The overarching research question presented for this paper is “what is the relationship between perceived social support and levels of self-esteem among Queer Black women?” The articles this paper reviews were chosen after an extensive review of literature on theories conceptualizing what it means to be queer and what it means to be a Black woman, in order to fully understand what it means to be a queer Black woman. The review is broken up into major themes. The first theme, Conceptualizing Homophobia, Heterosexism and Heteronormativity, defines heteronormativity and related terms, and also identifies the impacts of these issues. Next, Gendered Racism explores the intersection of racism and sexism. Untreated depression among Black women is …show more content…
cited as a detrimental consequence of gendered racism. Then, this paper discusses the unexplored challenges triple minorities face. Lastly, this review provides a general description of the relationship between social support and self-esteem. It concludes with an overview of the data gathered through research, and identifies an apparent knowledge gap. Conceptualizing Homophobia, Heterosexism and Heteronormativity ‘Homophobia’ is used to describe a negative disposition towards gays and lesbians. The term, also considered a psychological construct, has existed for over three decades (Blumenfeld, 2000; Fone, 2000). While a range of definitions of homophobia exist in literature, generally it refers to the irrational fear, abhorrence, and/or dislike of homosexuality and of those who engage in it. It is incredibly important to have language available to name the violence directed at lesbians and gay men, but there are several problems with the notion of ‘homophobia.’ According to Plummer (1998), these problems include: (1) it reinforces the idea of mental illness; (2) it neglects women; (3) it ignores how sexuality intersects with other vectors of oppression, namely, race, gender, and social class; (4) it directs attention away from the larger landscape of oppression of sexual minorities in general, and (5) it ignores the underlying structural and social conditions leading to sexual oppression by focusing on individuals rather than the larger social and cultural system. The significance of this inattentiveness to the underlying conditions cannot be understated. More recently the terms heterosexism and heteronormativity have appeared in academic and popular discourse. Although the terms are related, heterosexism generally refers to the belief and expectation that everyone is or should be heterosexual. Heteronormative thinking assumes that heterosexuality is the indisputable foundation of society. Essentially, heterosexuality appears as a “given”–natural, coherent, fixed, and universal (Richardson, 1996; Warner, 1993). It presumes that “heterosexuality is the original blueprint for interpersonal relations” (Richardson, 1996, p. 3). In light of the 2015 United States Supreme Court decision legalizing marriage between same sex couples, Obergefell v. Hodges, in Western political thought the heterosexual couple has come “to represent the principle of social union itself ” (Warner, 1993.) Heteronormative thinking, in theory and in practice, assumes that heterosexual experience is synonymous with human experience. The automatic notion that the heterosexual experience equates to the universal human experience renders all other forms of human sexual expression pathological, deviant, invisible, unintelligible, or written out of existence. These assumptions have detrimental impacts, and it begins at birth. For example, it is generally assumed that a child born to heterosexual parents will grow up to be heterosexual. For these reasons, the phenomena of “coming out” exists, because unless one announces that they are not heterosexual, heterosexuality is presumed. Gay identity development can be defined as the process through which an individual progresses from an assumed state of heterosexuality to an open, affirmed state of sexuality. This process has often been conceptualized in the form of linear stage theories, (e.g. Cass, 1979; Minton &McDonald, 1984; Troiden, 1979) Most of these stage models describe a similar progression that includes the following order, 1) a general sense of feeling different, 2) an awareness of same-sex feelings; a point of crisis in which an individual realizes that his or her feelings can be labeled as homosexual; and 4) an eventual acceptance and integration of ones gay or lesbian identity. While many authors have outlined differences between men and women that are apparent in gay identity development, few authors have explored how the added pressure of racism impacts these individuals. Even fewer authors have explored the intersections of sexual identity, race, and gender. Almost no literature exists exploring how each of these three identities interact with one another by specifically studying their impacts on queer Black Women. This research presents a qualitative exploration of queer Black women, the perceived support they receive, and how that support impacts their self-esteem. Gendered Racism: Unaddressed Mental Health Implications and African-American Women The term gendered racism was originally coined by sociologist Philomena Essed, and refers to simultaneous experience of both racism and sexism.
According to Essed, racism and sexism “intertwine and combine under certain conditions into one hybrid phenomenon." Essed, (1991) Pulling these -isms apart, racism is a system that gives advantages to member of a certain race, or individuals who are perceived to be a part of that race, while simultaneously giving disadvantages to individuals who are not members of that race. Sexism is a system that provides advantages and disadvantages on the basis of sex. Gendered racism differs in that it pertains specifically to racial and ethnic understandings of masculinity and femininity, as well as along gendered forms of race and ethnic discrimination. Both of these constructs make up the individual’s identity, and they intersect one another. Because people have social identities that intersect, it is important to focus on how those identities shape an individual’s experiences.
The intersection of race and gender and the experiences of discrimination and prejudice are paramount in defining and understanding the mental health of African American women (D. Brown & Keith, 2003; Canady, Bullen, HoIzman, Broman, & Tian, 2008). Behaviors seen in African American women are adaptations to a complex set of gender, generational, chronic, and extreme life stressors (hooks, 1993) and should be viewed in terms of the psychosocial and cultural factors unique to this
population. African American women's scores on the Center for Epidemiological Studies Depression Scale (Radloff, 1977) were indicative of clinical depression in a study examining the top three life events: (a) financial problems, (b) fighting among family members, and (c) personal injury (D. Brown, Ndubuisi, & Gary, 1990). The life experience of African American women also includes the high mortality rates of African American men. African American men have a shorter life expectancy than have men of other races (Wilkinson, List, Sinner, Dai, & Chodak, 2003). The psychological impact attributable to high death rates of husbands, sons, brothers, fathers, and other male family members cannot be ignored when looking at depression in African American women. To experience this higher rate of traumatic loss and grief, in all probability, jeopardizes the psychological well-being of African American women (Jenkins, 2002).
The text suggest from various studies that sexual freedom and expression is still limited. How women and men are taught to view their bodies, how they view their autonomy, how they view pleasure, and how marriage is perceived as respectability plays into the socialization of sexuality (49). These studies reminded me of the numerous reasons that many women especially black women conform to societal beliefs and limit their agency and pleasure in sexuality. These socializations of sexuality transcend into gender roles and how gender is considered in kin relationships. Robert Evans and Helen L. Evans suggest in their study Coping: Stressor and Depression among Middle Class African-American Men that men have become a critical group to understand in order to better understand the social and psychological climate of the African American community. They suggest that family issues, employment issues, environmental factors, and racism were the main causes of depression and emotional distress. Acknowledging these factors are essential to acknowledging a communities well-being. While reading numerous studies on the family structure from polygamy to motherhood to fatherhood to black female-black male relationship, I continued to consider the role that post-traumatic slave disorder takes. I so often refer back to the slavery, but I began to ask myself can we really blame everything on
The Author of this book (On our own terms: race, class, and gender in the lives of African American Women) Leith Mullings seeks to explore the modern and historical lives of African American women on the issues of race, class and gender. Mullings does this in a very analytical way using a collection of essays written and collected over a twenty five year period. The author’s systematic format best explains her point of view. The book explores issues such as family, work and health comparing and contrasting between white and black women as well as between men and women of both races.
Gender and racism are two of the main topics of “The Talk” by Dana Canedy and “What Goes Through Your Mind: On Nice Parties and Casual Racism” by Nicole Chung. Throughout their essays, Canedy and Chung prove whether it is an African-American boy or an Asian American woman, minorities face racism. Also, all types of racism such as casual racism or intended racism all are extremely hurtful, degrading to any minority. Gender has a lot to do with the severity of racism experienced. Police brutality on an African American woman happens, but is not as frequently and sever as it does to an African American man. Nicole Chung, who is Asian American believes that she has control over her own identity. When placed in an uncomfortable racist situation
Over 300 years of physical and psychological abuse has created a dilemma impacting African American communities throughout America. In Breaking the Chains of Psychological Slavery, Dr Na’im Akbar, diagnoses that “African Americans In America show symptoms of Post- traumatic stress syndrome due to inhumane conditions their ancestors have faced”. Although, Dr. Akbar, believes that being able to identify and accept a multitude of factors that contribute to what he calls “ghost of the plantation”, African Americans can began their process of internal healing.
Sexism is much like racism in a sense that it is the unequal treatment of individuals based on an ascribed characteristic; in this case, their gender. Sexism is directly related to patriarchy, the system in which males dominate females in most spheres of life (Thompson 300-301.)
Decades of research has shown us that African Americans have been depressed for hundreds of years. Although the Declaration of Independence states “All men are created equal,” that rule did not apply to African Americans. By the end of the Civil War more than 180,000 black soldiers were in the United States Military. After the Civil War, many Africa...
Often times in the black community we like to avoid talking about topics that effect us because of the fear of “scaring the community”. Hooks shows the readers of Sisters of the Yam: Black Women and Self-Recovery that we shouldn’t be worried about scaring the community and we need to inform the community to prevent them from being ignorant of the issues that are prevelant in the black community. This book allowed me to open my eyes to the issues that all African American women are facing on a day-to-day
"African American Communities and Mental Health." Mental Health America. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 May 2014. .
being black and being a woman. Scholars convey that African American women are involved in what’s called the “double threat” where membership in more than one oppressed social group results in cumulative risk outcomes (Brown 2000; Chavous et. al 2004; Childs 2005; Steele 1992; 1997). Black women may also experience stress due to unrealistic stereotypes. For example, research has revealed that black women experience “double threat” when they apply for housing from a white landlord. Results conclude that white landlords perceive black women as the “black single mother” stereotype, therefore they refuse to provide them with adequate housing (Iceland and Wilkes 2006; Roscigno et al. 2009). Black women actively seek to resist the positive and negative stereotypes for fear that embodying them will result in validation of those categorizations (Chavous et al. 2004; Fries-Britt & Griffin 2007; Rollock, Gillborn, Vincent & Ball 2011; Settles 2006; Steele 1997). Black women may not have intended to perpetuate stereotypes in the presence of others, but are subjected to social pressures to normalize these stereotypes for others and pigeonhole themselves in counteractive representations of black women (Childs 2005; Wilkins 2012). Steele (1992) described this process as “stereotype threat” which occurs when individuals perceive that negative stereotypes about their group as
During slavery, African American women were the ones that stayed home all day and cooked and cleaned for their families. These women were always told to just keep quiet and believe in God or their religious belief through everything they were going through. African American women didn’t have a voice in society so they couldn’t express their feelings like others could. This cultural aspect of African American women, just going through life and not being able to express themselves has contributed to many of the ladies suffering from depression. Depression amongst African women is very high because of past cultural experiences. African American women are one of the major groups of people that have sacristy of resources. Many times when African American women go to their doctors the doctors tend to diagnose them incorrectly or some time even give them the wrong treatment (Carrington, C. H. ,2006). African American when were always made to just deal with the problem that they were going through at the time not matter the mood they were in (Carrington, C. H.
...es are still highly stigmatized in today’s society. It seems that mothers of black/white biracials know this sentiment as they specifically use self-development racial socialization messages to help their children cope with discrimination they may face. It is made evident that not all biracials are all the same, they have different attitudes and experiences that help shape their identity. In the field of family development denying ones biracial identity can have extreme negative mental-health ramifications that can affect self-esteem and result in depression. Recent literature shows that identifying as biracial is not simple and may have its roots in labeling practices by families during childhood. Thus, more research is needed to fully understand the complexities of identity for biracial individuals in areas of their everyday life like education and employment.
It is very reasonable to conclude that research on depression of those who identify as gay, lesbian or transsexual is not accurate; there is an underreporting of people who identify as these sexual orientations because of the fear of being different. It is understood that those apart of the LGBTQ community actively hide their identity in hopes to avoid being rejected or abused (Bird, 2013). Once the reporting issue of having a smaller percentage of the actual representation of the LGBTQ population is put aside, there is evidence that highly suggests that lesbians and gay men are at higher risk for psychiatric disorders than heterosexuals (Cochran, 2001). Even after underreporting, there is still enough information to conclude that sexual discrimination can have harmful effects on the quality of life. Common factors that have been observed in lesbians and gays that can potentially increase depression during Cochran's study are anxiety and mood disorders and decreased self esteem. Cochran and her partner also noted that dissatisfaction with how one is treated beca...
Gender and race are commonly perceived as autonomous domains often seen as independent encounters which influence economic, political and social aspects of oppression. In social science research, gender, race, class, and identity are viewed as categories to be studied and measured separately. However, these categories overlap and intersect each other creating complex interactions. Feminist sociological theorists promulgate that race, gender, class, and other aspects of identity must be treated as overlapping and intersecting forms of oppression. Kimberlé Crenshaw was among the first to articulate this theory. She called the concept intersectionality. Intersectionality has emerged as a major paradigm of research in women’s studies. Patricia
Within the United States election season of 2012, we heard many of our current, and wanna-be elected leaders discussing a ‘so-called’ war on women. Coming into this years election cycle we will undoubtedly hear more of this discussion, which begs the question: Is there really a war on women in America? In America, women make up only 19% of the US Congress, 5% of the Fortune 500 C-level executives, and just 16% of the Heads of State [Nilges]. Whether it be in politics, the workplace, or through inherent speech patterns, gender bias influences opportunities afforded to both men and women. While tremendous improvement has been made within the United States over the last 3 generations, it is clearly a challenge that requires a persistent, collective effort.
1. My result for hostile sexism was between zero and one, while my score for benevolent sexism was between one and two. My scores were closest to the average female and male in England and Australia for benevolent sexism. However, my hostile sexism was very low compared to all the countries that were listed. My scores surprised me, because I did not expect my benevolent sexism score to be closest to England or Australia. More simply, I did not expect other females and males to have similar scores, so the graphs were shocking. My results were furthest from Cuba, Nigeria, and Syria. My scores for hostile and benevolent sexism were very low compared to average women and men in Nigeria, Syria, and Cuba. I was not surprised by these results, because these countries are known to practice traditional gender roles. In other words, I was not surprised that