Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Grammar Translation Method - Advantages & Disadvantages
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
According to Rogers et al. (1986) Grammar translation method of second language teaching is one of the most traditional method. This method was originally associated with the teaching of Latin and Greek. Basically its significance is on translating language to the opposite, during the practice of this technique learners have no difficulties to grasp the lesson because it is meted out in the mother tongue. Additionally, this method is labor saving because the teacher carries out all the lessons in the native language.
This method enhances with the cognitive theory because it supports technical learning. in this method, understanding of the language is more important than, the language itself explicit grammatical explanations. The rules are
…show more content…
The good part about this method is that it is good at “teaching about the language”, not “teaching the language”. Speaking or any kind of spontaneous creative output was missing from the curriculum. Students lacked an active role in the classroom. Very little attention is paid to communication and translation is sometimes misleading. However, I reject this method because it focuses on competence not performance, it does not take into account how learners perform.
• Direct method
The main focus of this method is on good communication, with spontaneous use of the language, no translation, and little grammar analysis. The direct method is based on the direct involvement of the student when speaking and listening to the foreign language in common everyday situations. The focus of the lessons is on good pronunciation, often introducing learners to phonetic symbols before they see standard writing examples.
In his book, R. Brown (1994:56) explains that the direct method wasn’t successful in public schools because of “constraints of budget, classroom size, time, and teacher background (native speakers or native like fluency) made such a method difficult to
…show more content…
It rejects the use of the mother tongue and both stress that speaking and listening competences preceded reading and writing competences. According to Lake 2013, the audio-lingual method typically includes drills and pattern repetition. There are four parts to this method: Repetition (the students repeat what the teacher says. Inflection (the teacher says a word; the students say another form of one of the words back to the teacher. Replacement (the teacher says a sentence and the students replace one of the words for a different word) and Restatement in which the teacher says a sentence and the students rephrase the sentence. This method uses dialogues as the chief means of presenting the language and stresses certain practise techniques such as pattern drills, mimicry. Listening and speaking were brought right to the centre of the stage in this
The teacher will evaluate the students’ comprehension of the lesson through the participation of the students in the class discussion, the quality of student responses to the paired translation exercise, and from the homework of the remaining passages to translate which were not discussed in class.
In the article, “Current Developments in Research on the Teaching of Grammar” by Hossein Nassaji and Sandra Fotos two main issues had been discussed. The first one is whether grammar teaching make any differences to language learning where the questions raised are whether grammar should be taught or not. The second issue is what kinds of grammar teaching have been suggested to facilitate second language learning. If grammar should be taught, how much and should it be implicit or explicit grammar teaching? Lastly, the article discussed on the current approaches to grammar teaching in which formal instruction can be integrated with communicative activities which are processing instruction, interactional feedback, textual enhancement, task-based
The author of this article stakes out a clear and insightful position on this educational issue and follows the specific instructions by presenting reasons to support that position. The article cogently argues that a corrective feedback can make learners reluctant to speak but it is necessary for developing fluency, accuracy and complexity . We need to develop a real speaking skill in our students. However, we can find problems that have been developed because of the usage of methodologies with very limited linguistic resources like, for example, CTL (Communicative Language Teaching) because they aren't based in a real teaching and content. Actually we have to call for more creative speaking and thinking, not less.
...e language classrooms students typically score higher on standardized testing, they develop vocabulary, spelling, grammar, and punctuation skills as well as or better than peer’s in more traditional classrooms. Students’ in whole language classrooms read for meaning versus reading for word identification, they gain a better sense of self as readers and writers, and all around become more independent readers, writers, and learners. I have seen first-hand how whole language works. My daughter has surpassed basic curriculum requirements and expectations for reading and writing, but the most significant benefit--she is enthusiastic about reading. Margo enjoys reading and will pick up a book or write a story at any moment of any day. In her own words, Margo says “I luv makn piktrs but I love reading books more.” She is wholeheartedly excited about reading and writing.
WORKS CITED Krashen, Stephen. The. Principles and Practice in Second Language Acquisition. New York: Pergamon Press, 2003. 1982 Omaggio, Alice C. Teaching Language in Context.
The behavioural approach is closely linked to behaviour psychology and guides the individual towards learning a language through direct interaction which people who speak the language. The natural behaviour of learning a language is linked to first listening to the language before gradually beginning to pick works, building sentences and eventually attempting conversation (Littlewood 2002). This requires for there to be a positive stimulus which keeps presenting the learning with opportunities to hear words, learn them and reply. It’s also the responsibility of the tutor of stimulator to re-enforce the individual confidence through encouragement, acknowledgement and polite corrections. The tutor or stimulus is a very important aspect linked to learning a second language but it’s also important to remember the individual must be able to bond with the educator to secure the required response while
It is known in Libya that grammar was taught deductively, by explaining basic grammar rules and practicing through a number of translation exercises whereas, the other vital skills such as writing, speaking and listening were not taken into account. Teachers followed the grammar translation techniques, which contained the translation of reading texts, and students had to translate these texts ...
Originally the method made use of lengthy dialogues, vocabulary lists and observations on grammatical points. There are four phases to the method which are firstly the introduction, secondly the active and passive concert readings; thirdly elaboration and finally production.
English language study requires learners mastering several parts including phonology, grammar, vocabulary etc. Among them, grammar studying plays an increasingly vital role in English language learning in secondary school. Generally, the traditional way of teaching involves a teacher-commanding class which teacher spent half class on the certain grammar points and using exercises to evaluate whether students fully master them. However, the old approach usually results in a class s filled with bored and exhausted students who may give wonderful result in tests but failed in communicating events. Since language functions on communicating, new teaching method should consider this purpose more than in the old days.
The concepts of CLT are about the focus of student’s needs and individual factors. It advocates several learning language principles opposed to an artificial learning theory such as ALM. As CLT draws upon several teaching methods CLT has developed into an approach rather than a method of teaching the English language. This factor alone shows the importance of CLT.
The direct method, the natural method, came as a reaction for the Grammar- Translation method because Grammar-translation method was not powerful enough for preparing students in using the target language. That reflected the purpose of creating a method that have student ready to communicate in the second language. As the Grammar-Translation allows students to participate in and use the native language of students which why they rejected this approach. After I have studied this method, I have found that it focus on spoken language rather than written language and I like its concept because spoken language is important for me or for the most language learners. That is, spoken language is used more often than written and which
Introduction Since the last few decades, exercising the skills of spoken language has been receiving high degree of attention amongst the educators. The curricula of foreign language creates the main focus on the skills of productivity by laying special emphasis over the competence of communication. Since recent times, there have been advancements within the multimedia technology that has resulted in the emergence of computer assisted language learning as a tempting option towards traditional sources in order to supplement or replace direct interaction amongst the student and the teacher. This includes the study of language at the laboratory or the self-study on the basis of audio tape (Cervatiuc, 2007).
By implementing a conversational based language approach, teachers should emphasis on communication and conversation to enable students to use the language in a comfortable atmosphere. Effective class activities should elicit responses and enhance language learning by involving students in the lesson as much as possible to encourage all language skills including listening, speaking, reading, writing, and communication. Activities should have clear and complete criteria using only English and should use many props and visual aids. Instructors are encouraged to use activities that encourage intellectual risk-taking and find ways to expand the students’ knowledge of the real world to improve their social skills and general understanding. It is imperative that teachers possess positive and effective classroom management skills and discipline students with consistency and fairness. It is just as important for instructors to show their human side by being fun but professional, punctual, and interesting while teaching and coordinating activities. Educators find that there is an increase in language retention in students when new information being introduced is associated with an action, word, or picture. Therefore, teachers are recommended to use a lot of body language while teaching a foreign language and to utilize various games to engage students to
While languages do essentially have the same building blocks, the arrangement of words can range. Some languages begin with clauses by naming a subject such as a noun, which would make it the topic of the sentence. However, other languages begin clauses with words that name the action in a specific sentence (Freeman & Freeman, 2014). For example, English syntax is different from Spanish syntax. This means that confusion may result for students whose L1 is Spanish. For example, in English “red shirt” is used, but in Spanish, the phrase is inverted to “shirt red”. This may result in non-standard syntax when Spanish learners speak or write English. Another difficulty may be faced if a student does not understand that a structured sentence is needed. A student may not see the purpose of saying “I want to get a dog” when simply the words “want dog” would suffice. The problem with this is because syntax is a part of grammar, there is a set of internalized rules that people acquire (Freeman & Freeman, 2014). Within time, students will discover that a full sentence is needed instead of just two words. However, this is something that cannot be simply taught, as a student requires this throughout time and
The Communicative Language Teaching is a method that focuses on the learning of language skills through communication. Instead of focusing on grammar and accuracy it instead places emphasis on meaning and establishing connections that can create conversations between classmates. The method hopes to provide learners with a chance to experiment using the language and in time develop accuracy and fluency in the new language. The method usually breaks down different topics into units. An example of this may be learning different locations, times, or objects.