Comfort Women Statue Analysis

934 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The effects of WW 2 on japan

The newspaper article entitled “Why did this statue of a little Korean girl spark outrage?” was originally published in the San-Diego Union-Tribune. The article dealt with the controversial issue of a “comfort woman” statue located in California’s Glendale Central Park. Comfort women is the euphemism used to recognize the nearly 200,000 women forced into sexual slavery during Imperial Japan’s World War II occupation of countries including Korea, China, Indonesia and the Philippines. The statue also celebrates an American victory in policy by commemorating the passing of a bill in the House to hold the Japanese government “historically responsible” for past war crimes. The challenged monument was brought to the Supreme Court to decide if it …show more content…

Some consideration should also be given to the Japanese misgivings. They for example say that the monument perpetuates a one-dimensional perspective of Japanese Americans as distinctly “un-American” in thought. In essence, it perpetuates an “us vs. them mentality”. A clear example of this is how American values are extolled by maidens such as Lady Liberty but Japanese culture in the region will only be defined by a war crime cast in bronze. The message of the statue is a clear symbol of Japanese harshness and oppression. This version of events ignores the thousands of faithful Japanese Americans who remained loyal to the U.S. throughout the war. Moreover, it hypocritically ignores how Americans captured thousands of Japanese families and placed them within internment camps. This statue in a sense highlights the convoluted and often egotistical display of American values. For example, it displays Asian women in the same similar manner of submission used to characterize Indians and African Americans. This plays into the American narrative of being the mightiest advocators of liberty. This statue though notably refuses to acknowledge how America itself went astray as a nation. History is careful to tell the truth optimistically from the point of view that is most

Show More
Related

  • Summary Of Eleanor Roosevelt's Undo The Mistake Of Internment

    306 Words  | 1 Pages

    In her speech “Undo the Mistake of Internment” Eleanor Roosevelt uses similes and allusions to situations well known to the reader to create an appeal using ethos that urges the American public to act peaceably towards Japanese Americans that may settle among them. Roosevelt supports this plea by first expressing sympathy to the plight of Americans whose families have died in the war, but then reprimanding them for being prejudiced against the Japanese. Roosevelt’s purpose was to deliver this speech in a way that remains relatable to Americans, hence the many mentions of how she understands them and their feelings are not unreasonable. However, at the same time Roosevelt explains that these same reasonable feelings are not acceptable, a reprimand

    Read More

  • Farewell to Manzanar

    708 Words  | 2 Pages

    Beginning in March of 1942, in the midst of World War II, over 100,000 Japanese-Americans were forcefully removed from their homes and ordered to relocate to several of what the United States has euphemistically labeled “internment camps.” In Farewell to Manzanar, Jeanne Wakatsuki Houston describes in frightening detail her family’s experience of confinement for three and a half years during the war. In efforts to cope with the mortification and dehumanization and the boredom they were facing, the Wakatsukis and other Japanese-Americans participated in a wide range of activities. The children, before a structured school system was organized, generally played sports or made trouble; some adults worked for extremely meager wages, while others refused and had hobbies, and others involved themselves in more self-destructive activities.

    Read More

  • Of The Poem 'To The Man Who Shouted' By Franny Choi

    979 Words  | 2 Pages

    Poetry is a form of literature that some view as obsolete in the modern world, but in the poem “To the Man Who Shouted ‘I Like Pork Fried Rice’ at Me on the Street”, Franny Choi dispels that belief. She uses poetry as a medium to convey her own personal experience with the stereotyping and fetishization of Asian American women, which is an issue that millions of Asian American women still face today. When considering Choi’s background as a Korean American woman and how that has shaped her identity and philosophy, we see how being an Asian American woman is intrinsically a core part of her work, which is why much of her work is about breaking the stereotypes that come with this identity.

    Read More

  • Japanese-Americans and the Constitution

    1941 Words  | 4 Pages

    "A More Perfect Union: ..." is organized as a chronology of events centering around one basic theme: the confinement of Japanese-Americans to "concentration camps" during WWII. I believe the message being conveyed to the public is one of a major apology to these Japanese-Americans and their descendants for the great injustices forced upon them. In addition, the museum attempts to warn the overall public that since such a violation of the constitution has proven possible in the past, we cannot blindly rely on the fabric of our constitution to prevent such injustices from occurring again. We must proceed with caution in matters of civil liberties and work towards achieving a "more perfect union".

    Read More

  • World War II Prison Camps for Japanese-Americans

    1802 Words  | 4 Pages

    Twenty years after the First World War, humanity was, yet again, plagued with more hostility. September 1st, 1939 marked the start of World War II, this time, with new players on the board. Waves of fear and paranoia rippled throughout the United States, shaking its’ very foundation of liberty and justice for all. The waves powerfully crashed onto a single ethnic group, the Japanese-Americans, who had their rights and respect pulled away from them. They were seen as traitors and enemies in their own country, and were thrown into prison camps because of it. This event marks one of the absolute lowest points in United States history and has changed the course of the country as a whole.

    Read More

  • Lincoln Memorial

    991 Words  | 2 Pages

    Washington, DC is a spectacular place. This being my first time in DC, I was in awe of everything and all the historical places I encountered. The presence of the monuments and history is what made the capitol so magnificent. Having only read about the Lincoln memorial, I never had the chance to experience the sensation of being inside such an honorable place of importance. The imposing white marble walls of the memorial and the many people surrounding it could be seen from afar. Arriving at the location, an unknown feeling came over me. I was experiencing history in a whole different level. When I think about a memorial, the term remembrance comes to mind. Seeing the statue of Abraham Lincoln brought pieces of memories from history class and evoked thoughts of what it might have felt like to be in his shoes. I was astonished by the statue’s enormousness and how grand Abraham Lincoln looked in his chair. The size of the statue compared to pictures from books and elsewhere was surreal. Abraham Lincoln was a very “powerful and prominent individual” in the history of our nation, the statue’s design and size reflected upon that. Looking around me, I wanted to know what the others thoughts were on seeing his statue and how they felt in that building. I finally had the courage to ask one or two people what they thought; they all had the same appreciation as me. Hearing about an important person or learning about them in a history book gives you vast knowledge but it doesn’t evoke the feeling of utter appreciation as the memorial does. When Abraham Lincoln was assassinated, many people wanted to build a memorial in honor of him. They wanted to be able to show how important he was to shaping our nation and to “honor his existence”. Ce...

    Read More

  • Japanese American Internment Camp Rights and Responsibilities

    1389 Words  | 3 Pages

    Harth, Erica. Last Witnesses: Reflections on the Wartime Internment of Japanese Americans. New York: Palgrave for St. Martin's, 2001. Print.

    Read More

  • The Odyssey

    2003 Words  | 5 Pages

    ...omic exploitation. After enduring such injustices and hardships, many are now enjoying the life the Issei dreamed of for their families. Bibliography Work Cited Parillo, Vincent N. Strangers to These Shors: Race and Ethnitc Relations in the United States. Needham Heights, : Massachuchetts: 2000, 287-289. Klimova, Tatiana A. “Internment of Japanese Americans: Military Necessity or Racial Prejudice.” Old Dominion University. 1-9 (5/2/00) Asia, Ask. “Linking The Past to Present: Asian Americans Then and Now.” The Asia Society 1996. 1-3 (5/1/00 Spickard, Paul R. Japanese Americans: The transformation and Formation of an Ethnic Group. New Yourk:1996,93-159 McWilliams, Carey. Prejudice Japanese Americans: Symbol of racial Intolerance. boston: 1945,106-190. Myer, Dillon S. “Joseph Yoshisuke Kurihara.” Upprinted Americans 1971. 1-5 (5/1/00) Asin, Stefanie.”Poignand Memories.” Houston Chronicle 7/31/95.1-3 5/2/00 Reaseach Center.”research on 100th/442nd reginent conbat team.:NJAHS.1-2 5/2/00 Miyoshi, Nubu.:Idenity Crisis of the Sansei.”Sansei legacy project 3/13/98.1-21 5/1/00 Kiang, Peter.” Understanding the Perception of Asian Americans.” Asian Society1997.1-2 5/2/00 Word Count: 1862

    Read More

  • The Inferior Race

    758 Words  | 2 Pages

    Shortly after the commencement of Japanese imprisonment, derogatory propaganda flooded the streets and fueled the Americans’ discrimination towards the foreigners. One of the main focal points of the propaganda utilized the term “Japanophobia,” which has been described as “the extreme and irrational fear of Japan, Japanese people or the Japanese culture” (Phobia Source). After Pearl Harbor, this term was born to justify the American prejudice and paranoia towards the Japanese. It was plastered on countless posters, newspapers, and images of propaganda in an attempt to quell any feelings of guilt for this hatred. In addition, some Americans simply hoped for revenge against those with Japanese in their blood because of the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor. Propaganda posters in the United States “focused on fueling the people's hatred for the enemy” (Education). This idea was quite evident in one specific image displaying a Japanese man strangling an American woman were released. One of the main goals of these murderous posters were to instill the impression that the Japanese were the enemy within. Omnipresen...

    Read More

  • comfort women

    921 Words  | 2 Pages

    On December 26 2013, Japanese Prime Minister Shinzo Abe visited Yasukuni shrine which was built for commemorating soldiers who had died in service of the empire of Japan from 1876 to the end of World War 2. His visit to the Shrine was denounced internationally because it can be seen as praying for the honor war criminals. Especially his decision to go to the shrine made the victims of the atrocities and the descendants of them suffer. When the time, both South and North Korea were colonized by Japanese government, majority of Koreans were devastated. The government officials hauled both men and women off to Japan. A lot of men were forced to fight for the empire and the rest were performed medical experiments on their bodies. Concurrently, some women were sent to factories which made bullets and clothes. Others were tragically compelled to be sex slaves, known as "Comfort Women". The comfort women are a big issue between South Korea and Japan.

    Read More

  • The Exploitation of Asian Women in the Japanese Comfort Women System During World War II

    2010 Words  | 5 Pages

    War is a devastating event in which a country is in a state of aggression and resentment. Although war has its effects on almost every civilian residing in that country, historically people of minority groups and of low social class suffer the most. During the Pacific War, the Japanese Imperial Army was struggling with many cases of rape and the spread of venereal diseases among its armed forces. In order to cope with these ongoing issues, they schemed an idea to invent a comfort women system. The system started off with real Japanese prostitute volunteers, but then turned to tricking and abducing women into the system once volunteers ran out. As the Pacific War continued, Japanese forces began establishing “comfort stations” in many other parts of Asia. When studying the Japanese Comfort Women system of World War II, it is apparent who the people who suffered the most were. The Japanese Armed Forces sought after a certain group(s) of women who were seen as easy drafts into the comfort women system because of the many disadvantages associated with being a woman of a low social class and/or non-Japanese race during the World War II.

    Read More

  • Gender and Race During the U.S. Occupation of Japan

    1742 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...direct assistance of a male. In Japan’s Comfort Women, the “weakness” of women is seen again. Rape and sexual trade became a power play by individual men all the way up to the highest levels of government. But it was also a story of strength and courage on the part of victimized women. The Pacific War changed many things in Japan and the evolution of those institutions of Japanese society happened rapidly. The changes, however drastic, however gruesome, however sorrowful, were what shaped the history and future of Japan.

    Read More

  • Women In Japan Essay

    726 Words  | 2 Pages

    This book depicts how Japanese behaved both before and after the World War II. In this book, it describes how Japanese military slaves (a.k.a. comfort women) was made, what motivated Japan to do these abuses.

    Read More

  • monuments

    444 Words  | 1 Pages

    Many people feel a strong sense of patriotism and nationalism when they view a monument. Pride in one’s country is a great feeling. Monuments help bring out those feelings of nationalism. Homeland monuments such as the Statue of Liberty and Madison Square Garden makes one feel special. Millions of people from all over the world come to where you call home to view something that is special to you. We take such things for granted too often.

    Read More

  • Japanese American Are A Minority Group

    1534 Words  | 4 Pages

    Throughout Americas history, there has been prejudice, discrimination, and segregation. The prejudice, discrimination, and segregation of African-Americans and Native Americans are well known and often portrayed in movies. The group that is less exposed in movies is the prejudice, discrimination, and segregation of Asians. Mine is about a minority group that has seen prejudice, discrimination, and segregation that is now recognized universally deplorable the Japanese American. The incarceration of the Japanese by the United States during World War II is now considered unjust. After “Executive Order 9066 the army moved 40,000 long-term immigrants, and 77,000 United States citizens of Japanese descent.” (Miksch and Ghere, 2004 p. 212) Although, at that time “Most people thought internment of enemy aliens was a normal precaution in wartime situations.” (Miksch and Ghere, 2004 p. 211) “The practice of internment of enemy aliens is normal practice in Canada, Australia, United States, and European countries.” (Miksch and...

    Read More

More about Comfort Women Statue Analysis

Open Document