Compare and contrast the views of Autumn in Ted Hughes’s There Came A

1600 Words4 Pages

Compare and contrast the views of Autumn in Ted Hughes’s There Came A

Day and John Keats’s Ode To Autumn. How do the poets use language

to convey these views?

There are many similarities and differences between the two autumn

poems ‘There came a day’ by Ted Hughes and ‘Ode to autumn’ by John

Keats. Both poems are based on autumn but they portray it in different

ways. ‘There came a day’ presents autumn in a negative way where as

‘ode to autumn’ presents it in a positive way. The reason that John

Keats may have written in a in a positive way about autumn is because

he was a pre-twentieth century poet and had a love for nature and

respect for the countryside. The style in which he writes is known as

‘romanticism’, which is when the poet writes from a personal view,

rather than based on facts. Ted Hughes was a twentieth century poet

and wrote in a slightly different way to John Keats. He knew a lot

about nature and was fond of animals and plants. This could explain

why he felt autumn is a harsh and ruthless season, because it

symbolises decay and the end of most plant life until spring.

We can tell from the title of John Keats’s poem ‘Ode To Autumn’ that

it is a positive poem, and obviously about autumn. The title means ‘to

praise autumn’ which implies that it is going to be about the good

aspects of the season. However, in Ted Hughes’s ‘There Came a Day’

there is a sense of anticipation and fear about the day. From the

title we cannot tell that the poem is about autumn but it is more

negative.

In the opening stanza of ‘Ode to Autumn’ the first few lines set a

bright and colourful introduction to the poem. It talks about autumn

as a season of mist and mellow fruitfulness. From this we know that it

is a...

... middle of paper ...

...rsonal tastes and styles. John Keats was a pre-twentieth

century poet, so the vocabulary used in his poem was very old

fashioned and traditional. We can tell this from the following words

and phrases “thou hast’’ and “thou dost”. Ted Hughes was a twentieth

century poet, so his writing and use of language is more modern,

phrases such as “stuff them” and “plucked it” imply that it is a more

recent poem.

The two poems have many differences and only a few similarities. I

believe there to be so many differences to be because of the different

time period that the two poets lived in because John Keats’s poem is

more traditional and Ted Hughes’s is modern. It is also because of the

different style they write in and their own personal points view about

autumn. Although I feel the similarity between the two poems is that

both poets show their individual feelings.

Open Document