The Battle of Mogadishu

2249 Words5 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: The Battle of Mogadishu conditions

What started out as a well planned kidnapping, the Battle of Mogadishu turned into a battle for the lives of many American Special forces. Most are more familiar with this battle from the book “Black Hawk Down” by Mark Bowden and the motion picture that followed with the same title. Let’s put the lack of operational, intelligence and command preparedness for conducting the actual mission aside for a minute and focus on the recovery of the American Aircrew and Special Forces members stranded in the middle of the city. Could the command have prevented the actions that followed the shoot down of Super 64? Were the soldiers properly trained for the sequence of events to follow? To determine this, I will first discuss the history and evolution of Personnel Recovery (PR). Secondly, I will outline the efforts to recover the crewmembers of the fallen UH-60’s and the confusion that ensued with the recovery team. Lastly, I will point out the lessons learned from the battle and how it has influenced PR into today’s military operations.

History
The sum of military, diplomatic and civil efforts to affect the recovery and reintegration of isolated personnel (IP), or PR as defined in JP 3-50, has evolved over centuries of military and civil conflicts. It is important to look back and highlight historical developments that have shaped PR to fully understand its current state.
Before World War II the attempt to recover IP was almost unheard of. Due to the lack of technology, communications where limited to visual or audio signals. Command and control was exercised by these forms of communication restricting the size of the battlefield and thus the size of the battling force. With these restrictions an isolated person was a very rare event an...

... middle of paper ...

...o that others may live to return with honor.”

Works Cited

HansenIbid, Darren T., COMBAT SEARCH AND RESCUE: SHOULD IT BE A JOINT REQUIREMENT? (Naval War College, Newport, R.I., May 2001)

Leahy, Timothy J., The Future of USAF Combat Search and Rescue (Unpublished Research Paper, U.S. Air University, School of Advanced Airpower Studies, Maxwell AFB, AL, 1998)

Militaryfactor.com, Despite the humanitarian-minded end-goal, the American involvement in Somalia proved a nightmare all around, shaping US foreign policy for the next several decades

Mullarky, J.W., Combat Search and Rescue-The CINC's Dilemma (Alexandria, VA: Defense Logistics Agency. Defense Technical Information Center, 1990)

Naskrent, Dieter, Personnel Recovery- A Primer (Joint Air Power Competence Centre, 2011)

Rucci, Gregory, Do We Still Need Navy CSAR? (U.S. Naval Institute Proceedings, July 2000)

Show More
Related

  • The 123rd Aviation Battalion of 1968

    736 Words  | 2 Pages

    In 1968, the United States Army activated the 123rd Aviation Battalion, creating a remarkable unit that was comprised of several Army assets. The design of the battalion revolutionized how assets could be combined to complete many missions by mixing infantry, signal, aviation, and support units. The 123rd’s mission ranged from was to collect intelligence, deliver supplies, insert and extract infantrymen, and provide air support. In addition to their primary mission they also participated in medical evacuation, an invaluable asset on the battlefields of Vietnam.

    Read More

  • The Civil Reserve Air Fleet

    2228 Words  | 5 Pages

    The Civil Reserve Air Fleet (CRAF) is a network of select aircraft from several commercial airlines that are all committed in various amounts to the Department of Defense (DoD) to provide airlift resources when the capability of U.S. military aircraft is exceeded. This system is designed so that these carriers can provide military cargo movement and troop transportation to anywhere in the world on short notice in the event of a military conflict. In order for airlines to join the CRAF, they must commit at least 30 percent of their long-range passenger fleet and 15 percent of their long-range cargo planes (Fact Sheet, 2004). These aircraft must also be U.S. registered, capable of over water operations, and have at least four complete crews assigned for each aircraft (Fact Sheet, 2004). Airlines that participate in CRAF have provided vital support to our military since the Korean War (Graham, David, 2003). The Persian Gulf War was the first official activation of the CRAF, where two thirds of the troops and one quarter of the air cargo was moved by commercial airplanes (Graham, 2003). Though not officially activated, the CRAF is currently supporting Operation Iraqi Freedom, providing nearly double the amount of aircraft that the DoD has estimated for its most demanding war strategies. This paper will provide a brief explanation of the purpose of the CRAF, its history, the effectiveness of the program, and a quick look towards the future of the CRAF.

    Read More

  • The Battle of la Drang in Vietnam

    2025 Words  | 5 Pages

    Throughout the battle, you see numerous Army Values and Warrior Ethos being used. “I will never leave a fallen comrade”, was the etho used the most, to reach the separated platoon. The battle also shows that not all tactical orders are effective, but as a leader you must never second guess yourself.

    Read More

  • Parallel Wars in History

    1297 Words  | 3 Pages

    Thesis. Air War College, 1987. http://www.airwar.edu//a>. Maxwell, Alabama: United States Air Force, 1987. DTIC Online -.

    Read More

  • The Special Forces Chemical Reconnaissance Detachment

    959 Words  | 2 Pages

    I have organized this paper into five distinct sections; mission, task organization, capabilities, limitations, and finally the conclusion. After the reading and comprehension of this paper, you should have gained a basic understanding of the Special Forces (SF) Chemical Reconnaissance Detachments (CRD). The following paper is mixed with Unclassified (UCI) and For Official Use Only (FOUO) information. FOUO is annotated at the beginning of all For Official Use Only information, the rest of the paper is UCI. If you wish to share this information paper with others, please at a minimum; confirm identity of the person prior to providing (FM 380-5, 2000). For further handling instructions please refer to FM 380-5, or contact me, I will gladly answer all questions.

    Read More

  • Technical Escort: Revealed

    984 Words  | 2 Pages

    The Technical Escort Unit (TEU) now provides the Department of Defense and other federal agencies to include the Secret Service and the Federal Bureau of Investigation with an immediate response capability for chemical and biological warfare material. Its mission is to provide a global response for escorting, packaging, detection, rendering-safe, disposing, sampling, analytics, and remediation missions. This does not only include chemical weapons for which it was originally created, but now incorporates biological weapons, state sponsored laboratories, small independent laboratories and small non-weaponized radioactive materials. Most recently, they have been task organized to assist Brigade Combat Teams (BCT) as a force multiplier; the objective of this is to give the Battle Field Commander instant on the ground intelligence regarding Chemical, Biological, Radiological and Nuclear (CBRN) hazards within their Area of Operations (AO). With this new mission with the BCT, the TEU is becoming an expeditionary force.

    Read More

  • A Comparision of Somalia and the United States of America

    1259 Words  | 3 Pages

    Civil War is another shared similarity between both Somalia and the United States. In 1991, following the overthrow of the dictator, Siad Barre, Somalia descended into anarchy. With no government presence to maintain some type of order, clan-based warlords began competing with each other, thus beginning civil unjust. While northern parts of Somalia, as well as the self-declared “Republic of Somaliland,” have remained somewhat peaceful, internal fighting flares up with little to no warning. Since 1991, it is estimated that 350, 000 to 1,000,000 Somalia’s have died due to the lack...

    Read More

  • Military Ethics – Humanitarian Aid in Somalia

    2908 Words  | 6 Pages

    In August of 1992, President George Bush Sr. sent US soldiers into Somalia to provide humanitarian relief to those Somalis suffering from starvation. The major problems in Somalia started when President Mohammed Siad Barre was overthrown by a coalition of opposing clans. Although there were several opposing groups, the prominent one was led by Mohammed Farah Aidid. Following the overthrow of Barre, a massive power struggle ensued. These small scale civil wars led to the destruction of the agriculture in Somalia, which in turn led to the deprivation of food in large parts of the country. When the international community heard of this, large quantities of food were sent to ease Somali suffering. However, clan leaders like Aidid routinely hijacked food and exchanged it for weapons leaving thousands to starve to death. An estimated 300,000 Somalis died between 1991 and 1992 (Clancy 234-236). US soldiers were later sent into Somalia to capture Aidid, but when the operation got bloody, displeasing the American public, Clinton withdrew troops (Battersby 151). In The Morality of War, Brian Orend outlines ethical guidelines that should be followed in all three stages of war: jus ad bellum, jus in bello, and jus post bellum. Orend states that a nation can be moral going into war, but immoral coming out of one. Did the US act justly in all facets of the Somali conflict? The United States espoused all the guiding principles of jus ad bellum but right intent, upheld the principals of jus in bello, and clearly failed to uphold several aspects of jus post bellum during the armed humanitarian intervention in Somalia.

    Read More

  • Army Design Methodology

    1263 Words  | 3 Pages

    In today’s operational environments, the U.S. Army is facing a range of problems and mission sets that are arguably more complex than previously encountered. Forces face an array of demands that encompass geo-political, social, cultural, and military factors that interact in unpredictable ways. The inherent complexity of today’s operations has underscored the need for the Army to expand beyond its traditional approach to operational planning. In March 2010 in FM 5-0: The Operations

    Read More

  • Comparison of the Invasions of Grenada and Mogadishu

    576 Words  | 2 Pages

    The USA has been involved with wars and conflicts since the beginning of its history. Many of these conflicts and wars range from big to small. Two main invasions during the 20th century were the invasions of Grenada in 1983 and Mogadishu, Somalia in 1991. These two invasions had many events that could be deemed successes or failures, but were similar due to the fact that they protected the US and the countries surrounding the conflicts. They also showed the strength of the US army at the time.

    Read More

  • The World War II: Air War

    1189 Words  | 3 Pages

    Lawson, Robert L., and Barrett Tillman. U.S. Navy Air Combat: 1939-1946. Osceola, WI: MBI Pub., 2000. Print.

    Read More

  • Genocide in Somalia: It's Impact on the World

    1263 Words  | 3 Pages

    In order to understand the full scope of genocide in Somalia and how it will affect other countries, we must understand their culture. This way you can determine if any outside assistance, such as the United States giving aid, would be accepted or unwanted. Cultural knowledge can also give outside countries insight to “how” and “when” relationships can` be established.

    Read More

  • Black Hawk Down Essay

    761 Words  | 2 Pages

    At that time in the early 1990’s, the U.S. was the only superpower country left in the world. The Soviet Union collapsed after the Cold War and the left the U.S. at the top. With the U.S. being the only superpower left, it meant that they were the only ones who could try to keep peace between other countries and hopefully end violence in the world. At the time, Somalia was a complete disaster and still is to this day. They have no structural government and warlords rule parts of the country.

    Read More

  • Operation Eagle Claw Failure

    1793 Words  | 4 Pages

    Among the numerous findings of the report was the fact that the US Military lacked the specialized aircraft and air crewman to successfully perform these precarious types of missions. The Holloway Commission also identified the fact that there was no unified command structure, which breached the principle of unity of command. There were separate commanders for site security, ground force, landing support, C-130’s and the helicopter force (Pushies, 2005). Moreover, there was also contention over the replacement of Navy pilots with their Marine counterparts, who were more skilled in over land assault operations, but not night flying. Furthermore, questions were raised regarding the fact that there were over 100 qualified Air Force pilots that could have been chosen but were not. All of these aforementioned concerns would bring about a shift in strategy and pave the way for the creation of the 160th Special Operations Aviation Regiment, or S.O.A.R as we know them today. This concept would be tested while planning and training for the

    Read More

  • The Strengths and Weaknesses of Joint Warfare

    623 Words  | 2 Pages

    Armed with numerous studies, and intensive public hearings, Congress mandated far-reaching changes in DOD organization and responsibilities in the Goldwater-Nichols Department of Defense Reorganization Act of 1986. This landmark legislation significantly expanded the authority and responsibility of the chairman, Joint Chiefs of Staff. Included in this expanded authority and responsibility was the requirement for the chairman to develop a doctrine for the joint employment of armed forces. As operations Urgent Fury, Just Cause, and Desert Storm have vividly demonstrated, the realities of armed conflict in today's world make the integration of individual service capabilities a matter of success or failure, life or death. Furthermore, the operation Desert One demonstrated the need for a strengthened Joint Warfare Doctrine and the consequent change in Joint Warfare Employment. It is plain to see the benefits of having the greatest navy integrated with the world's greatest army and air force. However, even in the wake of a relatively successful joint operation in the Middle East (Desert Storm), certain weaknesses are evident in the current joint employment tactics and/or capabilities. By analyzing past operations such as Urgent Fury and Desert Storm, we are able to see sufficient evidence that the Joint Warfare Concept can be disastrous in one instance and virtually flawless in another.

    Read More

More about The Battle of Mogadishu

Open Document