Should doctors be working more than a 24 hour shift? Before, 1st year residents were only allowed to work 16 hour shifts a week. But come July 1st, all first year residents will be allowed to work as long as they want. Doctors should not work more than 24 hours a week, because they are sleep deprived, have defective motor skills, and poor memory.
Doctors should not be working more than 24 hour shifts. Jodie Marks, a Nurse at a hospital in Houston said, “After working 24 hours most of us are usually exhausted”(Marks Interview). 5% of doctors prefer working 40 hours a week rather than, the regular 16 hours that most doctors are required to work. This shows that most doctors will keep going even though they are tired and exhausted. Even though
…show more content…
Jodie, as a nurse, said “If some doctors are too tired, they will make mistakes that can’t be fixed”(Marks Interview). When on the job, most doctors and nurses(34.5%), can’t help falling asleep. After working so long and hard, they must force themselves to keep their eyes open. They must force themselves to get up and keep moving. But when a doctor is so tired, mistakes are made. These mistake can’t be fixed. They can also terribly damage the patient or even kill them.
Most people tend to believe that, doctors and nurses don’t need the sleep that they deserve. While I agree with the view that patients should have the doctors full attention, I disagree with the view that doctors should be working more than 24 hours. As recent research has shown, that the more hours doctors work, the more sleep deprived they become. “We know sleep-deprived people can have impaired motor skills and their memory can deteriorate, said Dr. Michael A. Carome, director of health research at Public Citizen, an advocacy group.” This shows that doctors need sleep just as much as as we do. If they don’t get the full sleep that they deserve, thing could end up going terribly wrong. For example, if a doctors is too sleep deprived, they could end up killing the patient that they were operating on.”After a patient named Libby Zion died under the care of residents in a New York
The first way effective nurses can compensate for a doctor’s deficits is by meeting the physical needs of a patient, something doctors
Inadequate rest which results in fatigue has major implications on the health and safety of registered nurses and can compromise patient care. Nurses often work three to four 12 hour shift a week without taking any breaks while on duty. They often have difficult workloads and challenges which can take a toll and impact patient care. I will be taking a look at nurse fatigue and the impact it has on the nurse’s wellbeing, work, and patient care.
Overall, 12 hours may seem long but it is relatively productive for a week. Nurses who work 12 hour shifts and being able to do something they like are more likely to want to work for 12 hours. They find it flexible and balance between work and families. It is a duty to the heart to help those in need if it requires more time. It is similar to anyone who really works hard to get better results. Nurses work hard to get to where they are now and therefore should have the right to choose 12 hour shifts. It is important for nurses to understand that all jobs have negative outcomes, but as long as they make the choice to maintain the level of their health and sleep by taking breaks and adequate exercise. They can further be energized in helping patients and finding work more effectively.
Over the past several years extended work shifts and overtime has increased among nurses in the hospital setting due to the shortage of nurses. Errors significantly increase and patient safety can be compromised when nurses work past a twelve hour shift or more than 40 hours a week. Hazardous conditions are created when the patient acuity is high, combined with nurse shortages, and a rapid rate of admissions and discharges. Many nurses today are not able to take regularly scheduled breaks due to the patient work load. On units where nurses are allowed to self-schedule, sixteen and twenty-four hour shifts are becoming more common, which does not allow for time to recover between shifts. Currently there are no state or federal regulations that restrict nurses from working excessive hours or mandatory overtime to cover vacancies. This practice by nurses is controversial and potentially dangerous to patients (Rogers, Hwang, Scott, Aiken, & Dinges, 2004). Burnout, job dissatisfaction, and stress could be alleviated if the proper staffing levels are in place with regards to patient care. Studies indicate that the higher the nurse-patient ratio, the worse the outcome will be. Nurse Manager’s need to be aware of the adverse reactions that can occur from nurses working overtime and limits should be established (Ford, 2013).
A considerable amount of literature has been published on the impact of working hours (8 vs. 12 hour shifts) on fatigue among the nurses. These studies revealed that twelve-hour shifts increase the risk of fatigue, reduce the level of alertness and performance, and therefore reduce the safety aspect compared to eight-hour shifts (Mitchell and Williamson, 1997; Dorrian et al., 2006; Dembe et al., 2009; Tasto et al., 1978). Mills et al. (1982) found that the risk of fatigues and performance errors are associated with the 12-hour shifts. Beside this, Jostone et al. (2002) revealed that nurses who are working for long hours are providing hasty performance with increased possibility of errors.
This article has shown me that new strategies are needed to reduce sleep disturbances, improve sleep quality, and support the need for supplemental daytime sleep in hospitalized individuals. These strategies include monitoring patients’ sleep and assess quality of sleep and duration, resolving the problems of sleep disturbance, recognizing that nighttime noise, light, and other factors potentially interfere with patient sleep, minimize lighting in shared patient rooms and turn off lights earlier at night, frequently assess for pain and administer prescribed pain medications to minimize sleep disruption. This article taught me more about sleep cycles and disturbances in hospitalized patients. As a future nurse, I have to accurately assess the patients’ personal characteristics and health education needs, and share this knowledge with my classmates.
The Council of Pediatric Specialties gives a look into what an average work week looks like for Pediatric Oncologists. “The majority of pediatric Hematologist/Oncologists work more than 40 hours per week and hence those considering this career should be prepared for hard work both during training and beyond” (CoPS). The hours worked will, of course, depend on the number of patients a doctor needs to see in a day and the amount of home calls a certain physician gets for patient
Stimpfel, A.W., Sloane, D.M., & Aiken, L.H. (2012). The longer the shifts for hospital nurse the higher the levels of burnout and patient dissatisfaction. Health Affairs, 31(11), 2501-2509.
It is my position and with no doubt many other nursing positions that Ohio lawmakers need to pass laws to stop this mandatory overtime practice for nurses in the state. Failing to do so, Ohio will continue leaving both the nurses and the patients at risk. The cost of any mistakes or medical errors resulted from nurses’ fatigue and tiredness can be unprecedented. We need action now, to protect the patient as well as our staff nurse in the state of Ohio.
...ork shifts depending on their ability. In addition, it is important for nurses to understand that it is their ethical responsibility to only practice when they are fit to do so. Moreover, nurses should take responsibility for self care and take adequate time to rest and recover after shifts. In general, nurses should be aware of their mental and physical capabilities and only work when they are well enough to do so.
After a long while of looking at small tools and a lack of sleep, a nurse’s eyes can be weary, just like anyone else. Nurses need rest just as much, if not more than, the rest of the general population. There are only twenty four hours in a day and if one works for a twelve hour shift it does not leave much room to enjoy family or have a social life. Because of this, nurses are often sleep deprived and they find alternative sources of escape. Some of the so called sources or coping mechanisms are medicinal. Nurses have a good knowledge of medications and their side effects, so one might think they would be confident in taking drugs they provide their patients on a regular basis; however, many nurses use that knowledge to abuse these medications. They may take some from work instead of giving their patients their full dose and may overdose on those drugs to escape the stresses of daily
According to Wilson (2005), sleep deprivation can cause not only traffic accidents, but also medical conditions such as: obesity, type 2 diabetes, metabo...
Notably, having higher proportions of nurses working shorter shifts—8–9 hours or 10–11 hours—resulted in decreases in patient dissatisfaction” (Stimpfel et al.). This is essentially saying that the longer the shift length, the more negative outcomes result. This study proves that eight to nine-hour shifts are more effective, and should, in turn, be worked more than longer shifts. This is a problem because hospitals are likely to continue to schedule nurses for twelve hours shifts out of
Working in a fast-paced environment and being on their feet can really take a toll on a person. In addition they have to be prepared for anything to happen during their shift. A study of overworked and stressed nurses found that nurses are overworked suffered from physical sickness like type two diabetes (Stress and overworked 2006). For most nurses, their work week consists of more than sixty hours. Working that many hours can double their chances of sicknesses. When they compare the working week hours of nurses who worked the normal 21 to 40 hours with those that work more than 40 or 60 hours a week, they found that in comparison the ones who worked 40 hours or more a week increased the risk by almost 50 percent for type 2 diabetes (Stress and overwork 2006). If nurses were to work their normal work hours without mandatory overtime, then their health would improve.
When hospitals do not have enough staff to care for patients, nurses are required to work overtime and because of that, 50% of nurses quit their job (Martin). This is not healthy for nurses and not safe for patients because if nurses are constantly working overtime, they can become tired and dissatisfied with their job. Moreover, when nurses are dissatisfied with their job because of always working overtime, it lead nurses to quit their job which can become a problem for hospitals because it is hard to keep training new nurses all the time. This can cost money and effort. In addition, it will affect patients because it nurses are tired from working overtime, quality of care for patients can suffer. According to Sung-Heui Bae, author of “Nursing Overtime: Why, How Much, and Under What Working Conditions?”, When a nurse works for over 12 hours or more than 60 hours a week, nurses are more prone to making medical errors which can compromise a patient’s safety (Bae). Like what Fackelmann says, “Overworked nurse may not get to a patient quickly enough to catch a subtle sign of a potentially deadly complication”. This can be one of the reason of 20,000 death of patients each year because of overworked nurses