Ethical Dilemma In The Movie: Antwone Fisher

1065 Words3 Pages

In the film Antwone Fisher (2002), we witness the evolving therapeutic relationship of a psychiatrist, Dr. Jerome Davenport, and his client, Antwone Fisher. As a member of the military, Antwone is mandated to report to therapy sessions with Dr. Davenport after an altercation with a fellow serviceman. The relationship between Antwone and Dr. Davenport evolves beyond their mandated sessions and allows for the exploration of personal issues for both individuals. As a result of this, many ethical dilemmas occur that force Dr. Davenport to make decisions both in line with and against various principle ethics. Over the course of their therapeutic relationship, Dr. Davenport violates client confidentiality as it is described by the American Counseling …show more content…

Davenport’s various violations of the Code need to be considered from another point of view as an example of responsible disobedience. As Dr. Davenport and Antwone are both members of the military, there is a certain camaraderie experienced between them that the general public does not experience. Taking this into consideration, Dr. Davenport may be expressing responsible disobedience as he violates various standards in the Code in an attempt to respect the intricacies of the military culture (Cottone & Tarvydas, 2007). Because the military is a culture of its own, it is difficult to say whether any or all of the situations that resulted in an ethical violation were justified. It is easy to say that Dr. Davenport violated principle ethics during his work with Antwone but virtue ethics may support Dr. Davenport as he interpreted the standards in the context of the military culture (Cottone & Tarvydas, 2007). Inviting Antwone to Thanksgiving dinner is a particular example of how an ethical code violation may exemplify virtue ethics. While Dr. Davenport is extending the therapeutic relationship beyond its conventional parameters, this may not appear to be so from a military context. Members of the military often consider themselves a part of the same family (Whitehouse, McQuinn, Buhrmester, & Swann). Inviting Antwone to dinner may have appeared, to Dr. Davenport, as an acceptable decision being as they were close on both a professional and familial

Show More
Related

  • Lying On The Couch Sparknotes

    1382 Words  | 3 Pages

    While reading the book Lying on the Couch by Irvin D. Yalom one would come to realize that there are ethical and legal issues that get in the way of numerous counseling sessions. The novel focuses on the struggles that any therapist can come across while working with their clients. Although with this storyline the boundaries and legal issues may have been taken to the extreme, it strongly depicts what could happen if one would choose to make unethical decisions. One must also have a sense of the true meaning of the counseling sessions

    Read More

  • Comparative Analysis of A Few Good Men

    1375 Words  | 3 Pages

    The question of why these Marines obeyed the “Code Red” may be answered by Stanley Milgram’s conclusions from his experiment on obedience. When asked by Kaffee, while...

    Read More

  • Learning Lessons from 'The Antwone Fisher Story'

    634 Words  | 2 Pages

    When I decided to watch “The Antwone Fisher Story” I wasn’t really sure what I was about to watch. I had never heard about the movie before, but I am up for watching any movie that comes my way. It had a great story about Antwone Fisher’s struggles through life and how it has affected him in present time. How can I use what I have seen in this movie in my future classroom?

    Read More

  • The United States Army as a Profession of Arms

    518 Words  | 2 Pages

    Professional Military Education schools teach the Army Ethic and evaluation reports for leaders affirm this ethic. The Army punishes individuals, especially leaders, who violate this code. The Army administratively punishes Soldiers who do not adhere to this code, and the severity of punishment increases with rank. One recent and highly visible example of this is former General Petraeus’s adultery and the subsequent professional sanctions he experienced. The Army grows its own ethical code and maintains it through the American people.

    Read More

  • A Tactical Ethic Strategic Ethic

    1447 Words  | 3 Pages

    This book has not changed my views on ethics in combat nor in garrison. In the many years I have been in the military and the over seven combat deployments, I must disagree with Mr. Couch. Instances of unethical behavior are not encouraged to the degree he thinks nor as widespread. Of course, as with any organization where people are present, there will always be outliers

    Read More

  • The Milgram Experiment: The Relationship Between Obedience And Authority

    742 Words  | 2 Pages

    In a series of experiments conducted from 1960 to 1963, American psychologist Stanley Milgram, sought to examine the relationship between obedience and authority in order to understand how Nazi doctors were able to carry out experiments on prisoners during WWII. While there are several theories about Milgram’s results, philosopher Ruwen Ogien uses the experiment as grounds for criticizing virtue ethics as a moral theory. In chapter 9 of Human Kindness and The Smell of Warm Croissant, Ogien claims that “what determines behavior is not character but other factors tied to situation” (Ogien 120). The purpose of this essay is not to interpret the results of the Milgram experiments. Instead this essay serves to argue why I am not persuaded by Ogien’s

    Read More

  • The Importance Of Accountability In The Army

    1158 Words  | 3 Pages

    The circumstance of immoral orders is understandable, but a soldier should still meet his or her given instructions. The keys to a soldier's system are the policy letters and army regulations that dictate every given bit of information on the army and its moral history. Within each article and sub-article, the information is pertinent to the success of a soldier and shares the history as well. This can provide lessons to those who instruct other soldiers.

    Read More

  • James Marion Sims: Monster or Miracle Worker?

    2946 Words  | 6 Pages

    9) Wall, L.L. (2006). The medical ethics of Dr J Marion Sims: a fresh look at the historical record. Journal of Medical Ethics, 32(6), 346-350. doi: 10.1136/jme.2005.012559

    Read More

  • Duty to Protect vs Patient Confidentiality

    602 Words  | 2 Pages

    Corey, G., Corey, M.S. & Callahan, P. (2007). Confidentiality: Ethical and legal issues. In Brooks/Cole (8th Ed.), Issues and Ethics in the Helping Professions pp. 208-264.

    Read More

  • Ladd Code Of Ethics Essay

    881 Words  | 2 Pages

    Ladd argues that attempts to make professional codes of ethics are confused about the nature of ethics (Ladd, pg 130). I will be arguing that Ladd’s thesis is not true and that the supporting arguments for his claim do not hold up. To do so, I will first be stating and explaining Ladd’s arguments for his thesis. Next, I will show why these arguments do not hold up using reasoning and counterexamples. Lastly, I will consider possible responses to my arguments from Ladd and disprove those as well.

    Read More

  • The Morally Praiseworthy Actions of Medical Professionals who Provide Care for Enemy Combatants

    1298 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many Americans assume that medical professionals are generally helpful of others. However, a controversial question has been raised about the use of medical professionals and their involvement with torturing enemy combatants during war. Is it morally right or morally wrong for them to be involved in these sorts of practices? I believe that medical professionals who are involved in overseeing and treating tortured enemy combatants are morally praiseworthy. Medical professionals are praiseworthy because its undoubtedly correct for a medical professional to help preserve the life of tortured. Furthermore, medical professionals are praiseworthy because their job description demands that they assist injured people. Lastly, I emphasize that medical professionals are correct by performing these practices because it makes the doctors patriotic. I also will address a few opposing viewpoints within my points expressed and relate back to how my points outweigh the opposition.

    Read More

  • Reflective Essay: The Role Of Ethics In The Military

    467 Words  | 1 Pages

    The military has ingrained a set of standard by setting the seven Army values, Equal Opportunity programs, and Army regulations that govern how we act during ethical dilemmas. These programs and beliefs are especially important because each Soldier comes from a different background and environment, and cannot afford to have disruptions in workplace that can put our Soldiers in the way of harm. In order to maintain a healthy environment we need to keep defining and promoting an ethical

    Read More

  • Interview with a Social Worker

    2018 Words  | 5 Pages

    Tallant, S. H., & Ryberg, R. A. (1999). Common and Unique Ethical Dilemmas Encountered by Military Social Workers. In J. G. Daley, Social Work Practice In the Military (pp. 179-204). Binghamton: Haworth Press Inc.

    Read More

  • Dual Relationships Between Counselors and Clients

    1588 Words  | 4 Pages

    Sexual relationships between counselors and clients should never ben permitted due to the power associated with the counselor’s role with clients. While ethical guidelines vary between different counseling associations as to whether it is acceptable for counselors to have sexual relationships with clients after the professional relationship has ended, in many cases these relationships continue to be prohibited. This standard is held because some believe that the powe...

    Read More

  • A Case Study of Ethics in Psychology

    1511 Words  | 4 Pages

    Koocher, G.P., & Keith-Spiegel, P. (2008). Ethics in psychology and the mental health professions. New York, NY: Oxford University Press.

    Read More

More about Ethical Dilemma In The Movie: Antwone Fisher

Open Document