Comparing The Shoe-Horn Sonata 'And Mankind Is No Island'

832 Words2 Pages

Composers of distinctively visual texts are able to manipulate the emotions of the audience to influence the response of a collective group. This is demonstrated in John Misto’s play ‘The Shoe-Horn Sonata’ and Jason Van Genderen’s short film ‘Mankind Is No Island’ whereby distinctively visual techniques enable the audience to clearly imagine, form meaning and understand a composer’s unique perspective.

Misto’s Shoe-Horn Sonata (S-HS) demonstrates numerous heroic acts that engage the audience through distinct visuals. The play itself centres on two fictional characters, Bridie and Sheila, whose stories have been obtained from female survivors of the Prisoner of War (POW) camps. Sheila’s calm voice provides a distinctively chilling visual image …show more content…

As the audience hears the sound of crickets rising to a crescendo the suspense increases and allows the audience to experience the engaging climax. The scene ends with a dramatic representation of the two character’s separation through the use of isolated spotlights, which distinguishes that they are at opposite ends of the stage. This visual technique consequently shapes the audience’s interpretation of the two character’s relationship as reinforced by Sheila posing ‘would you have gone to the Japs for me?’ to which she receives no responses providing an emotional appeal to the audience. These heroics depicted in in S-HS consequently shape our perspective to position the reader to interpret the intended reading due to the distinct …show more content…

To convey his point, Van Genderson constructs the film through camera phone shots to force a point in reference to societies attitude of ignorance towards the homeless. A low angled shot a red heart balloon powerfully symbolises both love and hope are forfeited due to the nature of the balloon floating away. The composer carefully contrasts high-level shots against eye-level shots of the homeless to provide a distinctively biased visual image of the neglect faced by those less fortunate. We later notice the deflation of the balloon rolling along the street that indicates the fragility of hope and worthless felt by those homeless, which is reinforced by the repetition of the phrase ‘no standing’ to portray how they have nothing and societies obliviousness to this fact. The use of soft melody which transitions into a fast paced melody is carefully juxtaposed alongside the rhetorical question “when did you last see you dad, boys mother?” thus engaging the audience and evoking a sense of empathy by alluding to the family they may have once had. The way the composer complements the visual and dialogic aspects with music illustrates several interpretations of society, all which by distinctively visual techniques alter and manipulate our perspective to that of the composers

Open Document