In the article, “Why Video games can never be art”, Ebert makes it clear that he strongly sticks by the his opinion that video games are not art. Ebert starts his article off by referring to a TED talk by Kellee Santiago where she states that video games are art but no one has been able to find a game that is even eligible to be compared on the same level as work from novelists or poets (Ebert). She continues by comparing video games and chicken scratches from cave drawing saying the two were on the same level but as they evolved they turned into an art form, helping Ebert’s point. As the drawings progressed and were being called art questions arose over whether sports should be considered art too. Some definitions say that art is appealing …show more content…
Ebert believes that video games are not a form of art because they do not have the same characteristics such as rules and objectives compared to plays or films which are considered art. In addition, he adds that video games are not art because they result in a winner, unlike books and plays, which have climaxes and storylines in which they follow, which is one of Ebert’s main points (Chayka). Ebert believes that no video game is worth playing because they are and will never be considered an art form. In response to that the author argues that video games follow a storyline in order to win the game much like a book. Video games can offer just as much realization, experiences, and fantasy, for instance, “ Super Mario 64 is as much of a world to me as that created in The Godfather, with as much directorial vision as Coppola (Chayka).” Personally Chayka believes that a video game like Super Mario can be held up to the same standards as some books. Chayka believes that video games are more than just games, they have many of the same characteristics that books or films have. Chayka emphasized that Ebert failed to compare video games to art and should take into consideration how video games measure up to
He claims that, “They taught me how to tell stories, create worlds and even how to save and spend money.” Different games can provide different sets of values that children can pick up. Bergman conveys that because of video games, he found his career path, which is programming, and that is how he ended up where he is today. Bergman’s use of his own family and lightening the constraints was a good example. But, it was only good for his family.
The author primarily appeals to the audience using logos. He brings statistics and data from research studies throughout the essay. He either provides background information on why the studies are misleading or just presents a fact. For instance, “According to a 2001 U.S. Surgeon General 's report, the strongest risk factors for school shootings centered on mental stability and the quality of home life, not media exposure” (Jenkins, “Reality Bytes: Eight Myths About Video Games Debunked”). He provides data like this through the essay. He is strongly trying to appeal to the audience’s sense of logic and
It is often believed that children are better off spending more time reading books and less time zoning out in front of their video games. People claim that video games sanction and promote aggression and violent responses to conflict; and that most games are an immense waste of time. Steven Johnson, the author of “Why Games Are Good for You,” appreciates the virtues of reading books, but argues that playing video games may not be a complete waste of time. His purpose for writing this essay is to explain the impact of cybertechnology on human perception and communication, in which he defends the value of computer games. In his essay, Johnson fluctuates between the pros and cons of reading versus gaming to appeal to skeptics who believe video
Tavinor’s article argues that video games should be categorized as art. He outlines competition as one of the reasons that people to object to including games as an art form. However, competing does not take away from the aesthetic value of the game, and like Tavenor stated, if someone were to submit a poem into a contest no one would think twice about considering that art. When does competition start? If someone makes a painting with an intent to make something prettier than their brother has, would that be considered art? I think that competition is not a factor. There are marvelous aesthetics in Spec Ops that I doubt anyone can not call art if they have seen the game. Art has a long history of breaking through molds and forcing people to see concepts differently. Spec Ops broke the mold of what I assumed war video games could be and made me see the complexity of war differently. It made me asks questions I never thought to produce before, which I think is one of the most valuable aspects of art. As The New Art of Video Games states, these works engage with their audiences differently by using a narrative and letting their decisions change the outcomes. It may be a unique form of art because of its roots in technology, but that is no reason to reject it. One question did stick with me as a result of playing this game. At the end, a soldier asked how we survived
In pages 20-24 of Reality Is Broken: Why Games Make Us Better and How They Can Change the World, I agree that there are many different video games. For me, I am a fan of single-player games with story modes because I can play by myself and go at a pace that suits me. However, I enjoy playing online multiplayer when I have friends I can play with because it is fun interacting with friends and doing stuff together. I play on a console or my computer, but I have played on my phone and a hand-held device. I have not played a board game or card game in a while, but I would play it if the opportunity presents itself. The video games genres I play are sports, action, and adventure. I agree with Jane McGonigal that video games share four defining traits,
Video games have become a hot topic recently. There have been a lot of controversy over whether to play or not to play. The controversy is due to them being arguably more captivating than all other forms of entertainment. Video games narrate an epic tale like no other form of entertainment can. You can become immersed in video games, because of this they are both a highly entertaining escape from the real world and a complete waste of time.
In the essay “Who Framed Roger Ebert?” (291), Rich Stanton explains Roger Ebert’s comments on video games and why he himself considers video games to be a form of art. He establishes that the comments made by Roger Ebert are opposing the idea that video games are a form of art. Then he gives examples of others that either agree with Ebert and believe that video games are not a form of art or disagree with Ebert and believe that games are indeed a form of art. Stanton believes that there are many problems with Ebert’s arguments and finishes with “It's bunk - Ebert doesn't know about games, which is fine, and there this should have ended” (292). He goes on to describe the amount of reaction from Ebert’s comments many from games media outlets
Presented in an actual art exhibit, video games must have some artistic place in the world if they are put into the the renowned Smithsonian Art Museum in the United States. As a public coordinator for the Smithsonian American Art Museum, Laurel Fehrenbach interviews composer Austin Wintory in the article, “The Art of Video Games: The Music.” According to Wintory, who composed the video games Journey and flOw, “Scenes can be built around it (music) and it can add subtext through means only accessible to music.” By this, Austin tells us that much of a video game can revolve around the music and how it adds to the overall mood of the person playing the game. For instance, if the game being played is a creepy or eerie type, the kind of music that should be played should be lower noted strings with a dark sound to it. Getting to how easy it is to put a sound to a game in the twenty first century, music in the gaming industry has come a long way from what it was twenty years ago. Mentioned by Wintory, instead of the chopped sound of the 80s, today’s games can include very sophisticated composed works that require a professional musician, like orchestra pieces. The art in a video game is very important, even more than the music. One gaming company tells how ideas come together as art in a video game in the article, “The People Behind the Video
In the video game Enter the Matrix, released in 2003, the players take on the role of supporting characters in the film sequel Matrix Reloaded. They play the side stories; those that not appear on screen in the film. The game is inspired by the world that is depicted in the film. Enter the Matrix displays distinct visual parallel between the film and the video game. The overlook of the film and video game is similar and distinguishable because the video game mimics the visual style of the film. It gets players satisfied with their purchase of the game. Playing the game is a different experience for the players because it connects them with the source material. It allows them to be part of the story and to feel to be the character of their franchise. Players are considered spectators too because there are some cinematic cut scenes that are shown in the game which makes them observe and do n...
3. “Video Games” by Chris Jozefowics. Published by Gareth Stevens Publishing 2010. Pleasantville, NY 10570-70000 USA. Produced by Editorials Directions Inc.
Video games are no longer the uprising form of media that ill informed parents and scientists used to fear; video games are now an established form of entertainment that is just as universally accepted as film or literature. The difference between videogames and mediums like film and literature is that they do not have the higher value that books have in exercising the mind and communicating information, nor do they have the value that films have to intellectually challenge an audience and to make people think. This is the general argument that can be heard voiced by leading intellectuals in various field as well as parents who are rising young children; both claim that videogames
We should develop games that people want to spend time on that are also educational, increasing the attention span of people, visual acuity, and multitasking abilities of all generations. The author very effectively portrays her message of by connecting with her audience charismatically, visually, personally, and logically. In the age of technology we must come to terms with the changing hobbies and daily activities around us. Rather than passing them off as bad campaigning for them to be cut back, censored, we should be focusing on the good that is already done by video games and how we could continue to improve
From Mark Twain to Vincent van Gogh, each genre of art comes with its greatest master. There are many compelling arguments to why this specific artist, musician or writer is the best in their category. In modern days, we don’t have a Mozart, or a Hemingway or even an Andy Warhol. There are many good artists of their own kind and many more are emerging thanks to new technology and new forms of media art. However, many arguments are made as to why these forms of art aren’t considered true forms of art. A few years back and even today, many argue that digital paintings aren’t real art so it is not surprising when people don’t think of a video game as an art form, but it is. The world is at constant change and so is art.
Video game have been claimed as addictive, a waste of time, and a distraction. While this does apply to some people, others have found the benefits to playing video games. These benefits include simulating working environments, helping people escape working environments, and giving great experiences. Although these benefits seems to be beneficial, it still stands that video games are a waste of time in which other things can be more productive.
Movies and video games today, play a significant role in shaping the attitudes, thoughts, and beliefs of society. In terms of being more influential on its particular audience, video games are a much more potent medium of entertainment than movies for a variety of reasons. The influence video games have on their participant are very obvious and overwhelming. Study’s concur the overall impact of video games on their audience is substantial when comparing them to movies. Video games have a substantial influence on its audience because video games are increasing violent behavior of the player, contain more violent content and a deeper complex plot, and video games require a much deeper lever of engagement of the player.