The Best Things In Life: A Guide To What Really Matters By Thomas Hurka

1027 Words3 Pages

Inside of the book The Best Things in Life: A Guide to What Really Matters, by Thomas Hurka, there are three major theories of the good life and well-being. These include Ethical Hedonism, Desire Satisfaction Theory, and Objectivism. Ethical Hedonisms stance is that something is intrinsically good for you if and only if it is a state of pleasure. Your well-being improves when and only when you experience pleasure. Desire Satisfaction Theory has a few more layers to it. There are four different versions. All of them have to deal with satisfying something that is intrinsically good for you, they just vary based on what kinds of desires are being satisfied, if you wanted it at the time the desire was achieved, who the desires pertains to, and …show more content…

One thing that stood out to me is that Hurka values pleasure based off of intensity and duration, and that going from a -10 to a -9 is more of a significant improvement than going from a 9+ to a 10+ in happiness (pg. 56-57). Another one of his claims wa that there are 3 necessary conditions for knowing, which in turn discredit the value of the life and pleasure inside of the experience machine. The 3 parts are knowledge of the world, knowledge of place in the world, and knowledge of self (pg. 77-90). How this discredits the experience machine, which was talked about in great detail in his book, is because we lack our knowledge of our place in the world while inside of the experience machine. Living a well rounded life, and what it means to do so, was one of the most important takeaways from this book in my opinion. Hurka believes that well roundedness is dangerous because it leaves you as a master of nothing. As stated on page 170, “there are two opposing factors to consider: the dilettante's disadvantage, which makes the option line bulge inward and seeking well-roundedness unwise, and the costs of concentration, which do the opposite”. He believes that moderate concentration on one good is the

Show More
Related

  • Shafer-Landau's Argument Against Autonomy

    557 Words  | 2 Pages

    In chapter 2, Shafer-Landau proceeds to list the theories that attempt to disprove hedonism by highlight the shortcomings in its logic and hedonism's replies to these objections. The Argument from Autonomy, is one of strongest objections to hedonism listed. Shafer-Landau states that for a theory to pose a serious threat to hedonism, it needs to challenge the idea that happiness is the only thing of intrinsic value (34). Chapter 2 discuses four strong objections that have the potential and support to disprove hedonism. The Argument from Autonomy provides an abundance of strong information to support its claims.

    Read More

  • Novel Critique of The Four Things That Matter Most

    1883 Words  | 4 Pages

    Ira Byock wrote the novel The Four Things That Matter Most, in 2004. Mr. Byock is a renowned medical doctor who specializes and practices in palliative care and his main interest is offering care to alleviate mental, emotional, and physical symptoms for those that are in their last moments of life. His enriching novel discusses these concepts; it is a helpful tool for those that are dying, or for their loved ones facing the reality of the impending death, and for those that have lost a loved one. The cover of the book states that it is “A book about living.” Before I started reading it, I kept thinking, “How could this be a book about living?” when clearly the author had his interests for caring for the ill and dying. Would he not be writing a novel about how to come to terms about dying? I was definitely wrong in my assumption.

    Read More

  • Diane Ravitch's The Essentials Of A Good Education

    829 Words  | 2 Pages

    The ability for all children from varying walks of life to receive a well-rounded education in America has become nothing more than a myth. In excerpt “The Essentials of a Good Education”, Diane Ravitch argues the government’s fanatical obsession with data based on test scores has ruined the education system across the country (107). In their eyes, students have faded from their eyes as individual hopefully, creative and full of spirit, and have become statistics on a data sheet, percentages on a pie chart, and numbers calculated to show the intelligence they have from filling out bubbles in a booklet. In order for schools to be able to provide a liberal education, they need the proper funding, which comes from the testing.

    Read More

  • A Few Keys To All Success By Jim Muncy

    718 Words  | 2 Pages

    A Few Keys to All Success by Jim Muncy, published in 2002 explains that there are 7 universal keys to success that we can relate to everyday life. Discernment, Optimism, Responsibility, Initiative, Perseverance, Purpose, Sacrifice. Each one represents how we grow and teaches us how to have a high quality of life. From reading this book I am confident because I know being normal means being average and what we do can change how we act significantly. Also we can’t let the world hold us back from greatness. There will be negativity, there will be those who lack enthusiasm but you can’t let them interfere in what you have in store. And these keys will help you get to that point in your life. Discernment; Judge the seed by the harvest. The first

    Read More

  • The Essentials Of A Good Education Summary

    307 Words  | 1 Pages

    In Diane Ravitch essay “The Essentials of a Good Education,” argues about testing students in schools on basic skills that led to many public schools to abandon the importance of social skills and life choices. In her essay, it states that the federal law has demanded that all students must be proficient in mathematics and reading and that every state has been required to test those two specific subjects. Why do they demand that we are tested on mathematics and reading? Well in our lifetime, we will have to know how to do the math and also have reading skills for our career jobs. In the “No Child Left Behind” was an act in 2001 passed by congress that requires states to test children’s basic skills to qualify for federal funding. All students

    Read More

  • Preferentism And Self Sacrifice

    955 Words  | 2 Pages

    In moral philosophy, preferentism - or desire satisfactionism - is the idea that the fulfilment of preferences is the sole basic bearer of intrinsic goodness, and the frustration of preferences is the sole basic bearer of intrinsic badness. Simply, getting what you desire most is good, not getting that is bad. The source of value is not the pleasure gained by getting what you want; rather the fulfilment of the desire as an end in itself. This view came about as an alternative to traditional hedonism, especially after Nozick's Experience Machine showed that most people would not choose not to be most efficiently pleasured through the machine, and therefore we should look to things other than pleasure as sources of value.

    Read More

  • Epicurus Letter To Herodotus

    1350 Words  | 3 Pages

    Every person in the world wants to be happy and what makes us happy? Well that would be pleasure. Pleasure is a feeling of happiness and satisfaction physically through our body and mentality in our mind. Everyone in the world will do anything for pleasure no matter what it is. But should every pleasure we seek be desired because not everything is free, but comes with a price? Is pleasure going to be our most important goal in life? Well to answer those questions, you should read Letter to Herodotus by Epicurus, who is a philosopher, and maybe he could answer that question. Epicurus will tell us how to live a full and successful life. Epicurus made Epicureanism where we will learn the important of pleasure and the decision that we made that will lead to happiness or the destruction of

    Read More

  • Objective List Theory Essay

    911 Words  | 2 Pages

    From this one could say it is actually difficult to determine if one’s life is good or better than another’s life. As you look at the theory of Quantitative Hedonism, the presence of pleasure and absence of pain are the only aspects that can determine an intrinsically good life. To further explain this idea, I will use the example of the deceived business man. A businessman believed that his life was good and he experienced plenty of pleasure in his life to make his life good, so since that’s what he thought, it was true to him. However, behind the aspects of just how he felt about himself and his life, in actuality his wife was cheating on him and someone was stealing from him. Therefore, making it evident that his life was not good. Nonetheless, after you look at it from the Objective List Theory, the view on the man’s life and situation alters. From an outer look of this theory, the average observer would say that he really hasn’t achieved anything in his life. He is letting other people run his life because of the way he views his values and well - being, therefore, resulting in him being cheated on and deceived by the people around him and consequently takes away his freedom and knowledge of his own life. He becomes unaware of the circumstances he is in as well as the people he is associated himself with and

    Read More

  • Does Personality Correlate With Subjective Well-Being?

    1331 Words  | 3 Pages

    ... ultimate goal that guides individual choices, particularly those traits that lead to positive affect, which then will increase the subjective well-being of an individual. Having a high well-being is an important concept within our lives because it allows us to see a purpose of our lives and it provides a means of evaluating our own lives.

    Read More

  • True Happiness In Brave New World, By Aldous Huxley

    1524 Words  | 4 Pages

    Happiness is a trait that has definitely lost its true meaning due to superficial, materialistic extravagances. Society today has created an image of what happiness entails, and now there are many different ways to try to achieve that image. However, the question then becomes: is happiness, as a result of things like sex, drugs, consumption, real happiness? Is it better to feel fake happiness than to experience the drudgeries that come with living a sober life? In the novel, Brave New World, by Aldous Huxley, the whole society is built off of a precedent of fake happiness. The people take drugs to cover up their true feelings and individuality. Citizens are supposed to feel content with their lives and the society around them. In both the brave

    Read More

  • Does Money Buy Happiness?, by Don Peck and Ross Douthat

    1373 Words  | 3 Pages

    Erika’s sweet sixteen is today, and her parents bought her a brand new car. She pulls into the school’s parking lot and flaunts about how her parents not only got her a car, but also a trip to Italy. People start to walk away, even some of her best friends. As the day goes on, her friends have not talked to her since morning. Fed up, Erika asks them what is wrong. Kristie, one of her friends, tells her how they cannot stand listening to her talk about her ostentatious gifts anymore. When Erika gets home from school, her mom asks her what is wrong. It is then she realizes what her friends were trying to say and tells her mother she does not want the car anymore. Her mother, astounded, asks why not and gets a reply of money cannot buy friends, nor can it buy happiness. According to “Does Money Buy Happiness,” by Don Peck and Ross Douthat, they disagree with the connection between money and happiness.

    Read More

  • Response to Richard Kraut’s Desire and the Human Good

    1622 Words  | 4 Pages

    Desire Satisfaction Theory states that: a life goes best if and only if desires for that life are satisfied. The variability of desires from person to person, along with Desire Satisfaction Theory, makes it possible to have many types of lifes that are different yet all of them making the life of anyone who desire to live them go well; for example if someone desires to make a living as an engineer, the fulfillment of that desire makes his life go best, and at the same time another person who desires to write music would be better off studying music rather than engineering.

    Read More

  • The stoics : on happiness and self control

    913 Words  | 2 Pages

    We place an enormous value on our happiness. .For centuries mankind has been on a philosophical quest to find happiness. Arristippus ancient philosopher, and founder of hedonism the school of philosophy, echoed this sentiment when he said "the art of life lies in taking in pleasures as they pass." Arristippus concluded that the ultimate telos or goal for humans is happiness derived from pleasure. pleasure seekers by nature; we actively seek pleasurable experiences. Conversely we run away from the bad and the painful ones.

    Read More

  • Intrinsic And Extrinsic Motivation Research Paper

    653 Words  | 2 Pages

    Optimal Functioning and Well-Being: Leads to greater self-esteem and higher psychological well-being and higher quality interpersonal relationships. Greater subjective vitality, less anxiety and depression. Pursuing intrinsic life goals is associated with self-actualisation.

    Read More

  • Happiness is good life

    814 Words  | 2 Pages

    ...f being satisfied in life: There is no rule. Each individual has the right to look at things from his own point of view. We can all choose different paths and ways to fulfill our happiness. We can see it in wealth, in the dream-job, or in the people around us. As long as we choose that direction and take those decisions by ourselves, without being influenced by any external thought, happiness is inevitable. Here, I agree with Daniel Gilbert when he said “I don't think that's the problem. The problem is you can't always know what you want.” That is why the most important thing for happiness to be achieved is recognizing our wants and desires because just when we do, we will finally get to say “I am happy with my life!”

    Read More

More about The Best Things In Life: A Guide To What Really Matters By Thomas Hurka

Open Document