Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Justice in antigone
Antigone sophocles and law
Essay of justice in antigone
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Greek tragedian, Sophocles once wrote in the play, Antigone, “all men make mistakes, but a good man yields when he knows his course is wrong and repairs the evil. The only crime is pride.” The play Antigone is a Greek tragedy written in 442 B.C. about the tragic hero, King Creon; he is a man who commits an ‘act of injustice’ against his niece, Antigone. Directly disobeying Creon’s decree, Antigone buries her deceased brother, Polyneices; when Creon finds out, he forgets all reason and sentences her to death. Hence, Sophocles uses Creon, the power-hungry tragic hero and betrayed father, and his foil Haemon, the strong-willed son, to develop the theme that the power of reason is stronger than the desire for control.
Sophocles introduces Haemon
…show more content…
as the strongest foil of Creon using the dialogue of both Haemon and Creon to convey their different views on leadership. When Haemon goes to Creon to cajole him not to kill Ismene and Antigone, Creon starts talking about how “[his] voice is the one voice giving orders in this City!” (596). Sophocles uses Creon’s own speech to describe him as a controlling and power-hungry man who is not easily persuaded to do anything he does not want to do. Creon’s words support that because he is king; his words, and his words alone, should be followed. Creon wants to be in control because he believes that his decisions are final, that his laws should never be disobeyed. Haemon, on the other hand, believes that more than one person should make the laws and the decisions that govern the whole of Thebes: “There are other men / Who can reason, too; and their opinions might be helpful” (546 - 547). Sophocles manipulates Haemon’s interaction with Creon which characterizes Haemon as a ‘conscience’ and a foil of Creon. Haemon is only trying to show Creon common sense, for without the support of the City there would be no King Creon. In his place, there would only be a man who has lost everything due to his need for control and power. However, Haemon’s disloyalty to Creon only leads to his release of pure anger. Haemon’s betrayal and disobedient opinion induces the portrayal of Creon’s broken-hearted anger, thus proving Haemon is Creon’s foil. Furthermore, Sophocles develops Creon as a tragic hero by conveying Haemon’s motivation to do right under the gods' watchful eyes and Creon’s desire for power and sovereign status.
When Haemon goes to see his father about Antigone’s fate, he explains to Creon how “reason is God’s crowing gift to man [...] / The reasonable thing is to learn from those who can teach” (543 - 582). Sophocles utilizes Haemon’s statement as a juxtaposition of Creon’s decision to kill Antigone. to juxtapose Creon’s opinion that his decision to kill Antigone will serve the greater good. Haemon believes that having reason is the most powerful source of control because that is how he interprets God’s words. Creon is telling Haemon about the punishment law-breakers deserve, when he reminds Haemon that “the man who knows how to obey, and that man only, / Knows how to give commands [...]” (530 - 531). Sophocles applies Creon’s words to show Creon’s need for domination and regulation. According to Creon, the people who disobey him are people that need to be controlled, and those who know obedience are the only ones who can control the wayward citizens of the City. Despite his anger and ignorance, he truly believes that he is making the right choice for the City. Therefore, Haemon and Creon’s differing opinions about law signify that Creon is a tragic hero because he believes that his decisions are the righteous …show more content…
choice. Lastly, Sophocles highlights the theme that the power of reason is stronger than the desire for control with the father/son interactions between Haemon, and tragic hero, Creon. The Messenger and Creon have just found Haemon lying with the dead Antigone in her cell: “the tears rushed to [Creon’s] eyes / And he called to him: “What have you done, child?” (964 - 965). Sophocles uses the Messenger’s own words to portray Creon and Haemon’s emotional interaction. The tables have turned and the once rational Haemon has become blinded by the death of his beloved fiance, Antigone, while the once power-driven Creon has become the voice of reason for Haemon. In the midst of seeing his son’s pain, Creon tries to show Haemon reason, but Creon’s attempts are futile and Haemon commits suicide to be with Antigone in death: “My own blind heart has brought me / From darkness to final darkness” (987 - 988). Sophocles manipulates the interactions between Haemon and Creon to further develop the theme and Creon’s character as a tragic hero. Distraught and heartbroken, Creon realizes his mistakes and gains the self-knowledge that without reason there is no semblance of control or order. Thus, Haemon and Creon’s interactions portray that having reason is what gives a ruler their power, but having too much power is what brings the downfall of the ruler and the people around him. In conclusion, using the contrasting motivations of resolute Haemon and authoritative Creon, Sophocles develops the theme that order and control cannot exist without reason and rationale.
Haemon believes that not just one person should make decisions that affect a whole city. Haemon’s disloyal views of leadership clearly act as a foil to Creon’s need for power. He also believes that Creon is not thinking clearly or reasonably in his actions to condemn Antigone. Those opinions are what lead to Creon’s exhibition of anger and insecurity, thereby beginning to develop Creon as a tragic hero. Creon’s humanity is later revealed when he is forced to watch Haemon pierce a blade through his own heart over Antigone’s dead body. Creon’s anguish represents the misfortune he experiences as a result of his actions, for he has to deal with the fact that the choices he made of free will led to the deaths of his son and his niece. In the end, Creon realizes the mistakes he made and comes to agree that having rational thought when ruling a city is the only way control and order will continue to
stand.
Through Haemon's contrasting words, actions, and ideas, Creon's character develops into a tragic hero. Creon is a person of noble stature and also has a tragic flaw of unreasonableness; which are two characteristics of a tragic hero. He is unwilling to listen to anyone's opinion except his. Haemon explains “when men speak well, it good to learn from them.” (line 819) This was a response
In these lines of the play Antigone, Haemon tries to free Antigone by reasoning with his father and the king, Creon. Creon in turn reacted poorly to this by harshly threatening to kill Antigone right in front of him- “Bring out the hateful creature; she shall die full in his sight, close at her bridegroom’s side.” (Line 760). Haemon exits the room, and Creon ends up admitting to The Chorus that they are right- Ismene did no wrong and he will let her go free, but not Antigone.
Creon's insecurity blinds his ability to direct order in his country properly. After Antigone buried Polyneices Creon felt he needed to take a strong stand or people would think he would always be lenient toward criminals. However, to achieve this Creon felt he needed to take drastic action against Antigone. He once even said to his son, Haimon, who was about to marry Antigone, "The woman dies. I suppose she'll plead family ties. Well, let her. If I permit my own family to rebel, how shall I earn the world's obedience?" (19) This quote shows that Creon feels that to prove himself to the country he needs to earn the "world's obedience".
Sophocles play titled Antigone, embellishes the opposing conflicts between Antigone who stands for the values of family, and Creon who stands for the values of state. Sophocles explores the depths of Antigone’s morality and the duty based on consequence throughout the play, as well as the practical consequences of Creon who is passionate and close-minded. Although Antigone’s moral decisions appear to be more logical and favorable than Creon’s, a personal argument would be that both characters’ decisions in society can be equally justified.
" This indicates Creon’s decision to punish Antigone was not taken kindly by the gods, but his ego wouldn't allow him to solve that as shown by Haemon, which, again, contribute to his nemesis. This proves by how Creon’s stubbornness isn't liked by the gods establishing him as a tragic
Creon's character possesses an infinite number of glitches in his personality, but his excessive pride was the root of his problems. His pride leads him to make accusations, before he considers the wise advice of others. Creon's pride also fills him not just as a king superior to the Gods, but also a man superior to women. The issue of Antigone being condemned to die becomes more than just a person who disobeys Creon; instead, the punishment is given even more eagerly, because it is a woman who disobeys a man. Creon's intelligent son warns Creon the people of Thebes sympathize with Antigone, but Creon accuses Haemon of being a "woman's slave" (line 756). Even though he is suppose to be loyal to the state and her citizens, he defensively questions if "the town [is] to tell [him] how [he] ought to rule?"(Line 734)The Theban king is too prideful to obey even the wisest of prophets, blind Teresias, insisting that "the whole crew of seers are money-mad" (line 1055). Creon finally puts his pride aside and listens to the Chorus' wise advice. It is difficult even then, and he obeys only because he fears the punishment that he might receive. "To yield [for Creon] is terrible" (line 1095) meaning to swallow his pride and admit that he is wrong is a very difficult thing for him to do. When Creon loses his wife and son, Creon's pride disappears, and he admits that he made a terrible mistake by not listening to anyone's advice.
It is clear that Creon's tragic flaw was his pride, arrogance and beliefs of a leader that cause his downfall. His downfall began when he denied the burial of Polyneices and was firm when he condemned Antigone for her objection to his law. Creon represents the laws of the land and the divine ruler of society. He remains loyal in upholding his laws and trying to overpower the laws of the gods, until the end when he realizes that the divine laws are stronger than his own. His regards for the laws of the city cause him to abandon all other beliefs. He feels that all should obey the rules set forth by him, even if other beliefs, moral or religious, state otherwise. This is proven when he says, "As long as I am King, no traitor is going to be honored with the loyal man. But whoever shows by word and deed that he is on the side of the State-he shall have my respect while he is living and my reverence when he is dead" (40).
In Antigone Creon reveals his obstinate nature and how even someone as important as a king is not invulnerable to the problems such a character flaw causes. In the beginning of Antigone the townspeople of Thebes rejoice in their new leader, “Creon,” they call, “the new man for the new day” (174). The repetition of ‘new’ shows how the city is ready to welcome Creon with open arms; this outright praise of Creon shows how highly he is regarded by his people. “You cannot know a man completely…his sense of judgment, not till he’s shown his colors…making laws” (194-197). Here Sophocles is showing the reader not to trust Creon absolutely because even if it seems that it is a new age is dawning, Creon may not be a good leader. In this passage Creon seems determined to prove that he is as strong as Oedipus and Laius to whom Thebes was extremely loyal even through tough times, he is so desperate to prove himself that soon after he sentences Antigone to death. Later, after Antigone has been captured, Creon’s own son, Haemon, comes to him saying, “don’t please, be quite so single-minded” (789). At this point Creon is being directly told of what he is doing. Haemon is someone Creon shou...
His pride and anger becomes an obstacle and he is unable to see things for what they truly are. In an excerpt from the play Creon says, “You say – why it is intolerable – say the gods could have the slightest concern for that corpse… The hero who came to burn their temples ringed with pillars… Exactly when did you last see the gods celebrating traitors (Sophocles 319-327)?” As the uncle of Polynices, Creon is ashamed and hurt that his own nephew dared to raise an army against his own birthplace. This betrayal devastates Creon, which leads to the reader’s revelation of his many flaws and his growing disgust toward others. Joseph Tomain explores whether positive law, embodied by Creon’s policies, is subject to be overridden by some form of higher law, or the God’s will that Antigone tries to obey. In this, he states that there is not a clear answer to which one supersedes the other (Tomain). However it is clear that in the midst of Creon’s hatred, he establishes a law that goes against the will of the gods and leads to the demise of the virtuous Antigone which causes the downfall of other
Attitude is everything. In Antigone by Sophocles, one of the characters makes the remark, “Think all men make mistakes, but a good man yields when he knows his course is wrong, and repairs the evil. The only crime is pride” (line 34-36 scene 5). Pride is being shown in many ways throughout the play. Sophocles emphasizes different ironies to bring out Antigone’s arrogance. Creon’s intelligence, but also to show his irresponsibility and foolishness.
He anxiously awaits the day when he can call Antigone his wife, but because she defies King Creon, she deprives him of that opportunity. At first, Haemon tries to be loyal to his father. He tells Creon that he supports his decision to execute Antigone. However, as the conversation continues, he reveals that the community members are starting to renounce Creon’s decision. As the pain of potentially losing his fiancé becomes too much, he also renounces his father’s decision, arguing that the Gods would not condone it. In an act against his father, Haemon hurries to the cave Antigone was exiled to, in hopes to save her, but instead finds her hanging from the veil she was supposed to wear on her wedding day. Instantly overwhelmed with grief, Haemon, “[bewails] the loss of his bride” (Sophocles 152). Similarly, to Ismene’s case, Haemon cannot picture himself living on Earth without Antigone by his side, and commits suicide. In Antigone’s desire to appease the Gods, she abandons her loved ones, and causes them great suffering. This could have been avoided has she not pursued her desire to bury
In conclusion, the gods and the love of her family rule Antigone’s life. Creon’s life is ruled by what he thinks is good for his country and pride. Creon did not change his mind to free Antigone until a prophet told him he would suffer horribly for his actions. However, because Creon was so stubborn for so long and did not take heed to anyone’s advice sooner, he ultimately suffers in the end, as does everyone else in the play. This was all due to a man’s lack of good judgment, his selfish pride and his stubbornness.
“They say of all women here, she least deserves the worst of deaths for her most glorious act.” (Lines 787-788) This is what Haemon said to Creon when he was telling him what the people were mumbling. He also said that they are whispering this because they don’t want Antigone’s fate, too. Haemon‘s words, actions, and ideas contrast with Creon’s character to the point of these two characters having conflicting motivations. These conflicting motivations cause the characteristics of loyalty, love, and foolishness to be highlighted within Creon’s character.
Creon of Sophocles’s Antigone, ruler of Thebes, and uncle of Antigone has a decision, to follow his emotion and divine law or the civil law. Creon is a vigorous character, who quickly changes from the stereotypical strict ruler to feeling more compassion toward his niece, Antigone. Creon rejects Antigone for her request of the burial of her brother, Polynices, which then causes a chain of reaction spinning downwards, beginning from Antigone breaking the law to the death of three family members.
“Antigone” by Sophocles is one of the most deliberated plays, due to the indefinite struggle of wrong and right, the demands between the government and family, as well as the struggles of the laws. Both Antigone and Creon have very strong justifications for their beliefs of how the law should be enforced. Antigone believes in strong moral justification for her actions, while Creon believes the law of the land is the final say because he is the primary law maker. Antigone, is driven by a strong sense of feelings and morals; she believes there is a divine law one should live by. Creon, on the other hand, believes that the law of the land is the only authority by which people should live. In Creon’s world, men have an indefinite rule over everything