Wait a second!
More handpicked essays just for you.
More handpicked essays just for you.
Cultural Studies: Two Paradigms - Stuart Hall, 1980
TV and negative influence
TV and its role in shaping public opinion
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Recommended: Cultural Studies: Two Paradigms - Stuart Hall, 1980
c. Case study: race and ethnicity through televisions
This chapter will explain how television works to make the public collective memory. As discussing media, images and its representations, I’ll seek some concepts and ideas from Stuart Hall. This chapter will firstly explain who Stuart Hall is, secondly why I have chosen televisions, race and ethnicity, and finally how television conveys race and ethnicity focusing on images.
Stuart Hall is a sociologist and pioneer in the field of cultural studies. His work explored the concept of Britishness because he lived and worked in the United Kingdom, feeling blackness himself as he was born in Jamaica. For example, his study showed the connection between race and media, such as encoding and decoding
…show more content…
It is necessary to choose one medium in order to make the discussion specifically in this essay. Then, television would be a key medium among several media such as newspapers, radios, films, video games or Internet for these three reasons. Firstly, television is relatively new media. When On collective memory was published in 1950, television has not yet spread around the world and has not been popular as people in the middle class could not afford to watch televisions. Halbwachs were not able to expect the rise of mass media, and he did not include them in his logic. So it is worth taking television into considering. Secondly, television has many viewers around the world. A wide range of people sees the television, not only the young but also the elderly. So, it has a socially wide impact on the whole world. Thirdly, television tells the news through pictures. Newspapers tell a story with words and sometimes with pictures, but the pictures are only a part of information. On the other hand, television tells news through the movie, in other words, with continuous pictures. The use of pictures is a central debate on collective memory and on the next discussion of Stuart …show more content…
At first, I would like to make my stance about race and ethnicity. I would not discuss what race and ethnicity mean here because there are huge discussions in Anthropology. Based on the course of Anthropology of Ethnicity and Race in KUL that I took last semester, in short, race and ethnicity are the concepts that socially and historically constructed. How they identify themselves is largely decided by how others look them. And Hall stated (1973), “For television or radio’s “mode of identifying social reality” is not and cannot be a wholly neutral and objective process.” and “viewers come, not simply to ‘know what is happening’, but to construct from that knowledge “pictures of the world”, scenarios of action.” Audiences make an image of the world that they don’t know, but in a way that they believe they should be. These images fix people’s views on how they see and how they are seen at the same time, as a result, that viewpoints identify others. Ethnicity or race are empty vessels that socially and historically constructed and they depend on their awareness themselves because nobody could clarify the meaning. For these reasons, they are one of the most changeable, fragile and easily affected identities among other
Recitations of historic attempts initiated to biologically define differences in race and ethnicity culminated in the “Revised UNESCO Statement on Race” in 1995. The realization that ethnicity and race represent a culmination in more areas of commonality than in areas of differences, manifesting in th...
The conflict between race and ethnicity came up throughout the time I administered my questionnaires. In the questionnaires, many people questioned what they should respond to for the question which referenced their “race” or “ethnicity”. Some people saw it as a division and how the terms can be used as a negative term or a positive term to label a group of people.
Race, which is another characteristic of demographic data, is a modern occurrence. It is being questioned and more than likely not a valid determinant. Our textbook in chapter five states, “racial identity or race consciousness is both controversial and pervasive. When early explorers in the 15th and 16th centuries came across people who were different from them a debate began which groups were “human” and which were “animal” (pg. 191).
Omi claims that media and popular culture are two of the main culprits for the dissemination of a segregation ideology through music, movies and TV shows (Omi 114). According to Omi, media has the “ability to reflect the dominant racial ideology” and to “shape that ideology in first place” (Omi 115). These two sentences imply that Omi is not just blaming on media, but also on white people, who dominate communications and provide a better image of themselves in order to maintain the status of dominant culture. Moreover, Omi uses the concept of “representation” to claim that even the popular culture, which was supposed to be created by the people, brings segregating ideology on itself and do not contribute to the celebration of cultural diversity (Omi 120). Omi explains this belief of “representation” as a tool of segregation when stating that jokes and songs “reinforce stereotypes and rationalize the existing relations of social inequality” (Omi 121). Media and popular culture are outsiders, meaning that are not racist themselves, but according to Omi they are the main incentive to
There is a specific meaning to race and how its role impacts society and shapes the social structures. Race is a concept that “symbolizes social conflicts and interests by referring to different types of human bodies” (Omi & Winant 55). In other words, Omi and Winant get down to the crux of the issue and assert that race is just an illusion. Race is merely seen as an ideological construct that is often unstable and consisting of decentered social meanings. This form of social construction attempts to explain the physical attributes of an individual but it is constantly transformed by political struggles. The rules of classifying race and of identity are embedded into society’s perception. Therefore, race becomes a common function for comprehending, explaining, and acting in the
Kourvetaris, A. G. (2009). Perspectives on ethnicity, gender and race and their empirical referents: a four-sided paradigm and critical review. International Review Of Sociology, 19(1), 127-146. doi:10.1080/03906700802613988
Boylorn, R. M. (2008). As seen on tv: An autoethnographic reflection on race and reality television. Critical Studies in Media Communication, 25 (4), 413-433.
Woll, Allen L and Randall M Miller. Ethnic and Racial Images in American Film and Television: Historical Essays and Bibliography. n.d. Print.
Through research of DNA samples, scientists have been able to declare that race is not biologically constructed due to the similarities between human genes. Nevertheless, in reality, people still emphasized on biological aspects such as skin color, or hair texture to categorize others into different races. This in turn, denied the true identity of race, which it is culturally constructed. Ethnicity, by definition is also culturally constructed, therefore it greatly resemble race. There is no real clear line to distinct the two.
In the past, races were identified by the imposition of discrete boundaries upon continuous and often discordant biological variation. The concept of race is therefore a historical construct and not one that provides either valid classification or an explanatory process. Popular everyday awareness of race is transmitted from generation to generation through cultural learning. Attributing race to an individual or a population amounts to applying a social and cultural label that lacks scientific consensus and supporting data. While anthropologists continue to study how and why humans vary biologically, it is apparent that human populations differ from one another much less than do populations in other species because we use our cultural, rather than our physical differences to aid us in adapting to various environments.
Race and Ethnicity According to Anthropologists Examining the ideas and beliefs within ones own cultural context is central to the study of Anthropology. Issues of Race and Ethnicity dominate the academic discourses of various disciplines including the field of Anthropology. Race and Ethnicity are controversial terms that are defined and used by people in many different ways. This essay shall explore the ways in which Anthropologists make a distinction between race and ethnicity and how these distinctions serve as frames for cross-cultural comparison and analysis. It is important to accurately define these coined terms before one is able to make accurate comparisons and distinctions between them, and their relation to the concept of culture.
During the 18 century, people divided humans based on where they live and skin color like Europeans as “white”, Africans as “black”, Indians as “red”, and Asians as “yellow”. For example, in Haiti, color has been the dominant force in social and political life. Skin texture, facial feature, hair color, and socioeconomic class together play a role in placement. The anthropological perspective define race as members of a society have similar biological traits. These members are diverse from other members of society because of these traits. In the end, the race concept is not acceptable to humans but it is used as a cultural classification. ...
One effect TV has had on how we view things is in the area of advertisement. A few weeks ago in English, my class had quite a discussion on the subject of commercials. A person can tell what type of society they live in by simply watching the commercials during any TV program. One example, in America, is the numerous ads for various types of medication. From this, it is easy to see that our society cares a lot about health care and making sure that they feel healthy.
Racial and ethnic diversity on television is not something that I have ever really noticed as a problem, but sitting down, and paying very close attention to the people, their roles in the show, I was able to see that there was a lack of diversity on TV. I chose a random TV channel, one that I probably would not watch, and studied the characters in the show and in the commercials for over two hours, I realized that I had never paid that much attention to the people in the show. I noticed after I was done that the largest group of people in the show and on the commercials, were white people, although there was some diversity, maybe one or two people of a different nationality, gender, or race, that overall the lack of diversity was minimal compared
Race and ethnicity are two terms that are constantly used in today’s society. Understanding these terms can help people to recognize that color of skin or color of hair does not define a person. These terms connect with history, social interaction, and the overall make up of a person. However America is constantly obsessed with labeling people by the way that they look or the way that they act. America seems to encourage the terms race and ethnicity and continue to divide people into categories. It is interesting to comprehend these terms because they are not going to disappear any time soon. Race and ethnicity are apart of America’s history and will be a part of the future.