Gary Steiner, a professor of philosophy at Bucknell University, is a vegan and animal rights activist, and has written a great deal about animal rights. He wrote Animal, Vegetable, Miserable in 2010 for The New York Times to discuss how poorly animals are treated and how humans are brutal towards them whether we mean to be or not. Throughout his piece, he uses strong emotion to connect with his audience, and also appeals to one’s character continuously. However, his tone and lack of reason makes his piece sound irrational.
Veganism revolves around one's character and ethics, which Steiner does a very good job of discussing and using it to back up his argument. In his article, he talks frequently about the ethics and morality regarding animals and how many lack those traits. For a portion of the article he uses the bible as an example of morals and ethics to connect with the audience: after that he uses illustrations from everyday life. One prominent example is when he talks about the fact that nearly fifty-three billion land animals are killed for human consumption and that people are still willing to eat meat after learning that fact(Par.10). These examples are used to effectively connect with the audience and address his argument.
…show more content…
Another way he is able to connect with his audience well is through the appeal to emotion.
Steiner is very passionate about the rights of animals, and makes it clear all throughout the article with active illustrations and tone of voice. His tone expresses a clear understanding and devotion to animal rights, which expresess his emotion clearly with the audience. He also uses examples such as his cat, which shows emotion because it’s his pet that he sees as a friend instead of a source of entertainment for when he is bored(Par.20). Examples like this are used well to demonstrate his emotions in a way that makes sense and backs up his
argument. Steiner uses emotion and appeals to ethics very well in his article, but doesn’t use a lot of logos to back his statements up. He uses very few facts and instead mostly uses ethos and pathos to get his points across. This doesn’t work well though because to effectively connect with the audience, one must give them the textual evidence and appeal to reason. He does use the statistic regarding the number of land animals killed per year to appeal to character, but uses nothing else to back up his argument, making it impotent. Overall Steiner is able to connect well to readers through ethos and pathos, but he lacks the logos to make his piece convincing. The article is well structured to give readers the information they need and gets his argument across. If he used more sources and reason, his piece convincing and have a bigger impact.. However it may be hard for someone to write such a piece when being a vegan is an idea that revolves around ethics and feelings.
From the beginning of the advertisement, we are shown the success of the doctor. The initial shot zooms out from the medical bag which we presume to carry supplies or tools of the medical trade. The doctor then gets into a nice automobile with an “M.D.” addition to his license plate. These signifiers reminds us of his success and authority. During the doctor’s “time out” that is few and far between, he chooses to smoke a Camel cigarette. According to a nationwide survey, more doctors smoke Camels than any other brand. Camels are reported as mild and good tasting. The final shot shows a
In 102 Minutes, Chapter 7, authors Dwyer and Flynn use ethos, logos, and pathos to appeal to the readers’ consciences, minds and hearts regarding what happened to the people inside the Twin Towers on 9/11. Of particular interest are the following uses of the three appeals.
Many characters have hopes and dreams which they wish to accomplish. Of Mice and Men has two main characters that go through obstacles to get what they want. In the beginning it is George and Lennie running away trying to get a job. Once both George and Lennie have a job they try to accomplish their dreams. Unfortunately they both can't get their dreams to come true since lennie does the worst and George has to shoot Lennie. Steinbeck uses characterization, foreshadowing, and symbol as rhetorical strategies to make George's actions justified.
In life, actions and events that occur can sometimes have a greater meaning than originally thought. This is especially apparent in The Secret Life Of Bees, as Sue Monk Kidd symbolically uses objects like bees, hives, honey, and other beekeeping means to present new ideas about gender roles and social/community structures. This is done in Lily’s training to become a beekeeper, through August explaining how the hive operates with a queen, and through the experience Lily endures when the bees congregate around her.
Jonathan Safran Foer wrote “Eating Animals” for his son; although, when he started writing it was not meant to be a book (Foer). More specifically to decide whether he would raise his son as a vegetarian or meat eater and to decide what stories to tell his son (Foer). The book was meant to answer his question of what meat is and how we get it s well as many other questions. Since the book is a quest for knowledge about the meat we eat, the audience for this book is anyone that consumes food. This is book is filled with research that allows the audience to question if we wish to continue to eat meat or not and provide answers as to why. Throughout the book Foer uses healthy doses of logos and pathos to effectively cause his readers to question if they will eat meat at their next meal and meals that follow. Foer ends his book with a call to action that states “Consistency is not required, but engagement with the problem is.” when dealing with the problem of factory farming (Foer).
Rhetorical Analysis of “The Pleasures of Eating” by Wendell Berry In the article by Wendell Berry titled “The Pleasures of Eating” he tries to persuade the readers of the necessity and importance of critical thinking and approach to choosing meals and owning responsibility for the quality of the food cooked. He states that people who are not conscious enough while consuming products, and those who do not connect the concept of food with agricultural products, as people whose denial or avoidance prevents them from eating healthy and natural food. Berry tries to make people think about what they eat, and how this food they eat is produced. He points to the aspects, some which may not be recognized by people, of ethical, financial and
At the beginning of George Orwell’s Animal Farm, an aging pig named Old Major gives a speech to the rest of the animals. In his speech, he explains to them how awful their lives are in order to shows them that the Rebellion against Man, their one true enemy, will come soon. Old Major appeals to the animal’s emotions by using rhetorical questions and fear to effectively persuade the animals of the coming Rebellion.
Steiner believes that eating humanely treated animals is a “profound contradiction” because people are unaware of the effects greater than just how the animals
Manipulation of language can be a weapon of mind control and abuse of power. The story Animal Farm by George Orwell is all about manipulation, and the major way manipulation is used in this novel is by the use of words. The character in this book named Squealer employs ethos, pathos, and logos in order to manipulate the other animals and maintain control.
The subject of death is one that many have trouble talking about, but Virginia Woolf provides her ideas in her narration The Death of the Moth. The moth is used as a metaphor to depict the constant battle between life and death, as well as Woolf’s struggle with chronic depression. Her use of pathos and personification of the moth helps readers develop an emotional connection and twists them to feel a certain way. Her intentional use of often awkward punctuation forces readers to take a step back and think about what they just read. Overall, Woolf uses these techniques to give her opinion on existence in general, and reminds readers that death is a part of life.
“The pen is mightier than the sword.” This is a popular saying that explains that, sometimes, in order to persuade or convince people, one should not use force but words. In Animal Farm, by George Orwell, animals overthrow the human leader and start a new life, but some animals want to become the new leaders. To make the other animals obey the pigs, they first have to persuade the farm’s population. Squealer is the best pig for this job because he effectively convinces the animals to follow Napoleon by using different rhetorical devices and methods of persuasion.
As an advocate of animal rights, Tom Regan presents us with the idea that animals deserve to be treated with equal respect to humans. Commonly, we view our household pets and select exotic animals in different regard as oppose to the animals we perceive as merely a food source which, is a notion that animal rights activists
Albany: State University of New York Press, 1992. Call Number: HV4711.A5751992. Morris, Richard Knowles, and Michael W. Fox, eds. On the Fifth Day, Animal Rights. and Human Ethics.
Herzog, H. A. (1993). “The movement is my life”: The psychology of animal rights activism. Journal of Social Issues, 49, 103-119.
21 Sept. 2011. Freeman, Carrie. The Packwood. " Framing Animal Rights in the "Go Veg" Campaigns of U.S. Animal Rights Organizations.