Text Connection To Nikolai Popov's Why?

1362 Words3 Pages

Virtually everyone has started a fight but has ended up being the victim or have whatever was fought for ruined. The story “Why?” by Nikolai Popov is a wordless picture book that allows the reader to understand the story in several different ways. Different readers would read this book differently based on the diverse experiences they have had. Better connections to a book or story allow better comprehension. Making these connections however, require acknowledging themes of a story so better connections are made to help comprehend them. The book “Why?” along with all other books has themes that almost any reader can interpret easily. For example, war and jealousy. At first, the rat seems to be jealous of the frog with its flower and the rat …show more content…

An example of a possible text to text connection to “Why?” is a part of “The Land of Stories” series. In a section of the series, the main characters who are twins are able to travel to a magical world named “The Land of Stories” through a book thanks to their father from the magical world and their mother from the “regular” world. One twin claims to have seen their dead father while protecting The Land of Stories from being destroyed. The twins follow their “dead dad’s” path and find out that he is actually their uncle. The uncle’s older brother (the twins dad) had always been the “better” child and ha had always been jealous. So one day, he decided that everyday he lived for was for the day that he destroyed the Land of Stories including his mother, the fairy godmother who had taken away his magic once she found out his plan. Instead of him getting what he wanted, he was left without any real friends or family and started regretting his decision when it was too late. This can connect to “Why?” because just like the twin’s uncle, the rat was jealous of the frog for it’s flower and after a fight for the flower, the rat soon was left with virtually …show more content…

Many people may take their connections and what they assume the themes of “Why?” are and agree that the main idea of the story is that fighting does not solve anything. In fact, fighting usually ends with what was fought for, being broken, ruined, or just not worth the fighting anymore. The rat seems to have wanted the frogs flower, but because of knowing the feeling of wanting what someone else has, even when there are many of the same around, many people understood that the rat just didn’t want the other flowers, even if it was silly of the rat to think so. The rat however, didn’t think to use any other options such as politely communicating to possibly share the flower, and decided to attack the frog, eventually starting what seems to be a war. The war did not solve anything and ended off with the rat and the frog alone in a state worse than how they started off

Open Document