More handpicked essays just for you.
Is it ethical to conduct tests on animals
The ethics around animal testing
Animal experimentation ethical dilemmas
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
Project Nim: Knowledge or Nagging?
Project Nim is a documentary about an experiment that took place in the 1970’s. This certain experiment was created to test whether or not animals other than humans would be able to learn and use language in the same way that human beings can. It was focused around a chimpanzee named Nim, and was led by a man named Herbert Terrace. Nim was brought into a loving family home, and he was raised as if he were a new member of the family. Terrace, himself later concluded that the experiment did not turn out the way that he had predicted. There are multiple instances in the film Project Nim that show Nim “understanding” and responding to American Sign Language. While this was fascinating to witness, there is no way to prove whether or not he was comprehending the signs, or just reacting in the way that he was taught to respond. This is where
…show more content…
The same is true when training any animal, whether they are usually housepets, or not. If animals know that a treat or reward is involved, they will obey, no matter the circumstances. In Nim’s case, it is clear that he was trained extremely well. He was also shown how to sign words such as “drink”, “eat”, “toilet”, “play”, and “Nim” using American Sign Language. In Nim’s mind, if he made a certain shape with his hands, he would be able to receive a reward. It was said that Nim picked up on the signs he was taught very quickly, and that he would even find ways to use the signs to his own advantage. For example, in times that Nim was feeling aroused, he would use the signs he was taught for the words “hug” or “cat”. Also, in situations where Nim felt uncomfortable, he would use the sign for the word “toilet”. This goes to show that Nim never entirely understood what he was signing, but rather understood the reaction he would get to the certain words he
He claimed that since chimpanzees naturally used a gestural form of communication it made sense that they would also be able to learn sign language. Gestural forms of communication would have likely been used by our common ancestor as well. However, once the larynx migrated in our throat, and our tongues became more mobile, it allowed us to create complex sounds for spoken language. Evolutionarily speaking, these traits were likely selected for genetic changes to better our language skills to survive. The ability to exchange ideas provides greater
Tanya Lewis Staff Writer. Chimps Learn Tool Use by Watching Others. 30 January 2013. Report. 25 April 2014. .
I even after going through our American Sign Language course, I still was able to find things in this video surprising. For instance, I found it surprising that Alexander Graham Bell taught deaf children and that his wife and mother were both deaf themselves.
Your puppy may believe you gave the reward mainly because it was looking upwards, or there is movement from your dog's ears to signify interest. So, rewarding your canine friend was carried out, but nevertheless, the specific required behavior wasn't reinforced.
NIMS is a uniform set of processes and procedures that emergency responders at all levels of government will use to conduct response operations. NIMS helps improve cooperation and interoperability among organizations. The framework is adaptable and accessible. It encourages all hazards preparedness. NIMS enables a variety of organizations to contribute successfully in emergency management and incident response. NIMS creates uniform professional emergency management and incident response practices.
“Tool use is rare in animals, and the chimpanzees stand out as the most proficient tool users besides humans” (Boesh, Boesch-Achermann18). Some debate has taken place between researchers regarding how these chimpanzees learn to use these tools and whether or not there is a difference between wild chimps and captive chimp’s tool use. Some theories say that chimps do not actively teach or are taught, but rather learn by observation, trial, and error; as stated in the article Thinking Like a Chimpanzee by Jon Cohen. This article also suggests that some reaserchers do believe that chimps do poses the capability to be taught and understand what they are learning.
Many studies supporting the use of baby sign language had participant samples that were too small, nor were the participants randomly assigned to control groups (Kirk, Howlett, Pine, & Fletcher, 2012). Also, these children could have already been advanced learners to begin with (Kirk, Howlett, Pine, & Fletcher, 2012). Some baby signing studies were original studies and others were meta-analyses ( Johnston, Durieux-Smith, & Bloom, 2005). Johnston, Durieux-Smith and Bloom (2005), for example, conducted a review of literature regarding the effectiveness of teaching children (not able to speak yet) to use symbolic gestures. Seventeen out of 1,208 reports met their criteria. Only 8 articles were of original studies. Out of those articles, five of them were case studies. Also, four articles were longitudinal studies and one was a ...
In chapter thirteen, Walker and Shipman dug into if Homo erectus, specifically "Nariokotome Boy," could verbally communicate amongst each other. They studied the size of the vertebral canal. The canal was to narrow, meaning the boy received less information from his senses. While Walker was trying to figure out what the small canal meant for the boy he attended a lecture. The lecture used PET scans to look at the differences when a person reads, hears, or speaks a word. The demonstrated activity helped him understand that language didn't trigger " asymmetric brain activity" when turning thoughts into words. By looking at deaf babies, it confirmed that language is not the same thing as speech. Babies, as well as trained apes, can use "proto-language,"
Had he understood the importance of fostering a relationship with the dog, a native Husky with inbred instincts regarding the native climate, the dog would have interacted differently with him, maybe warning him of the danger of the weather through its actions or perhaps providing help, either by sharing its body heat or by going for help. However, instead he held little regard for the dog and the dog reciprocated: "there was no keen intimacy between the dog and the man. So it made no effort to communicate its apprehension to the man".
Project Nim is a documentary that explains an experiment that took place in the 1970s in an attempt to teach a chimp who was named Nim Chimpsky American Sign Language (ASL). This project set out to analyze whether chimpanzees like Nim had the ability to use language in such a way that indicated that they understood it at a similar level of humans (Terrace book pg 31). Although the researcher, Herbert Terrace, who initiated this experimental investigation concluded that Nim's use of sign language was not consistent with human language and he was unable to form sentences in complex ways (Terrace 2014). Therefore, Nim was able to repeat the signs that he had learned from his teachers, but this could not be classified as a form of language in the
Some dogs are simply stubborn. With these types, it may take extra diligence on your part to succeed in training. Keep your dog leashed, even in house. By having a tether to your dog, you can easily redirect him from doing something he shouldn't without having to always revert to a time-out in the his crate.
The tragic case of feral child Genie provides a unique perspective on the roles of socialization and physiology in language acquisition during the critical period. After 11 years of isolation and abuse Genie was discovered possessing no known language, having already passed what was theorized to be the critical period. Through examining Genie’s diagnosed mental retardation and dichotic testing, we can draw conclusions from her physical abuse and social isolation as it pertains to language development during the critical period. Using the example of Genie’s stalled linguistic development, her language acquisition compared to both normal children and late learners of American sign language (ASL), the role of exposure and socialization and brain lateralization, this paper will demonstrate support of the theory of critical period for language
You will realize that dogs are normally curious by nature and wants to learn something new. Dogs can also be instinctive at times. Training them will go a long way in ensuring that your dog uses its brains
middle of paper ... ... ceive the trainer in white and pay attention to instructions given by the trainer in green. The chimpanzee successfully got the food most of the time. This supports the idea that non-human animals are capable of deceit. The characteristics of this behaviour are very like a conditioned behaviour.
This meant that humans have a built in mechanism to help them recognise and speak language. Chomsky believed that children simply neede... ... middle of paper ... ... rmal language acquisition early in life. q Sachs reported the case of Jim, whose parents deaf but who was surrounded by spoken language from the television and radio in the hope that he would learn normal language.