Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Related literature on collaborative and cooperative learning
5 basic elements of cooperative learning
Advantages of cooperative learning
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
General Overview of the Cooperative and Competitive Learning Structures In this research paper I will review the learning structures of cooperative and competitive learning. These are two different methods that are used to motivate students to enhance their learning experience in the classroom. Researchers, psychologist, and educators are among the many that have been trying to figure out which strategy is most appropriate for classroom instruction. Both are widely used in today’s classrooms and each of them have positive and negative consequences for students and their learning. By deciphering through previous and current research, I will determine which method is the best. There is an abundance of research on the cooperative and competitive …show more content…
After reviewing a great deal of current research, I will now discuss what learned about the cooperative and competitive learning structures in more detail. I will differentiate between the two, providing all advantages and disadvantages of each. This will help me determine which method enhances learning most effectively.
Utilizing the Cooperative Learning Structure Research for the cooperative learning structure has demonstrated that it can really enhance a student’s achievement, attitude towards learning, and the atmosphere where learning takes place. According to Akinbobola, “Cooperative learning is a mode of learning in which students work in small groups to achieve a purpose. Here there is an emphasis on the importance of group work, students in a group help each other in learning the content, but achievement is judged individually” (2009, p.2). The cooperative learning structure encourages students to work together toward a common goal, but that common goal can only be attained if each individual reaches their
…show more content…
In this learning structure students need to be extremely familiar with the subject matter so that they are able to outwit their opponent’s knowledge level. According to Anderson, “These activities are characterized by using competition as a motivator to encourage student engagement in the learning process as they master content that is transferred to them” (Anderson, 2006, p.6). One subject area that research has found that competitive learning can be helpful with math because it promotes performance on things they have already learned (Durik & Eccles, 2006, p.
...understand the benefits of working together toward a common goal, setting aside the traditional roles of manager and subordinate and hopefully opening up the workplace as a creative outlet for all who work there.
Competition teaches cooperation, which is essential in a school environment. For example, when you have to work on a group project you have to cooperate with your group to get work done. If you get in a disagreement with a group member then your work won’t get done and your grade will suffer. In order
Learning, along with teaching, has been studied for thousands of years. Theories have been made based on those studies and are still debated to this day on the best ways to teach and how students learn. Theorist, Ernest Hilgard (1948) once said, “The science of learning remains in a state of flux, in part because we have not yet reached agreement upon the most appropriate concepts to use in stating our problems and interpreting our data.” Theories of learning are somewhat different than theories of teaching however. We look at learning as the way in which a person learns, but teaching concerns the way in which another person influences another to learn. As an educator, I find it to be essential that I study both types of theories to become
"People have to be able to work together if they are to realize the shared destiny and to preserve a habitable environment for generations to come." Albert Bandura, 1995
To always give your maximum and expand your capacity to achieve the goals. 4.- Teamwork – To look for improvements and growth as a whole. The key for teamwork is communication and always be willing to help in order to achieve goals. To keep in mind that working as a team keep everyone aligned and focused on the same vision.
Rosini B. A. (2010). The Effects of Cooperative Learning Methods on Achievement, Retention, and Attitudes of Home Economics Students in North Carolina. Journal of Vocational and Technical Education. Volume 13, (2) 33-67.
To seek a best way to structure learning runs the risk of imposing conformity on what should be a rich and diverse experience. As you can see, each theory has its positive and negative aspects, which is why I suggest a pragmatic approach that considers both the learner and the subject matter at issue and then opts for the approach -- classical/operant conditioning, social learning, cognitive, or a combination -- that best suits that particular learning experience.
Building self-esteem, enhancing student satisfaction with the learning experience, and promoting a positive attitude toward the subject matter are all benefits of collaborative learning. A higher degree of accomplishment takes place as a group because you essentially are a team. An example of this is a sports team. In a collaborative situation it takes every member to do his or her part in order for a situation to have a greater resolution; as where a sports team needs everybody’s individual talent to win a game. In retrospect, as a group; the contributions of our own talents can make the difference between a “win or Lose situation” it gives you a sense of competition, and knowing that you can win as a group; self esteem in one’s self is accentuated. Johnson and Johnson (1989), Slavin (1967). Another benefit to collaborative learning is based on the members of your group. Every individual in the group demonstrates their own input based on where they were born, what nationality they are so on and so on. The benefit of this is that you get a different perspective on things rather than always knowing what you know. You can take information from other cultures and add or apply it to what you already know.
Competition can have a huge impact on the teaching and learning of individuals in a school or university area. The students of those institutions may compete either academically or athletically. On the track, the competitors compete for the title of first place whereas in the classroom, many different students compete for an extremely high average against the entire class; there are also students that have a fixed competitor or rival. Having a rival in this sense, encourages the individual along with the rival to strive for high grades in school and to sur...
To add more, in the examination of cooperative learning with group processing, Archer-Kath et al., (1994) found that group processing with whole group feedback was less effective than group processing with individualistic feedback in increasing: (a) achievement motivation, (b) participants’ positive relationships and the quality of relationships between participants and the teacher, and; (c) self-esteem and positive attitudes toward the subject area. In sum, students achieve better and demonstrate superior learning skill if these basic elements of cooperative learning are included in cooperative learning groups (Johnson & Johnson, 2008), and experience more positive relationships among group members, and between students and the teacher, and more positive self-esteem and attitudes toward the subject area (Slavin, 2011). Once these five elements are structured in cooperative settings, the roles of the teacher and students will be changed remarkably. The teacher becomes not the “sage on the stage”, but “the guide on the side” (Johnson et al.,
Collaborative learning is an educational approach that involves groups of learners working together to reach a consensus through negotiation to solve a problem, complete a task, or create a product (Bruffee, 1993). Learning occurs through active engagement among peers, wherein the main characteristics of collaborative learning are: a common task or activity; small group learning, co-operative behaviour; interdependence; and individual responsibility and accountability (Lejeune, 2003).
Passive learning was once the go to mode of teaching students in university and college, but the method has been changing over the years to have students become more involved using active learning, as it has been found that students perform better when actively involves in their studies (Shimanzoe & Aldrich, 2010). Similarly, Wasley (2006) argues that, students that are exposed to group work while learning, and are involved in educational activities outside the classroom, earn better grades and feel more satisfied with their education. Learning theories explain that when students spend time discussing, investigating, and applying new concepts, they acquire long-lasting knowledge about the new material. This type of environment helps students
"Unity is strength. . . when there is teamwork and collaboration, wonderful things can be achieved." --Mattie
Shared Goals: ‘everyone is working towards the same result and there are no personal or hidden agendas’.