Hirschman’s “Immigration and the American Century” states that immigrants are shaped by the combination of an adaptation to American...
Richard Wright was a young migrant that moved to Chicago in December of 1927. He was nineteen years old and like other immigrants sought a better life, one without violence, intimidation, humiliation, and spiritual claustrophobia. Wright hel...
"Immigrants and the American Dream." Society 33.n1 (Nov-Dec 1995):3(3). Expanded Academic ASAP. Thomson Gale University. 26 Sep. 2006.
The. Kessner, Thomas and Betty Boyd Caroli, “Today’s Immigrants, Their Stories.” Kiniry and Rose, 343-346. Print. The. Portes, Alejandro and Ruben G. Rumbaut, “Immigrant America: A Portrait.” Kiniry and Rose, 336-337.
Immigration is the international movement of people into a country that they are not natives to. This topic is a common subject in many texts. Even though they might talk about the same topic, not all texts portray the subject of immigration the same way. The texts, “Red Umbrella”, and “Band-aid for 800 Children” both have immigration as the main subject and they portray the subject in both similar and different ways.
Written almost thirty years ago, describing an age far removed from its own, E.L. Doctorow's novel Ragtime nevertheless explores issues of identity and ethnicity that still face America in spite of its lofty ideals of individualism and diversity. It displays for the reader a rich and hypnotic portrayal of the soul of immigrant America, yet still fails to avoid ethnic bias in certain subtle ways. Whether the lapses into feelings of cultural superiority originate from the purposeful portrayal of the characters Doctorow created or without the author's conscious prior awareness, a careful reading of the text will reveal them. In this way, these same assumptions and prejudices test our own. As Ragtime delineates between ethnic identities that are understood to be like children or animals and noble races that are simply misunderstood, it holds a clear mirror up to the reader's own assumptions of identity and ethnicity.