Have you ever gotten a participation trophy? Think back to all of those ribbons and awards lining your shelves when you were a child. You would go to t-ball and at the end of the season, you would be handed an award for just showing up. Back then it seemed like the best thing in the world, but now, it sounds ridiculous.
The society we live in makes it normal to give out awards that have not been earned. Why should we give awards to people that haven’t earned them? People will say that we do give out unearned awards to encourage children and make sure they don’t feel left out or feel like they aren’t good enough. In reality, studies have shown that awarding children for only participation has a negative impact. Kids know when they have earned
…show more content…
something and when they have not, so awarding them (when not earned) can produce self-obsessed, irresponsible, and unmotivated children. While giving children unnecessary praise is not good for the child, they do need to be encouraged and praised for the right reasons. Children do need to have people tell them that they did a good job, but we cannot let them believe that they don’t need to try. Carol Dweck, a Stanford University professor, has warned that participation trophies are a part of a larger cultural message: to succeed, you just have to show up. The message is engrained into the minds of our children at a young age, and they don’t forget about it as they grow older.
Many people that have gotten participation trophies feel cheated when they aren’t recognized for their accomplishments. This mindset, that you will be rewarded for all accomplishments, is a stark difference from the real world. When you get a job, you will not be rewarded just for showing up. Because we continue to keep this from our children, we are robbing them from learning about what the real world is like.
In the op-ed “Losing is Good for You”, the author talks about how participation trophies can lead to narcissism and entitlement later in life. Children begin looking forward to getting a trophy at the end of a season, no matter what. This belief has kept with the children into adulthood. Now, many people feel as if they should automatically get a promotion, even if they have done nothing to earn it.
Rich Lowry, the author of the op-ed “No Trophy for You”, states that giving effort and participating should be reward enough. He goes on to tell about his Little League experience, without trophies, and how it taught him a valuable lesson: sometimes your best is not enough. Lowry saw a post from James Harrison, a NFL quarterback, that
said: I came home to find out that my boys received two trophies for nothing, participation trophies! While I am very proud of my boys for everything they do and will encourage them till the day I die, these trophies will be given back until they EARN a real trophy. I'm sorry I'm not sorry for believing that everything in life should be earned and I'm not about to raise two boys to be men by making them believe that they are entitled to something just because they tried their best...cause sometimes your best is not enough, and that should drive you to want to do better...not cry and whine until somebody gives you something to shut u up and keep you happy. This post from Harrison started a huge debate. People all over are now questioning whether or not they agree with Harrison. Some people believe that there is nothing wrong with participation trophies because they reassure all children that they matter and that they are special. This idea sounds wonderful! Who wouldn’t want to make sure their children feel good about who they are? Now, we have years of research that shows that participation trophies don’t lead to willingness to take on difficult tasks. Participation trophies lead to unhealthy self-esteem and narcissism. Now think about all of the children that get participation trophies. Think about all of the difficulties that will come later and how they are going to be unprepared for these problems. Don’t you think we should teach our children that failing is OK and nobody is perfect?
About one year ago, I played on a Pburg Liners basketball team. It was the championship game and we really wanted to win, but we did not play well, so as a result, we lost. After the game, our coach gave us all trophies. On the other hand , I was thinking, did we actually deserve them. Apparently, some people think that everyone should get a participation trophy. However, people strongly believe not everyone should get a trophy. People believe this because kids who only show up to some practices and do not try hard should definitely not get the same recognition as a person who shows up to all of the practices and works really hard. It teaches kids that young kids have to
L. Hefferman’s article “ In Defense of Participation Trophies: Why they really do teach the right values?” it states “ An award is not really an award if everyone gets it.” (Today.com) In another article by Ashley Merryman called “Losing is Good For You” it says “Awards can be a powerful motivators but nonstop recognition does not inspire children to succeed. Instead, it can cause them to underachieve.” (New York Times Sept. 2013) It is clear, by not giving participation awards it make the children who do get awarded feel more special than if everyone gets one. Obviously, not giving participation awards to everyone gives more of a boost of self-esteem to the people who do get
Our society has shifted its beliefs in how we should treat competition in young people. The question is asked, should all kids get a participation trophy? As it may seem to be an unanswerable question, it honestly isn’t. Thought that the participation trophies may send the message that “coaches” value the kids’ efforts despite their abilities, trophies do not need to be given out. Your words mean just as much when you remind an athlete that you value them in more ways than one. Some may think trophies are a great idea because it shows that everyone’s a “winner.” However, I disagree with that idea. I believe that kids should know that they need to work their hardest in order to be rewarded and understand that not
Every kid on the football field has a trophy. Even the kids who are on the losing team. Kids’ and parents’ faces are bright with smiles, and laughter echoes throughout the field. Kids are showing off their miny trophies, each with a bronze football on them. No one is paying attention to the two feet tall, gold, first place trophy that is in the winning team’s coach’s hand. Everybody is focused on the miniature trophies. Why are these trophies so special? These are participation trophies. Every kid gets one just for participatcuing in a game. Kids started getting participation trophies in the 20th Century. They got the trophies to feel more confident about themselves. Trophies should not be given to every kid because of narcissism increase,
Todays generation of kids have been crafted to expect praise for everyday tasks and have become entitled all because of something many people thought was harmless, participation trophies. If you ask anyone, they have probably recieved a participation trophy at least once in their life and some will think it was a good thing, but others may beg to differ. In my opinion participation trophies are a bad tool in life because it goes along and is a big part of the we are all winners concept. Trophies should be a symbol of accomplishing something not a symbol of participation in an activity and a few people have written about their opinion about this situation varying from critical writers, to college athletes from around the country here are
John Darns worked hard his entire soccer season for his trophy; he attended every practice, went beyond the required off season training, and always left the field knowing he left everything he possessed on there. With grass stains in his shorts and bloody scrapes on his knees, he was finally rewarded with the championship trophy, that beautiful two feet tall golden trophy with a man on top in the middle of kicking what would be a perfect goal. Yes, he wore that orange tiger on his jersey well; he truly deserved that trophy. Yet a few feet away, are The Black Hawks, the team who lost every game the entire season, getting an almost identical trophy for participating in the league. They did not work as hard: they practiced less than half as much as John’s team, and they are rewarded almost equally to make sure everyone feels like a winner. The concept that every child deserves a blue ribbon or a trophy for trying their best plagues generation Y every day of their young lives.
For example Carol Dweck, a psychology professor at Stanford University in California, said in the article “Should Everyone Get a Prize?” written by Brenda Iasevoli that, “‘The trophy has to mean something,’ Dweck told TFK. ‘If we give a trophy to everyone, then the award has no value.’” This shows how if everyone gets a prize, there is no point in getting one at all. It means nothing to have it when everybody has one as well. Additionally, Dr Michelle Anthony an author and psychologist and Karen Coffin a coach who writes about youth sports agreed in the article “Should Everyone Get a Trophy?” written by Lauren Tarshis that “... trophies can lose their meaning when everyone gets one.” This explains how it is senseless to get the trophy because it no longer means anything to the child who receives it. As a result, giving everyone a reward takes away the
This article responds to the idea of a “participation trophy” culture and whether or not it is healthy to give every child a trophy. Comparing the situation to grade inflation, both issues strongly rely on how both parents and children look at the intent and the reasons behind getting the rewards in the first place. Kelly Wallace’s article quotes the author, Ashley Merryman, by saying, "The idea was if we give kids trophies… if we tell them they're special, they'll sort of develop a sense of fearlessness … and actually we now have about 20 years of research that shows that's not true." Merryman also says, "That if you tell a kid they're wonderful and they believe you, then it just confirms their belief and that's not about healthy self-esteem,
No More Participation Trophies Think back to doing little kid sports. Everything was great. It didn’t matter if you showed up to practice, and the score never mattered. At the end of the season your coaches would hand out participation trophies. What.
When a child goes out to go play tee ball one year, let's say he does not get a participation trophy. Than the next year he tries his best works hard, but he still want that trophy so he starts yelling and being disrespectful to his teammates. That is the last thing that you want in your 7 year old, especially since he will work with peers to accomplish a goal all of his life. If you give him a trophy, the message is very clear. You did a good job and you worked hard. If you tell children this, their easily impressionable young minds will cling to the idea that hard work is rewarded. Now people say that hard work is not always rewarded, and that you do not always succeed in life by working hard,but that is false. If you are trying out for a baseball team and you get on the team but you never play,but the coach sees you out there everyday working hard and supporting your teammates, if any of your teammates get injured or can not make the games, you will be the first person they call up. Winning is fun, but having respect and working hard is
Although some people my argue that participation awards are a good thing to receive, it is evident that participation awards influence you to not try and to just give up on the sport. First of all, participation trophies can make you think you are entitled to something just because you showed up and it can lower your self esteem. According to the article against participation awards, it describes the awards to "reward the parents for signing their kid up" instead of "the childs effort and attendance." For example, the minute the child's name is written down on the paper, they will receive an award even if they don't attend any of the events. Another example, is that you get first place
Children, when they don’t get a reward, it often lowers their self-esteem. Kids who don’t get participation trophies at all are found to understand why they don’t get awards for effort and are more happy and proud of themselves when they do get an actual trophy, knowing it’s for their performance. A child once said to author of ‘Playing to Win: Raising Children in a Competitive Culture’, Hilary Levey Friedman, “Well, I purposely played in this easier one because I knew I would win and now I don’t really count that as a real victory because I knew I went in and it was below my level.” (Source #1) This proves that children do understand that trophies, given when unrequired, aren’t for them doing good.
In fact, the Merryman article states,”‘My children look forward to their trophy as much as playing the game.’ “ Giving kids these trophies is boosting their egos - and a little too much. Living rooms are simply filled with trophies from just participation in sports. Furthermore, the Merryman article shows,”In college, those who’ve grown up receiving endless rewards do the required work, but don’t see need to do it well.” These college students don’t see the need to do it well, because they have been assured their whole life that they are great at everything, even when they don’t try their best.
There are many heated debates raging in modern day America, but what is perhaps the most underrated of these debates is the topic of participation awards. Not only these awards, but more so what they represent in handouts, for lack of a better term, is what makes this such a pertinent topic. I agree, perhaps even more strongly, with Kevin Sherrington’s views expressed in his article. The overuse of participation awards amongst todays youth sports are in fact detrimental to their competitive spirit, therefore harmful to their overall ambition. Kevin Sherrington writes a very interesting article, “Kids Need to Earn Hardware,” on the uniquely timely debate of the value of participation awards.
Giving children trophies for doing nothing does not benefit their point of view on life. In the real world nothing is just given without any effort put into getting it. “... everything in life should be earned and that effort alone is not a cause for recognition” (Heffernan). The people who win need some recognition because unlike the participation winners these days, they actually worked to get their prize, not just show up.