Theme Of Sunzi And The Emperor's Concubines

1444 Words3 Pages

Reading the story “Sunzi and the Emperor’s Concubines” was about Ch’i state native, Sun Tzu who trying to prove to Ho Lu, the king of Wu, that his theory of managing soldiers was affective. When Sun Tzu was demonstrating to Ho Lu his techniques, the two concubines he was using at the time did not pay attention. They did not do anything they were supposed to do which made Sun Tzu look bad. After this, Sun Tzu wanted to have them beheaded because of their behavior, but the king was resistant. These were his favorite concubines, and to have them beheaded would be tragic. Sun Tzu did not listen to the king and the concubines were beheaded. This resulted in two others having to fill in. In this story there is an overall concept that can be …show more content…

Instead of killing them, Sun Tzu could have just replaced them with two others. This would have been no harm and the job still would have gotten done with the replacements. Sun Tzu could have respected the king’s wishes and not have them beheaded. A second option would have been to replace Sun Tzu and put someone else in charge who could have controlled the army better. Regardless of what happened, there were deaths which goes against taking whole. Another theme from Art of War is orthodox and unorthodox approaches. It could be seen that having no one die would be orthodox approaches, but instead Sun Tzu went with the unorthodox approach and killed two concubines. It would have made sense for Sun Tzu to just move on with two other people, but on the other hand, two deaths is nothing compared to the amount it could have been. They were fortunate it was only two deaths and not a lot more. Even though the alternatives seem plausible, the job would not have gotten done as well and Sun Tzu would not have become general and had success. If they just replaced the first two concubines then the others would not change their behavior and just be okay with being replaced until there were two that listened. The fact that they saw Sun Tzu kill the concubines was needed in order for the others to realize he was not going to tolerate any messing

Open Document