The Savagery Show And Tell Summary

1171 Words3 Pages

Dan Dallas’s Savagery Show and Tell (1978) article discusses the mental health efforts implemented to minimize trauma in young children and their parents after exposure to a homicide that occurred in public view. The murder took place in front of over 50 students of an elementary school in Illinois. Immediately, the elementary school was concerned with the possible psychological effects witnessing the murder could have on the students. In response, the school implemented various methods of processing and coping to minimize potential negative effects. Although Dallas covered an interesting and important topic in his article, there are many flaws with how the article was written. The six primary concerns with Dallas’s article are: ambiguity of …show more content…

Dallas’s abstract includes a description of the homicide that was witnessed by the students, a question posed by a student, and a breath of information regarding the immediate implementation of counseling services. Although some of this information is relevant to the article, it also leaves out several essential details. With that being said, the abstracts lacks a hypothesis and leaves the reader questioning the purpose and the focus of the article. For example, is the article about the effect of the trauma on the students, or parents, or is the article about the counseling efforts to avoid the effects of trauma before or after the onset of symptoms? Furthermore, the abstract does not indicate any methods or outcomes of the counseling efforts mentioned. Additionally, the already brief abstract includes an off topic question regarding what to do when a child asks questions about the acceptableness of murder. This question is only addressed briefly and is not a central theme of the …show more content…

The Dallas (1978) indicated once that the offender was 23-years-old, then directly addresses the offender six times as being a young man or a youth. Much like the misleading nature of the emotionally charged words, calling a 23-year-old a youth misleads readers and distorts judgements of the events. By wrongfully giving the impression that the offender is younger, the author makes the offender seem more innocent than he is, and in turn, makes the homicide seem more shocking and potentially traumatizing than it really

Open Document