Weather By Seymour Simon And Astronomy, By Jay M. Pasachoff

1045 Words3 Pages

For this assignment, Weather—a trade book written by Seymour Simon—and Astronomy, a textbook written by Jay M. Pasachoff as part of the Prentice Hall Science Explorer collection, were analyzed for readability, friendliness, considerateness, fairness, and text complexity. Weather is a picture book that provides an introduction to the concept of weather and the various components that compose it, as well as explores the effect of weather conditions on human activities and the effect of human activities on weather conditions. On the other hand, Astronomy is a textbook that provides an in-depth introduction to the field of astronomy, by including units on “Earth, Moon, and Space,” “Exploring Space,” “The Solar System,” and “Stars, Galaxies, and the Universe” (Pasachoff, 2005, vi). Both texts could be used to enhance instruction in a middle school …show more content…

The results of Fry’s Readability Formula showed that Weather is written at a seventh grade level and Astronomy is written at an eighth grade level. Based on those scores, if Weather were to be used in a seventh grade class, most students should be able to read the text with ease, since the text is at their assumed reading level (see Appendix A). However, on the other hand, if I were to use the Astronomy textbook with my sixth grade class, since it is written at an eighth grade level, I would need to provide additional supports, as well as teach the students literacy strategies that could help them better comprehend the text (see Appendix A). For both texts, I would need to especially work with my English Language Learners and any other student that may not be reading at grade level to ensure that they receive the support needed to understand the information presented in the

Open Document