An Analysis Of Anne Lamott's Shitty First Drafts

1237 Words3 Pages

In her article “Shitty First Drafts,” Anne Lamott creates an argument attempting to prove to her readers that every good writer begins with a “shitty” first draft. This is a very bold claim to make about writers, and obviously should have some solid evidence to back it up. However, contrary to what one might think, Lamott has little to no “real” evidence to support her statements. Instead, she uses humor and sarcasm to cover the fact that she has no real support for her views. By doing this, Lamott lacks much of the credibility (usually) needed in a rhetorical argument, and her humorous tone does not suffice for a convincing argument. Even though Lamott incorporates a great deal of sarcasm and absurdity in her work, she lacks the most important …show more content…

Pathos is the appeal to an audience’s emotion. Aside from the other two appeals that I have outlined in this essay, pathos is by far the most recognizable appeal in Lamott’s article. The humorous tone of the article is very easily recognized and frankly, it is hard not to laugh at some of Lamott’s uncalled-for sarcastic remarks (whether it be in your head or out loud). For example, when writing about how every writer she knows never writes an elegant first draft, she continues, “All right, one of them does, but we do not like her very much. We do not think that she has a rich inner life or that God likes her or can even stand her” (1). By making such presumptuous claims about this person, some audiences might find this type of language comical or entertaining, which in turn makes them want to believe Lamott and continue reading. In a way this helps Lamott seem credible to some readers, in which case she has created a successful argument. On the other hand, some readers might find this kind of language unprofessional and inappropriate. Because much of the article deals with language that is full of humor and sarcasm, it would make sense to say that Lamott has directed this article towards an audience who is looking for something more entertaining than a typical statistic-filled essay that one might consider mainstream in this field. Whether it be entertaining or absurd, Lamott most definitely uses the appeal of pathos in her

Show More
Related

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Magnasoles

    731 Words  | 2 Pages

    For instance, they claim that MagnaSoles are “popular among consumers” (52-53). This use of luring pathos is creating a situation where the reader recognizes themselves as a consumer and that they should be conforming to also like the product. This is exactly what the speaker wants the reader to feel. This need to conform is a clear highlight to The Onion’s purpose of exposing how easy it is for advertisers to make a consumer buy in to the product. Additionally, the speaker puts the reader in a vulnerable position when a user of the product says to “try to prove that Magnasoles didn’t heal me!” (61-62). This is used to make the reader feel like this user of the product. The user thinks the product is great and he even goes as far to challenge the reader to find problems with his claims. If he is challenging the reader than more often than not the reader will just accept what is said and believe it. Once again The Onion mocks how consumers often feel when addressing a product’s claims. The seductive pathos allows for proof that consumers believe anything when they are tested to conform and believe

    Read More

  • Of The 1 % Ethos Pathos Logos

    728 Words  | 2 Pages

    Stiglitz applies the use of pathos all throughout his argument but one specific time is when he wrote, “This new inequality goes on to create new distortions, undermining efficiency even further. To give just one example, far too many of our most talented young people, seeing the astronomical rewards, have gone into finance rather than into fields that would lead to a more productive and healthy economy”(Stiglitz747). When I read this the audience feels that so many talented people do not follow their dreams, but rather go into to fields like finance and others that do not even benefit the economy. When creating an effective argument that pulls in your readers you need to appeal to them on a personal level. If you can pull readers in and connect them to real life situations they are more likely to continue reading. Applying pathos throughout the piece helps Stiglitz’s argument become more effective. This creates feelings and emotions that make the readers become invested in the piece the same way Stiglitz’s

    Read More

  • How Does Stevenson Use Ethos In Just Mercy

    771 Words  | 2 Pages

    Bryan Stevenson wrote a book called Just Mercy, which is about the failures in the criminal justice system. He tells the stories of victims of horrible injustices. He uses pathos as a narrative technique in order to persuade readers to feel empathetic towards the people about whom he wrote in his book. Stevenson uses pathos to have the reader feel a variety of emotions, specifically sympathy, anger, and hope because he knows that those emotions have more influence on the readers.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis On Abortion

    218 Words  | 1 Pages

    Parker attempts to use pathos in order to appeal to her audience's emotion. For example, she appeals to her audiences’ weaknesses by saying that women who have undergone an abortion feel shame, yet how can someone determine that another feels shameful because they realize that abortion is wrong. You could easily argue that they were in a state of depression because they miss their baby; that does not make them shameful.

    Read More

  • Alice Goffman Ethos Pathos Logos

    373 Words  | 1 Pages

    Pathos is emotional appeal that influences what we think. According to everything’s an argument there are four main ways that Pathos is used. They are using emotions to build bridges, using emotions to sustain an argument, using humor, and using argument based on emotion. To build a bridge, the speaker makes the audience feel empathy for the situation. The speaker appeals to her or his own experience to gain sympathy early that way the audience will be more inclined to listen later. When utilizing emotion to strengthen an argument, it makes the claim stronger, because it can energize the situation. Humor can be a great tactic to lighten the mood, but a jokester must be careful because the joke may be thought of as ridicule. Arguments based on emotion are to strike a particular emotion, so that the audience will feel more

    Read More

  • Why Do Doctors Commit Suicide?

    1982 Words  | 4 Pages

    ... audience, it made it more complex to have pathos effect all the audiences. To sum up, the author use of pathos did get the audience to be interested in the topic by giving them a solution to help yet, most would not like the topic of depressed doctor in need of aid.

    Read More

  • Is Google Making Us Stupid?, by Nicholas Carr

    1419 Words  | 3 Pages

    ...echniques employed are persuasive and subtle, and this allows Carr to take advantage of all emotional arguments at his disposal. In conjunction with sources pertinent to the topic, Carr’s emotional appeals seem to get his audience thinking, and from the article it is easy to agree with the points he has made. Carr’s use of logos and pathos does bring into question his ethos, however. Fortunately, Carr’s ethos should not be questioned, as he has written several books and articles on the topic. This does not excuse his bias, but it does permit him to speak on the topic at hand. Carr definitely presents himself as a strong literary figure, and his views on the internet are reasonable as well as relatable. This combination of ethos, pathos, and logos successfully allows Carr to write as an expert in this field, and his article and thoughts are not to be taken lightly.

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis: Doing The Ice Bucket Challenge

    555 Words  | 2 Pages

    To define, pathos is the Greek word for suffering and experience. This appeal is used to persuade an audience through emotion. For example, the writer evokes emotion by briefly explaining her own personal experience with the Lou Gehrig’s disease. Gutterman stated, “Don't get me wrong: I think raising money for ALS research is a great idea. My dad died of ALS when I was 16.” In addition, the writer went into detail with her story, further captivating readers emotion. “ My dad might still be alive if people 10 or 20 years ago had given ALS the attention it's getting now,” was another statement that implied how she felt on the

    Read More

  • Rhetorical Analysis Of Ain T I A Woman

    1368 Words  | 3 Pages

    Pathos is a writing technique that she uses in many ways, many of which are encompassed in her other rhetorical devices.

    Read More

  • Example Of Ethos Pathos Logos

    321 Words  | 1 Pages

    Pathos being the Greek word for “experience” is often called the emotional appeal because it persuades a person through their emotions and feelings. In my opinion, Pathos is the most important appeal because it causes the audience to identify as well as respond emotionally to the writer’s point of view, i.e., to feel what the writer feels. Apart from the emotional side, pathos has an imaginative side to an article or text as well. For example, President Obama’s speech on the assassination of Osama Bin Laden, Pathos is seen when he describes that day by saying ”The images of 9/11 are seared into our national memory- hijacked planes cutting through a cloudless sky; the Twin Towers collapsing to the ground; black smoke billowing up

    Read More

  • CNN Rhetorical Analysis

    1213 Words  | 3 Pages

    Pathos is an appeal to emotion, and is a way of convincing an audience of an argument by creating an emotional response. Examples of pathos can be sadness, anger, strength, and pain. I think CNN uses these types of emotions by using different colors for descriptions using context headlines and articles. It makes you angry looking at the way politics are paying to the government which is penalizing the communities . They use blue and red words. They use red if it is really important and they also use red for anger and blue to grab the reader's attention. An example of sadness comes from the amount of deaths tallying up over the United States and the year has just begun. It also is invoking the pain factor on our hearts for the families of the events that are going on globally. Strength can also be an emotion that can play on thus seen thru the different tab links like health. They use the color green to represent health because it makes you think of the environment. They use the color blue for money because money can be used for business, markets, and global. They show the color red if it is very important. They also use the color red when something is

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Reading To Write By Stephen King

    925 Words  | 2 Pages

    Many people think that reading more can help them to think and develop before writing something. Others might think that they don’t need to read and or write that it can really help them to brainstorm things a lot quicker and to develop their own ideas immediately (right away). The author’s purpose of Stephen King’s essay, Reading to Write, is to understand the concepts, strategies and understandings of how to always read first and then start something. The importance of this essay is to understand and comprehend our reading and writing skills by brainstorming our ideas and thoughts a lot quicker. In other words, we must always try to read first before we can brainstorm some ideas and to think before we write something. There are many reasons why I chose Stephen King’s essay, Reading to Write, by many ways that reading can help you to comprehend, writing, can help you to evaluate and summarize things after reading a passage, if you read, it can help you to write things better and as you read, it can help you to think and evaluate of what to write about.

    Read More

  • ASPCA ASPCA Uses Aristotle's Power of Persuasion

    606 Words  | 2 Pages

    Pathos is an emotional appeal in which the advertisers hope that the consumers will allow their claim. Say for instance most people will notice a puppy behind what looks like to be a rusty cage. Seeing a cage like that, makes some wonder how bad the conditions are that the puppy is living in. then there is the puppy who looks very solemn, sad, and miserable. It makes one think how can people do this, why would they do this. This is an animal that should not have to live their life this way; it can really tug at some heartstrings, and cause many emotions like sad, anger, and even happy. For instance something like this makes most people think wow how can someone do th...

    Read More

  • Winston Churchill's Speech Ethos

    625 Words  | 2 Pages

    When talking about the use of Pathos in a speech, one has to realize this can very well be the most effective one of the three. This being said Winston Churchill use this device to inspire many of his soldiers, in what seemed like the darkest hour during the war. “Upon this battle depends the survival of Christian civilization.” (Churchill) In this quote he utilizes pathos to invoke a fire within the men of his army. During this time Christian beliefs were held in high regard. So

    Read More

  • American Century Rhetorical Analysis Essay

    1124 Words  | 3 Pages

    Pathos means to persuade an audience by appealing to their emotions. For instance, “If America meets it correctly, then, despite hosts of dangers and difficulties, we can look forward and move forward to a future worthy of men, with peace in our hearts. If we dodge the issue, we shall flounder for ten or 20 or 30 bitter years in a chartless and meaningless series of disasters.” This pathos makes the readers feel nervous, and they want to figure out whether America can avoid waste the best period. Therefore, the readers will focus on how they can solve the problem, and they cannot wait to read the following words. Another instance is that the paragraph “If there's one place we Americans did not want to be, it was in the war. We didn't want much to be in any kind of war but, if there was one kind of war we most of all didn't want to be in, it was a European war. Yet, we're in a war, as vicious and bad a war as ever struck this planet, and, along with being worldwide, a European war.” The author stand with the reader: they do not want to be involved in the war, and they want to escape from it. Then he said that “We say we don't want to be in the war. We also say we want England to win. We want Hitler stopped - more than we want to stay out of the war. So, at the moment, we're in.”, which shows the consideration of getting out of the war, and it makes the readers acknowledge that the America was

    Read More

More about An Analysis Of Anne Lamott's Shitty First Drafts

Open Document