The Stupidity of the Civilized Man in Madame Bovary and The House of the Spirits

1362 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Gender roles and literature

In Madame Bovary and The House of the Spirits, both Gustave Flaubert and Isabel Allende criticize the stupidity of the civilized man. They set their story during times of technological growth to demonstrate how technology masks the true nature of man. They also characterize their characters to typify their society to disparage the stereotypes of their society, and they manipulate gender roles to prove how women are the dominant partners in relationships, contrary to social beliefs. All of these techniques come together to prove their opinion of man.

Flaubert and Allende set their books during times of great technological change and growth to demonstrate how they feel technology masks the true nature of man. At the agricultural show, Flaubert contrasts the councilor's speech with Emma and Rodolphe's actions to unveil the primal nature of humans even during times of growth. The councilor declares, "Everywhere commerce and the arts are flourishing; everywhere new means of communication . . . establish within it new relations"(Flaubert 186-187). During this discussion of progress, Emma and Rodolphe begin their affair. Emma is unable to stay faithful because Flaubert believes man is just a lustful animal trying to procreate and no progress can overcome this nature. The syntax itself is a representation of the nature of man breaking through progress. Flaubert demonstrates this nature with the back and forth attention between Emma and Rodolphe’s conversation and the speeches at the agricultural show. Flaubert also condemns the new medical techniques and technology through the failed surgery on Hippolyte's foot. Cavinet is an intelligent doctor whom Flaubert praises. Therefore Flaubert promotes his own ideas through Cavinet. Cavinet arg...

... middle of paper ...

...se of the strength of the women.

Flaubert and Allende thoroughly criticize the stupidity of the civilized man. They both lived in and set their stories during technological change, which they both argue only covers up the ignorant and instable nature of man instead of changing it. They both create characters representative of their society disparaging them as ignorant or selfish. Lastly they manipulate gender roles, flipping men and women’s traditional characteristics. Their criticism of the civilized man moreover criticizes the patriarchal societies in which they both lived. Both societies ended up failing and Flaubert and Allende believe this is no doubt because of the men who ran them.

Works Cited

Allende. Isabel. The House of the Spirits. New York: Bantam, 1982.

Flaubert, Gustave. Madame Bovary. Trans. Eleanor Marx-Aveling. Mineola (NY): Dover,

1996.

Show More
Related

  • Fahrenheit 451

    887 Words  | 2 Pages

    Clarisse is a distinct contrast towards the people in society. She seems lively and unrealistic in this dull, robotic society, due to her old and traditional beliefs, as opposed to the rest of society who is sucked into its ideas and agrees with their way of living. Clarisse loves watching the rain and tasting it on her lips. She takes time to notice the flowers, watch birds, and collect butterflies. In Montag’s second meeting, the two of them find a dandelion and Clarisse tells Montag of rubbing it under the chin. Clarisse remarks, “If it rubs off, it means I’m in love.” (22) Clarisse even values superstition; something that is completely against this society. Since she is tremendously incompatible with this civilization, they regard her as strange and different. She is even forced to visit a psychiatrist for her abnormal and unpractical behavior, but in truth, she symbolizes youth, question, innocence...

    Read More

  • The Ladies Paradise by Émile Zola

    1712 Words  | 4 Pages

    Zola's portrayal of men and their attitudes towards women may be the relation between that of, the controller and the controlled. One is made to believe that it is the men who control the women, and although this is the case in most instances of the Ladies Paradise, there are two people who ensue in resisting against all odds, at being run over by the machine that captivated and engulfed the late nineteenth century bourgeois household unit. They are the elegant Mademoiselle Boudu and the brushy eye browed Monsieur Bourras. One of the main characters Monsieur Mouret ("governor" of the Ladies Paradise) spectacularly uses the lower classes as a tool to increase the perception of happenings in his store. So as to invoke middle class ladies of France not only to enter his palatial trap set for the nineteenth century consumer, but as well to create their desire of acquiring greater material possessions than they may actually need. Another implication is the insatiable consumer appetite created by Mouret results in the development of kleptomania, exemplified in the latter stages of the book by a bourgeois wife of a Magistrate, Madame de Boves, as well as long time employees of the department store. Mouret is the quintessential renaissance man of France with his dashing ways of charming women and subduing them to his desires whilst having them believe that his actions are in their favor and interest at all times.

    Read More

  • The Role of the Doctor in Kate Chopin’s The Awakening

    653 Words  | 2 Pages

    While in his garden reading, Doctor Mandelet is interrupted by Mr. Pontellier, who promptly reports his wife’s troubled mind, indicating that Mr. Pontellier himself has a troubled mind through lines like “it isn’t easy to explain” or “She’s making it devilishly uncomfortable for me”(88). These disclosures help to add a few more stenciled lines, deepening Mr. Pontellier, who is, through the course of the novel, made most noticeable by his absences. His character is marred by a dependency on social conventions and aristocratic pride that he cannot push the logic of the facts toward a conclusion that would require a rethinking of his way of life.

    Read More

  • Realism In Gustave Flaubert's 'A Simple Heart'

    935 Words  | 2 Pages

    Gustave Flaubert incorporates and composes a realistic piece of literature using realistic literature techniques in his short story, “A Simple Heart.” Flaubert accomplishes this through telling a story that mimics the real life of Félicité, and writing fiction that deliberately cuts across different class hierarchies; through this method, Flaubert

    Read More

  • Trifles And A Doll House Comparison Essay

    727 Words  | 2 Pages

    In “Trifles” by Susan Glaspell and “A Dollhouse” by Henrik Ibsen, the authors use symbolism to shed light on the way woman were once looked down upon by men. In both plays the woman face similar derisive attitudes from the men in their lives. Women are treated as property, looked down upon and only useful in matters pertaining to cooking, taking care of children, housework and sexual objects. The women’s marriages, socioeconomic and social status are completely different, but both women reach their emotional breaking point, and grow so discontent with their situations they are willing to take drastic actions.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of A Simple Heart By Gustave Flaubert

    856 Words  | 2 Pages

    Gustave Flaubert incorporates and composes a realistic piece of literature using realistic literary techniques in his short story, “A Simple Heart.” Flaubert accomplishes this through telling a story that mimics the real life of Félicité, and writing fiction that deliberately cuts across different class hierarchies; through this method, Flaubert is able to give the reader a clear understanding of the whole society. Flaubert makes the unvarnished truth about simple hearts clear by exposing a clear replica of a realistic story, therefore, allowing the reader to clearly understand the society and the different classes of characters. The story, “A Simple Heart” focuses on the life of a naive, simple-minded underclass maid, Félicité, and her encounters with those around her.

    Read More

  • Objectification of Women in The House of Mirth

    2117 Words  | 5 Pages

    Edith Wharton's The House of Mirth is an affront to the false social values of fashionable New York society.  The heroine is Lily Bart, a woman who is destroyed by the very society that produces her.  Lily is well-born but poor.  The story traces the decline of Lily as she moves through a series of living residences, from houses to hotel lodgings.  Lily lives in a New York society where appearances are all.  Women have a decorative function in such an environment, and even her name, Lily, suggests she is a flower of femininity, i.e. an object of decoration as well as of desirability to the male element.  We see this is very true once Lily's bloom fades, as it were, a time when she is cast aside by her peers no longer being useful as something to admire on the surface.  The theme of the novel in this aspect is that identity based on mere appearance is not enough to sustain the human soul physically or metaphysically.  Once she is no longer able to keep the "eye" of her peers, Lily finds herself with no identity and dies.  This analysis will discuss the theme of the objectification of women in a male dominated society inherent throughout the novel.

    Read More

  • Kate Chopin And Gustave Flaubert's The Awakening Literary Analysis

    1112 Words  | 3 Pages

    Both novels are focused at a time, the nineteenth century, when the woman was unquestionably submissive to the man, otherwise, known as the era of the domestic woman. The settings for both novels give the audience insight as to why the protagonists wanted to liberate themselves from the traditional aspect of the woman. The authors also employ a healthy amount of symbolism in their work. For example, the caged birds who understand each other represent Edna and mademoiselle Reisz who are imprisoned by their communal beliefs. The actions of Edna are only understood by mademoiselle Reisz. In “Madam Bovary”, Emma’s appearance has great symbolic significance in the novel. It shows how her soul deteriorates as her focus on physical things increases. Her disgust on the blind man’s image emphasizes how she has lost herself to the

    Read More

  • Sexism In The Great Gatsby

    1447 Words  | 3 Pages

    Throughout time women have been written as the lesser sex, weaker, secondary characters. They are portrayed as dumb, stupid, and nothing more than their fading beauty. They are written as if they need to be saved or helped because they cannot help themselves. Women, such as Daisy Buchanan who believes all a woman can be is a “beautiful little fool”, Mrs Mallard who quite died when she lost her freedom from her husband, Eliza Perkins who rights the main character a woman who is a mental health patient who happens to be a woman being locked up by her husband, and then Carlos Andres Gomez who recognizes the sexism problem and wants to change it. Women in The Great Gatsby, “The Story of an Hour,” “The Yellow Wall Paper” and the poem “When” are oppressed because the fundamental concept of equality that America is based on undermines gender equality.

    Read More

  • Virginia Woolf's A Room of One's Own

    655 Words  | 2 Pages

    Beton discovers men’s anger toward women by glancing through an apparently well-known Professor von X’s book titled The Mental, Moral, and Physical Inferiority of the Female Sex. The mere title makes her angry—outraged that the words could even form the title of a book, which, to Beton, is the natural response to “be[ing] told that one is naturally the inferior of a little man” (32). She does not know at first why men are so critical of women, but she does know that their arguments say more about them than they do about the women they write about. The books “had been written in the red light of emotion,” she says, “and not in the white light of truth” (33), meaning that the men Beton speaks of are responding to something—some feeling or condition that they, as a sex identifying with one another, are sensing, rather than merely expressing a natural fact as their rhetoric seems to suggest.

    Read More

  • Movie Essays - Gustave Flaubert's Madame Bovary on Film

    2315 Words  | 5 Pages

    The films of Minnelli and Chabrol represent two radically different approaches to Flaubert's novel. In general, Minnelli tends to romanticize the story, even sentimentalize it, making Emma much more of a sympathetic heroine than seems to be the case in Flaubert's text. Much of the ironic tone of the novel is lost. Minnelli also omits from his film all scenes which are not directly connected with Emma. The harsh realism and ironic social commentary which underlie Flaubert's novel are ignored for the most part. Chabrol, on the other hand, attempts to be scrupulously faithful to the text and spirit of the novel. The director claims that virtually every word of dialogue in the film was taken directly from Flaubert...

    Read More

  • A Comparison of Gustave Flaubert and Madame Bovary

    1428 Words  | 3 Pages

    to abide by it.  In the novel, Emma meets a pitiful doctor named Charles Bovary.

    Read More

  • Reality vs. Imagination in Emma Bovary's Predicament

    3641 Words  | 8 Pages

    Madame Bovary, a novel by Gustave Flaubert, describes life in the provinces. While depicting the provincial manners, customs, codes and norms, the novel puts great emphasis on its protagonist, Emma Bovary who is a representative of a provincial woman. Concerning the fundamental typicality in Emma Bovary’s story, Flaubert points out: “My poor Bovary is no doubt suffering and weeping at this very moment in twenty French villages at once.” (Heath, 54). Yet, Emma Bovary’s story emerges as a result of her difference from the rest of the society she lives in. She is in conflict with her mediocre and tedious surroundings in respect of the responses she makes to the world she lives in. Among the three basic responses made by human beings, Emma’s response is “dreaming of an impossible absolute” while others around her “unquestionably accept things as they are” or “coldly and practically profiteer from whatever circumstances they meet.” (Fairlie, 33). However, Emma’s pursuit of ideals which leads to the imagining of passion, luxury and ecstasy prevents her from seeing the world in a realistic perspective or causes her to confuse reality and imagination with each other.

    Read More

  • Lacanian Desire: Gustave Flaubert’s Madame Bovary

    2244 Words  | 5 Pages

    Madame Bovary is Gustave Flaubert’s first novel and is considered his masterpiece. It has been studied from various angles by the critics. Some study it as a realistic novel of the nineteenth century rooted in its social milieu. There are other critics who have studied it as a satire of romantic sensibility. It is simply assumed that Emma Bovary, the protagonist, embodied naive dreams and empty cliché that author wishes to ridicule, as excesses and mannerisms of romanticism. She is seen as a romantic idealist trapped in a mundane mercantile world. Innumerable theorists have discovered and analysed extensively a variety of questions raised by its style, themes, and aesthetic innovations. In this research paper an attempt has been made to analyse life of Emma Bovary as a paradigm of Lacanian desire.

    Read More

  • Romance and Reality in Flaubert’s Madame Bovary

    1129 Words  | 3 Pages

    In the story of Alice in Wonderland we follow Alice down a rabbit hole into a land of pure wonder, where the logic of a little girl holds no sway. In Gustave Flaubert’s Madame Bovary, we witness exactly the opposite as Emma Bovary, a most romantic creature, is purposely cast into a harshly realistic world. In either case, a creature is put into an environment unnatural to her disposition, yet in Flaubert’s example, Emma shares the world we inhabit, and thus the message her story brings is much more pertinent. To convey this message, Flaubert replicates not a world of fantasy, but rather the real world, with all its joy, sadness, and occasional monotony intact. Then he proceeds to dump an exaggeratedly sentimental woman, Bovary, with the training, appearance, and expectations of an heiress, into the common mire and leave her there to flounder in the reality of middle class life as a farmer’s daughter. From Madame Bovary’s reactions within this realistic situation, and from the novel’s outcome, a message is rendered concerning romanticism itself, and its misplacement in a cacophonous and uncomplimentary world.

    Read More

More about The Stupidity of the Civilized Man in Madame Bovary and The House of the Spirits

Open Document