What is the Limit between Collecting and Hoarding?

1143 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Impact of collecting and hoarding

Imagine that you are going to go over to your friend’s house to have dinner for the first time. You pull into their white picket fence lined driveway and realize their white house looks nice with their blue shutters and their bright red front door. As you smell their fresh flowers outside, you can only imagine how lovely the inside of their house looks like. You walk into the front door and are immediately greeted by a wall covered in antique doilies. You think that it’s odd but still continue to walk into their living, which is also covered in doilies. There aren’t just a few doilies here and there; the walls are covered top to bottom with doilies. What is that strange material on their couches? - Doilies! Small doilies, large doilies, rug doilies, and lamp shade covered doilies everywhere. What have you gotten yourself into? Your friend comes in and starts to tell you about her “collection”. You wonder how it could be a collection when it has taken over her whole house. At this point you think that she is more of a doilie hoarder rather than a collector. When is having a collection something more serious like being a hoarder? Why do people even start collecting things and what makes an object collectible? These are just some of the questions I will analyze in this paper. Before going any further, the definition of the topic should be discussed to understand the problems with it. The meaning may be obvious to most people, but when looked at in the dictionary, many flaws arrive. A collection means the act or process of collecting; a group of objects or works to be seen, or kept together ("American Heritage® Dictionary of the English Language, Fourth Edition, 2003"). The definition causes a problem because i... ... middle of paper ... ...of Mental Health and Addiction (2014) ProQuest. 26 Apr. 2014. Maycroft, Neil. "Not Moving Things Along: Hoarding, Clutter and Other Ambiguous Matter." Journal of Consumer Behaviour 8.6 (2009): 354-64. ProQuest. 28 Apr. 2014 . Anderson, s, H Damasio, and A Damasio. "A neural basis for collecting behaviour in humans.." Brain: A Journal of Neurology. 128.1 (2005): 201-212. Print. Belk, Russell W. "Collecting as Luxury Consumption: Effects on Individuals and Households." Journal of Economic Psychology 16.3 (1995): 477-90. ProQuest. 26 Apr. 2014 . Feller, Ray. Collecting Away their Suffering: Meaningful Hobbies and the Processing of Traumatic Experience. Order No. 3493085 Antioch University New England, 2011 Ann ArborProQuest. 29 Apr. 2014 . Lehman, H, and P Witty. "The present status of the tendency to collect and hoard." Psychological Review. 31.1 (1927): 48-56. Print.

Show More
Related

  • Stereotypes about Homelessness in America in Dumpster Diving by Lars Eighner

    666 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...ghner, 1993). It is the authors belief that consumers are aware of their consumption, as well as realize how wasteful they are with food in general For the students who do not fit into Eighner's wasteful category, he presents a grouping of frugal consumers who, "carefully wrap up even the smallest leftover[s] and shove it into the back of the refrigerator for six months or so before discarding it" (Eighner, 1993).

    Read More

  • Rejecting Heritage: Wangero's Greed Illustrated in Walker's, Everyday Use

    1603 Words  | 4 Pages

    It was a little girl’s second Christmas and, although she does not remember now, she was so excited to open the big red package from grandma. She ripped open the package and the soft, handmade brown bear went poof in her hands. She has kept the ratty, old bear not for its beauty but because it has sentimental value of a simpler time. Like this example, many people have memories of items they grew up with that have more than monetary value, most people forget the real value of these items, however, and commercialize them as art or sell them away as junk in garage sales. In Alice Walker’s “Everyday Use,” we are shown a vivid example of what can happen when people take these once treasured items for granted. Walker’s character Dee/Wangero is an estranged daughter and sister who has not seen her family for six years reappears at her mother’s home to take away her family’s most sentimentally valuable possessions. Because Wangero’s view of her own heritage has been skewed and distorted by her peers, Wangero forgets the value of her mother’s possessions in an attempt to impress her contemporaries. Through Wangero, Walker reveals how misunderstanding one’s heritage can lead him to search for his place in a fake legacy invented to help him reconcile his misunderstanding of his own origins, and can even cause him to cheapen his family heritage because of a desire to stand out among his peers.

    Read More

  • Mardi Gras Made In China Analysis

    1523 Words  | 4 Pages

    To collect is to bring things together. However there is an art to collecting, as it is not simply just bringing miscellaneous things together. There is a common theme for the objects and together they serve as a special meaning to their collector. In both texts “The Museum and the Public” by Stephen Weil and Walter Benjamin “Unpacking My Library” by Walter Benjamin, and in the film “Mardi Gras: Made in China”, the purpose of collecting is to tell a story and to showcase the significance of the objects in the collection.

    Read More

  • On Dumpster Diving By Lars Eighner

    960 Words  | 2 Pages

    Reading the story “On dumpster diving” by Lars Eighner it made me feel grateful for my materialistic things, because I would not want to experience dumpster diving to survive. Eighner has led me to question where I place my value. He has made me curious about what treasures could be found in dumpsters. Most of these items have lost their intrinsic value; however, they could hold great personal value. A can of food could mean a meal for someone in need. It has also made me wonder about what I throw away, and if someone has ever discovered what I’ve thrown away and used

    Read More

  • Graham Hill Consumerism

    2231 Words  | 5 Pages

    1. The main idea is not only that owning stuff is not the key to happiness, it’s also that consumers today own more than they need to thrive which directly impacts the environment. Hill illustrates the environmental impact by showing statistics of global warming today versus the past century, and how consumerism is leading to a hotter climate. Hill debunks claims of buying happiness by discussing a study where stress hormones spike to their highest when people are managing their personal belongings. Hill’s most prominent example that consumerism is not the answer is himself, as he discusses some of the most stressful times of his life being right after coming into a large sum of money and buying whatever he fancied. When Hill concludes his article, he states that “I have less—and enjoy more. My space is small. My life is big” (213).

    Read More

  • The Use of Drugs by 1950s Artists

    4706 Words  | 10 Pages

    Van Den Haag, Ernest. "Conspicuous Consumption of Self". National Review VI (April 11, 1959): 656-658.

    Read More

  • Barbara W. Tuchman's 'Persumption Of Consumption'

    1094 Words  | 3 Pages

    Not everything that is expensive is better. Rich people can get everything they want, but middle class people need to think if they need it, or they can find the same thing cheaper. Most people try to find cheaper things, but some buy expensive things, because they think that it will help them to feel that they are rich. First, people buy those expensive things, and after that they are in debt. Expensive things need a lot of money, but people don’t have them, so they use credit cards to buy for that. According to the article “All That Glitters Is Not Gold” 32% of attendees who were at the auto exhibition bought a car and 56% of attendees reported they were going to buy a car in the near future. It shows that that people don’t have money, but they saw that other people bought the car, and they want it also. For example, my parents just last week bought a new car, because our old one broke. My dad said that everyone has big and new cars, so we need to buy a costly car like other people have. I thought that it was a stupid idea to look at expensive car, but anyway he found a good car, nor costly, nor a cheap car. The cost is in the middle, and it is a wonderful car. Indeed, running after expensive things people forget to look at prices. They forget that they will need to pay for that thing for many years after they buy

    Read More

  • Analyzing Thorstein Veblen's The Theory of the Leisure Class

    856 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1899 Thorstein Veblen wrote The Theory of the Leisure Class: An Economic Study of Institutions. In this work, Veblen presented critical thinking that pertains to people’s habits and their related social norms. He explores the way certain people disregard the divisions that exist within the social system, while subsequently emulating certain aspects of the leisure class in an effort to present an image of higher social status. He also presented the theory of conspicuous consumption, which refers to an instance when a person can fulfill their needs by purchasing a product at a lower cost that is equal in quality and function to its more expensive counterpart; however, said person chooses to buy the more expensive product, by doing so, they are attempting to present an image of a higher social status. The almost 110 year cycle between 1899 and 2010 reveals few differences in buying behaviors, other than the differing selection of luxury goods to indulge, or over-indulge in.

    Read More

  • American Culture: The Tendency to Spend Money on Useless Things

    850 Words  | 2 Pages

    ... English, it is the love of material things. This "love of material things" causes the majority of people to spend money carelessly, always buying things that they believe make them "happy". In a study done by 24/7 Wall Street, there are 10 things that the "average" American household spends almost 15% of its annual income. These ten items are, in order from highest to lowest (in number, not price):

    Read More

  • Affects of Frontal Lobe Damage

    2599 Words  | 6 Pages

    Jonides, J. & Smith, E. (1999, March 12). Storage and executive processes in the frontal      lobes.      Science, 1657-1663.

    Read More

  • Compulsive Hoarding Syndrome

    1788 Words  | 4 Pages

    Timpano, Kiara, and Norman Schmidt. "The Association Between Self-Control and Hoarding: A Case Report." Cognitive and Behavioral Practice. 17. (2010): 439-448. Print.

    Read More

  • Collection Development Policy

    2010 Words  | 5 Pages

    A library or information unit must have a dedicated plan on having an organized Collection Development Policy, represents the guideposts of all types of library institutions. Collection development is the process of planning, selecting, acquiring and evaluating the library collections’ convenience to print and electronic collection developments. Thus, it is essential to have a written collection development policy, a statement of general collection building principles with desalinating the purpose and content of a collection in terms of relevance and internal audiences (Clayton and Gorman 2007). Broadly, the international and local libraries have sketched written collection development policies which they are aware of its uses. Recently, the written policies consistently renewed with the rise of digital collections. However, the value of the written collection development plan shakes with the complexity of managing electronic resources, funding and time considerations, criticism on how it written and also its inflexibility. This essay will examine the arguments for having the advantages of the written collection development policy (CDP) and the issues evolve which against the latter.

    Read More

  • Minimalism Essay

    1117 Words  | 3 Pages

    Hoarding is a mental illness which leads its victims to live in squalor. Hoarding is a form of obsessive compulsive disorder. This is commonly referred to as OCD. OCD is a mental illness that causes obsessions which lead to repetitive behavior. In contrast, minimalism is based on not having a multitude of things. Minimalism promotes a clear mind. This tool is based on reducing things that cause stress. Theoretically, less stress puts an ease on the mind. The tool of minimalism is also used to gain better awareness. Through awareness comes a better understanding of situations. As a minimalist, having less stuff can lead to being more focused on the important things. Things such as relationships, health, dreams and passions. Minimalists only own things that add value to their

    Read More

  • Money Can't Buy Happiness

    1150 Words  | 3 Pages

    Acquiring things like houses and cars only has a transient effect on happiness. People’s desires for material possessions crank up at the same, or greater rate, than their salaries. Again, this means that despite considerably more luxurious possessions, people end up no happier. There’s even evidence that materialism makes us less happy. People don’t shift to enjoyable activities when they are rich.... ...

    Read More

  • Essay On Recycling Attitude

    1289 Words  | 3 Pages

    Joung (2013) studied two groups, classified as materialistic and non-materialistic consumers, and found no difference between participation in recycling between the two groups even though the materialistic consumers had higher scores for disposing and lower scores for environmental attitudes than non-materialistic consumers (Joung 2013). It could be suggested that a consumer’s general recycling behaviour is a poor indicator of their environmental attitude and other disposal behaviours; Shim (1995) suggests that consumers can “develop a habit of recycling without much sensitivity toward environmentalism” (Shim 1995). Here general recycling behaviours are a result of the convenience of recycling for the consumer rather than a representation of their environmental concerns.

    Read More

More about What is the Limit between Collecting and Hoarding?

Open Document