The Shining: All Meaning and No Play by Stanley Kubrick

1220 Words3 Pages

Initially tanking at the box office, Stanley Kubrick's The Shining garnered a cult following and high appreciation many years after premiering. The film, differing from Stephen King's original novel, lacked speed and coherence; however, fans accumulated after noticing small details that conveyed entirely different messages. The director dedicated attention to every detail, causing confusion after noticeable inconsistencies and pointless-seeming deviations from the book. Stanley Kubrick's The Shining spawned numerous discussions through multiple enigmatic, open-ended components and deep-reaching symbolism.
The film exhibits American issues of 1920s chauvinism as Jack, slowly adopting the bigots' life philosophies, attempts to join an “exclusive and eternal Fourth of July costume party where the whiskey flows free of charge” (Smith 302). Slowly losing his sanity, the father enters a conversation with the ghost of a previous caretaker in the bathroom; they discuss his interest in joining the party, when the apparition asks why his son, Danny, “brought an outside party into [the Hotel]” (302). Referencing an African-American man Danny sent to save himself and his mother, Wendy, from his murderous father, Jack realizes that he must “shed his enlightened liberal schoolteacher/writer personality and adopt the racist views....[of] wealthy, white, pre-Depression and pre-World War II American [males]” by killing the savior (302). He later succeeds, murdering the man en route to hunting down his son and wife. Furthermore, in the same conversation, Jack shows his narrow views as he references Wendy by calling her “the old sperm bank” (Metz 55). After his wife mentions a mysterious woman in one of the hotel rooms, the man seems inte...

... middle of paper ...

... theories possess great merit.

Works Cited

Ethan, Alter. "Shining Through." Film Journal International Apr. 2013: EBSCOHost. Web.
Hogan, Michael. "The Shining: 10 Best Conspiracy Theories." The Telegraph. Telegraph Media Group, 24 Sept. 2013. Web.
Jacobson, Mark. "'I Know What The Shining Is Really About': Inside the Crowded Cult at the Overlook Hotel." Editorial. New York Magazine 25 Mar. 2013 EBSCOHost.
Metz, Walter. "Toward a Post-structural Influence in Film Genre Study: Intertextuality and The Shining." Film Criticism 22.1 (1997): 38-61. EBSCOHost.
Smith, Greg. "`Real Horror Show': The Juxtaposition of Subtext, Satire and Audience Implication in Stanley Kubrick's "The Shining."" Literature Film Quarterly 1997: 300. EBSCOHost.
Trinh, Jean. "'The Shining': The Craziest Theories Behind the Film." The Daily Beast. Newsweek/Daily Beast, 28 Mar. 2013. Web.

Open Document