World History: How Can a Discipline Remain Relevant?

1418 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Importance of studying world history

“Historians are a contentious lot. While their arguments are usually conducted in polite language, the disputations are conducted on a number of fronts at once, and the frame of mind of the disputants ranges from a sporting pleasure with making point after point to a savage determination to win the day.” Although a sense of negativity creeps into this notion of Manning’s, a strengthening of world history can also emerge from this back and forth debate. World history will take shape as scholars push each other to clarify and defend ideas, while remaining skeptical and critical readers. This debate is key to avoiding either a stagnation of ideas or a dilution of possible new insights. As Manning asserts, “The exciting debates and the real advances in knowledge come when multiple scholars are working on related topics, testing their assumptions, data, and interpretations against each other’s.” As world history moves forward, as a discipline, historians would do well to keep this in mind. In addition to internal debate, a need to defend world history as a discipline is still necessary. A significant amount of work was done on defining and defending world history in the early to mid 1990’s. Any cursory look at the Journal of World History during this time period highlights this fact. In addition if you look to the May 1995 issue of History and Theory you see a thematic take on world history. As a result of this scholarship the discipline of world history gained momentum in academia, especially at the teaching level. Despite this trend, world history still finds itself defending its ideas. World history has yet to gain support from the elite universities and those that wish to pursue a PhD in world history have limi... ... middle of paper ... ...r than a series of airtight specialist monographs.” Only by engaging in the debate within and from outside of world history will the discipline continue to be relevant on both an academic and popular stage. Works Cited Duchesne, Ricardo. “Asia First?.” The Journal of the Historical Society 6, no. 1 (March 2006): 69-91. Frank, Andre Gunder. ReOrient: Global Economy in the Asian Age. Berkeley: University of California Press, 1998. Hobson, John. “Explaining the Rise of the West: A Reply to Ricardo Duchesne.” The Journal of the Historical Society 6, no. 4 (December 2006): 579-599. Landes, David. The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Some Are So Rich and Some So Poor. New York: WW Norton and Company, 1999. Manning, Patrick. Navigating World History: Historian Create a Global Past New York: Palgrave/MacMillan, 2003.

Show More
Related

  • Historical Accounts of the English Civil War

    2026 Words  | 5 Pages

    Second, the historian must place himself within the existing historical debate on the topic at hand, and state (if not so formulaically as is presented here) what he intends to add to or correct about the existing discussion, how he intends to do that (through examining new sources, asking new questions, or shifting the emphasis of pre-existing explanations), and whether he’s going to leave out some parts of the story. This fulfills the qualities of good history by alerting readers to the author’s bias in comparison with the biases of other schools of scholarship on the topic, and shows that the author is confident enough in his arguments to hold them up to other interpreta...

    Read More

  • The Houses of History, by Anna Green and Kathleen Troup

    965 Words  | 2 Pages

    It’s truly fascinating how there are so many different approaches to history, how so many different types of minds and schools of thought can come together to study the events of the world’s past. There are so many ways to approach what happened in our past, and the groups of historians previously mentioned are only a fraction of the actual number of different ways of researching and thinking that exists as it pertains to the study of history. History is in some ways, always a mystery, and all historians, regardless of schooling, training or biases, seek to accomplish one goal: to understand what occurred before us and why, and to use that knowledge to learn how the world was shaped into the world we live in today.

    Read More

  • Causes and Effects of the Protestant Reformation

    1175 Words  | 3 Pages

    Duiker, William J., and Jackson J. Spielvogel. World History. 3rd ed. Belmont, CA: Wadsworth/Thomsom Learning, 2001. 374-438.

    Read More

  • Social Control through Works of Fiction

    1379 Words  | 3 Pages

    "They Who Write History Control History and Thus Control the World." The Institute for Economic Democracy RSS. Www.ied.info, n.d. Web. 25 Feb. 2014.

    Read More

  • The Landscape of History

    1626 Words  | 4 Pages

    John Lewis Gaddis, in his book, The Landscape of History, generates a strong argument for the historical method by bringing together the multiple standpoints in viewing history and the sciences. The issue of objective truth in history is addressed throughout Gaddis’s work. In general, historians learn to select the various events that they believe to be valid. Historians must face the fact that there is an “accurate” interpretation of the past ceases to exist because interpretation itself is based on the experience of the historian, in which people cannot observe directly (Gaddis 10). Historians can only view the past in a limited perspective, which generates subjectivity and bias, and claiming a piece of history to be “objective” is simplistic. Seeing the world in a multidimensiona...

    Read More

  • Robert Reich's Why The Rich Are Getting Richer

    1223 Words  | 3 Pages

    The richest people who seem to keep getting richer have been walking into their wealth since the day they have been born. It has been proven by how the companies have been popping up around the world, how the companies are being bribed by governors trying to make their state seem more economically powerful. “Philips, Sony, and Toyota factories are popping up all over—to the self congratulatory applause of the nation’s governors and mayors, who have lured them with promises of tax abatements and new sewers, among other amenities.” (Paragraph 17) People are born into their jobs, and are doomed for their economic boats. IN other countries such as China, it has been proven that the families with the moneys are the ones with the money, are the ones with the economic power. “Many wealthy Chinese and western residents moved their money abroad and some actually left the colony. By 1971, the Cultural Revolution in China had ended in failure and conditions in Hong Kong calmed,” (Lannom) such as Gloria Lannom states, yet it took a while for Hong Kong to rebuild its economic standings because of this

    Read More

  • The Horrors of War

    731 Words  | 2 Pages

    Perry, M., Davis, D., Harris, J., Laue, T. V., & Warren, D. J. (1985). A history of the world (Revised Edition ed.). Boston: Houghton Mifflin.

    Read More

  • Why did the Great Divergence Occur

    1372 Words  | 3 Pages

    Landes, D., 1999. The Wealth and Poverty of Nations: Why Some Are So Rich and Some So Poor. New York: W. W. Norton & Company, 38-59

    Read More

  • Why the Rich are Getting Richer and the Poor, Poorer

    1571 Words  | 4 Pages

    Reich, Robert. “Why the Rich Are Getting Richer and the Poor Poorer.” The Work of Nations.

    Read More

  • Critical Analysis of "Historiography in the Twentieth Century" by Georg G. Iggers

    1705 Words  | 4 Pages

    Iggers opens the book by talking about a revolutionary way that the Western world was taught about history. Throughout the book he ascertains the changes that take place throughout historiography and the nature of history itself. He also examines prior historical notions and the way that historiography was altered after World War II. History morphed from previous antiquarian teachings into a deeper, more evaluated approach. Historians gained a more intimate relationship with postmodern ideas and began looking at history in an objective manner using contemporary discipline. Iggers studies the way postmodernism was changed by new social sciences which allowed more detail into cultural influences and the problems surrounding globalization theories. He also explains the birth of microhistory which replaced macrohistory.

    Read More

  • Analysis of The Tulse Luper Suitcases Trilogy

    2648 Words  | 6 Pages

    History and time are considered to be cultural formations since a History cannot be detached from the culture in which it is produced and received. It is through culture that a historical sense is achieved and in fact, each culture experiences History in a different way leading us to the current perception of History as not being one, but many histories depending on the cultural groups involved. Historians have fought throughout the centuries on whether such thing as “objective History” can exist but in the end, even materialist historians will admit that the reality of History is so complicated and contradictory that no single version could possibly represent the truth; consequently different interpretations are inevitable.

    Read More

  • Overview of Afghanistan's Woes

    1800 Words  | 4 Pages

    "The Differences Between Rich and Poor Countries :: Papers." The Differences Between Rich and Poor Countries :: Papers. N.p., n.d. Web. 18 May 2014.

    Read More

  • Far East

    2007 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Far East, written by Paul H. Clyde and Burton F. Beers is a book containing a collection of facts and is presented in chronological and topical order starting with history in general and this history in particular. The authors begin their book with “What is history?” The answer is “In its simplest form, history is the record of things thought, said, and done. Such a definition is a useful starting point but it leaves a host of questions unanswered”. (p.1) It is here that I find myself in complete agreement with the authors not just for this book but history in general as a subject.

    Read More

  • Does Money Makes Countries Rich Or Poor?

    1530 Words  | 4 Pages

    Stiglitz, Joseph E.. "Why Resource-Rich Countries Usually End Up Poor." Slate Magazine. Project Syndicate, 12 Aug. 2012. Web. 20 Apr. 2014. .

    Read More

  • Mini Paper #1

    654 Words  | 2 Pages

    Since the time of the ancient world to the Renaissance and Progressive Era, the study of history has remained the same. Most of the methods that emerged or used during these times were largely influenced by other ideas and not only objectivity. While objectivity and professionalism may have affected the study of history, it did not challenge or completely alter it. The study of history has always been a systematic approach, and although new methods emerged throughout the past, the same sense of objectivity to finding the “truth” remains.

    Read More

More about World History: How Can a Discipline Remain Relevant?

Open Document