Bureaucracy

387 Words1 Page
bulb-icon

Recommended: Discuss the features of Max Weber’s bureaucracy

Bureaucratic institutions were formed as a way to manage large-scale collective action, to increase organization and coordination. Max Weber is known for his analysis of the bureaucratic institution. In the Weberian sense, bureaucracies are composed of a hierarchical structure of authority in which command flows downward and information flows upward, a division of labor composed of specialized tasks, a consistent set of rules, a large amount of impersonality, advancement through demonstrated merit and overall specified goals.

By definition, bureaucratic organization may not seem to be a bad thing. However, in practice, bureaucracies are known to have a negative effect on all its participants. As defined by Samuel Kernell and Gary Jacobson, "The model bureaucracy is, in short, a purposive machine with interchangeable human parts." Bureaucracies are dehumanizing, they train for obedience, and stifle creative thought. The characteristics of bureaucratic organization that have the worst effect on its participants and most compromise efficiency are its hierarchical structure in which all the power resides at the top and the specialization of tasks.

The complex and elaborate hierarchical structure of bureaucracies is what leads to the massive amounts of paperwork or "red tape" for which bureaucracies are known. When control is dictated from the top down and information is relayed from the bottom up, problems of principal-agent loss arise. Information has the potential to become clouded and misconstrued, or even lost for that matter, which greatly compromises efficiency. To reduce principal-agent loss and increase efficiency, the free flow of information between all levels should be promoted. With this, workers would not have to go through a "middle man" to contact someone higher in the hierarchical structure. Not only would this increase efficiency but also increase the quality of communication. Also, the top level in the bureaucracy should not have all the power. The top should have more power, but the power and authority should be distributed which would also help cope with principal-agent loss.

Another characteristic of bureaucratic organization that compromises efficiency is the division of specialized labor. When all the tasks are specialized and everyone is trained to do one specific thing, there is no allowance for free riding. If one person, or many people for that matter, decides to slack off (which is simply human nature), what then happens?

Show More
Related

  • Bureaucracy and The Branches of Government

    593 Words  | 2 Pages

    Often, when the discussion of American bureaucracy is broached in conversation, those holding these conversations often think of the many men and women who operate behind the scenes within the government. This same cross section of Americans is looked upon as the real power within the federal government and unlike the other branches of government, has little to no oversight. A search of EBSCO resulted in the following definition, an organization “structure with a rigid hierarchy of personnel, regulated by set rules and procedures” (Bureaucracy, 2007). Max Weber believed that a bureaucracy was technically the most efficient form of organization, one structured around official functions that are bound by rules, each function having its own specified competence (2007). This wide ranging group of Americans has operated within the gaps, behind the scenes, all under the three core branches of government: the legislative, executive, and judicial branches. The division of government into three branches and separate powers gives each branch both exclusive powers and some additional power...

    Read More

  • Paradoxical Analysis In Joseph Heller's Catch-22

    1169 Words  | 3 Pages

    This leads to one of the major themes of the book, which is that when operating in a bureaucracy, certain people are enabled to put their interests in front of the interests of others, whether it is supporting the interest of their

    Read More

  • Trustees and Delegates

    1036 Words  | 3 Pages

    Modern Bureaucracy in the United States serves to administer, gather information, conduct investigations, regulate, and license. Once set up, a bureaucracy is inherently conservative. The reason the bureaucracy was initiated may not continue to exist as a need in the future. The need or reason may change with a change in the times and the culture needs. A bureaucracy tends to make decisions that protect it and further it’s own existence, possibly apart from the wishes of the populace. It may not consistently reflect what might be optimal in terms of the needs and wants of the people. Local governments employ most of the United States civil servants. The 14 cabinet departments in the U.S. are run day-to-day by career civil servants, which have a great deal of discretionary authority.

    Read More

  • Texas Plural Executive System

    524 Words  | 2 Pages

    A German philosopher and political economist Max Weber once said “The fully developed bureaucratic apparatus compares with other organizations as does the machine with the non-mechanical modes of production.” Max Weber explained to the audience that each governmental system have their own style of running in a political bureaucratic structural standpoint. For example, Texas governments are ran by a plural executive system. They are very weak and the other being the cabinet system. One can argue that the other is better because these two system are very different.

    Read More

  • Public Administration And Organization Theory: The Structural Foundation By Paul Barker's Outline

    1782 Words  | 4 Pages

    Paul Barker 's, "Public Administration in Canada" defines the roles of different administrative structures in Canada. In the second chapter. "Public Administration and Organization Theory: The Structural Foundation," Barker addresses Max Weber, a German scholar, and his approach to the classical Bureaucratic Theory. Bureaucracy 's main purpose is to achieve a high level of efficiency. Bureaucratic structures contain a hierarchical structure, specialization of labour, merit based employment and promotion, full time employment, unbiased or unprejudicial decisions, documentation and employment separated from personal life. Weber also believed bureaucracy was also detrimental for society. It overwhelms leaders and is a mind numbing experience for

    Read More

  • Essay On Texas Bureaucracy

    596 Words  | 2 Pages

    A bureaucracy is the system of non-elected officials administering government policies and programs. Building roads, inspecting gas pumps, inspecting facilities for cleanliness, writing tickets, educating, operating transit systems and Game Warden are the many tasks of a bureaucracy. In the Federal Bureaucracy the president is the CEO. His job is to appoint all officials and being elected to lead this diverse group of organizations. However, Texas does not have a CEO, the power and blame is spread across the various bureau heads. This allows each bureau head to do as they wish in their department, unless the state runs out of money. The governor does not hold this responsibility, but the voters do. Unlike the Bureaucracy of Texas, the responsibility

    Read More

  • Mainstream And Critical Perspectives Of Bureaucracy And Post-Bureaucracy

    875 Words  | 2 Pages

    Bureaucracy has been the main form of organisation for over a century and can be characterised by the following: functional specialisation, employees carrying out one function of activity as their primary role; hierarchy of authority, those in superior positions having authority based solely on the virtue of the position itself; a system of rules, the tasks of the organisation following a formal set of procedures and practices; and impersonality, individuals being treated on the basis of the rules rather than emotions and personality (Knights & Willmott, 2012). The mainstream perspective states that a bureaucratic organisation’s central aim is to maximise efficiency, objectivity and fairness and can be thought of as a ‘machine’ with the people making up the components (Knights & Willmott, 2012). This view attributes three problems to this rule-centred organisation: poor motivation, poor customer service and a resistance to innovation and change (Knights & Willmott, 2012). Employees in bureaucratic organisations tend not to be committed to their

    Read More

  • Office Space

    1547 Words  | 4 Pages

    An organization’s structure can affect its efficiency and productivity. The two main management theories are the Classic Theory and Theory X. Classical theory is defined as a management theory of a large organization in which management is led by intuition to motivate and control employees (Hamilton, 2008 p. 41). The Classic Theory can be divided into two large subgroups, scientific managers and bureaucratic theorists. Scientific manager’s focus is on reducing production costs while bureaucratic theorists focus is on administrative efficiency (Hamilton, 2008 p. 43). Although Theory X is not a large subgroup of the Classical Theory, it is under the classical theory and its crucial point is that workers are assumed lazy; therefore managers punish them to motivate them. Managers of Theory X believe that the average person; will avoid work because they do not like work, will not strive to achieve objectives, will avoid responsibilit...

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Max Weber's Bureaucracy

    1478 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many authors have utilized his writings as the basis for their own research. Consider, for instance, Robert K. Merton whose Bureaucratic Structure and Personality shares many explicit similarities with Weber’s thought. Merton is also, for instance, a strong proponent of bureaucracy as the ideal type of administrative form: “The ideal type of such formal organization is bureaucracy and, in many respects, the classic analysis of bureaucracy is that by Max Weber” (Merton, 1940,). Merton’s writings already began incorporating the troubling aspect of dehumanization inherent to bureaucracy: “As we know from Merton, bureaucrats often seek refuge in rules and procedures as protection from criticism” (Lerner & Wanat, 1983, p. 506). Modern authors have studied this important disconnect as

    Read More

  • Taylor's and Weber's Theories of Management

    1089 Words  | 3 Pages

    Although there are some differences among bureaucratic and scientific management theories, in actuality, they both share a deliberate and detailed approach towards improving an organization’s efficiency and effectiveness. Dissimilarities seen in these approaches may be due primarily to their points of reference. Where the scientific approach focuses primarily on maximizing the efficiency of work, the bureaucratic approach’s concentration is directed on the structuring of the personnel within the organization. Although there are weaknesses in both management theories time has shown each to be successful models. These two classical approaches to management complement each other and lend well to large organizations. Both theories have been universally adopted and adaptations of each are in practice today.

    Read More

  • Organizational Theory of Behavior of Frederick Taylor, Max Weber, and Henri Fayol

    956 Words  | 2 Pages

    Frederick Taylor thought that changes in the work process and/or rules would advance efficiency and productivity. He originated the scientific management approach in public administration. It was based on the idea that work processes should be observed via experiments which would greatly improve productivity. It would do so by doing away with the rule of thumb work methods and replacing them with the results of actual timed observations (14). The application of the scientific approach to management methods would lead to optimizing task time by simplifying the job. It would mean observing work processes to find the one best way to perform each job (15). Once the best way was discovered, all employees were to use it. The simplification of the job would improve task time. This method would lead to increased productivity, higher wag...

    Read More

  • Traditional Model to New Public Management

    1315 Words  | 3 Pages

    ‘Weber emphasized on top-down control in the form of monocratic hierarchy that is a system of control in which policy is set at the top and carried out through a series of offices, whereby every manager and employee are to report to one person in top management and held accountable by that manager’ (Pfiffner, 2004, p. 1).

    Read More

  • Traditional Model to New Public Management

    1498 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to Sapru R.K. (2008) p370-371 the traditional ideal of public administration which inclined to be firm and bureaucratic was based on processes instead of outcomes and on setting procedures to follow instead of focusing on results. This paradigm can be regarded as an administration under formal control of the political control, constructed on a firmly ranked model of bureaucracy, run by permanent and neutral public servants, driven only by public concern. In emerging nations the administration was true bureaucracy meaning government by officers. In this perspective Smith (1996) p235-6 perceived that“the bureaucracy controls and manages the means of production through the government. It increases chances for bureaucratic careers by the creation of public figures,demanding public managers, marketing boards.

    Read More

  • Essay On Centralization And Decentralization

    748 Words  | 2 Pages

    Satisfaction of Human Needs: Decentralization is an important tool to fulfill the human need for power, status, independence, and prestige. This satisfaction helps to construct a frame of satisfied managers, who feel their responsibility towards the company and work.

    Read More

  • Culture, Power & Politics in the Workplace

    1484 Words  | 3 Pages

    Bureaucracy is an organizational design based on the concept of standardization. “It is characterized by highly routine operating tasks achieved through specialization, very formalized rules and regulations, tasks that are grouped into functional departments, centralized authority, narrow spans of control, and decision making that follows the chain of command” (Judge & Robbins, 2007, p.

    Read More

More about Bureaucracy

Open Document