Vichy France: The French Turning Against themselves, to the Germans

1264 Words3 Pages

Vichy France is a period of French history that has only fairly recently begun to be examined for what it truly is: a period in which many of the French turned against their own state and collaborated with the German forces to betray their own country. Until the eighties, the Vichy Regime was regarded as “an aberration in the evolution of the French Republic” (Munholland, 1994) , repressed by the French in an attempt to regain their national pride. ‘Lacombe Lucien’ (1974), directed by Louis Malle is a film which aims to capture the ambiguity of the era through the documentation of fictional collaborateur, Lucien.

Lucien is an uneducated country boy with highly apolitical views, as is apparent from his lack of attention to the radio broadcast in the opening sequence, so his incentives for becoming a collaborateur are questionable and ambiguous. Lucien is very much representative of the general population of rural France in this way, and this is evident within the film when we see the teacher chastising a pupil for being unable to spell a word, but eventually brushing it off with the notion that he will simply become a farmer anyway. In fact, according to Jean-Paul Sartre “most collaborators, it’s a fact, came from the bourgeois” (Jankiwski, 1991). Like many other collaborators, Lucien has not grown up in an environment where education or attention to current affairs are high priorities, so an ambigious reaction to Vichy France is natural for him since it is not something he is well informed about. The idea that evil deeds can simply arise as a result of ignorance is supported by Hannah Arendt who says there is a “strange interdependence of thoughtlessness and evil” (Arendt, 1964). It is this banality of evil that makes Vichy Fran...

... middle of paper ...

...e exact opposite, rendering his dedication and involvement in the Milice questionable. In this sense, Lucien, is portraying the typical bourgeois collaborateur as a human being who is capable of love, quite unlike the traditional image of a “monster”. However, Lucien and his motives remain ambiguous to the audience due to his questionable treatment of France at certain points within the film. Whilst Lucien is “courting” France, he demands that she escort him to a dance at the hotel which has become a gathering place for the Milice, against her will and her father’s will. This is a highly selfish act on Lucien’s part, as France is in great danger the entire evening since the generals within the Milice are well aware of her status as a Jew, creating doubt withing the audience over the authenticity of Lucien’s love and his capability to think and feel in a moral manner

Open Document