Philippe De Vitry Vs Machaut Analysis

733 Words2 Pages

The isorhythmic motet is a compositional style that emerged from the movement Ars Nova in the fourteenth century. It is defined based on the use of a talea, a repeated rhythmic pattern, to the main melody of a motet that is the color or the melodic pattern. Philippe de Vitry and Guillaume Machaut are the two most representative composers of this music style. Both composers wrote sacred and secular music in a variety of styles. For the purpose of analysis, the pieces Cum statua/Hugo, Hugo/Magister invidie composed by Philippe de Vitry in 1320 and Felix virgo / Inviolata / Ad Te Suspiramus composed by Guillaume de Machaut in 1360 will serve as a subject of comparison and contrast to determine the characteristics of isorhythmic motet from …show more content…

In this style of composition, it was very common for composers to use a Gregorian chant as a base to compose original pieces. As a general rule, the tenor voice sang the Gregorian chant, and the upper voices have new original material. Machaut followed this line by putting the chant Ad te suspiramus gementes et flentes on the tenor voice in his piece; whereas, Philippe De Vitry composed original music for all voices. Although the piece by De Vitry is called a motet, it might be just labeled as a polyphonic composition since all the voices have original music.
Themes in both pieces differ even though they are related to a religious subject. There is a biblical context in both pieces. For instance, Guillaume Machaut expresses devotion to the Virgin Mary in the lyrics. To illustrate, the composer wrote the following text for the motetus voice:
The lyrics are very straightforward, and all the voices have similar texts which are dedicated to the Virgin Mary. Then, the poetry written on the piece by De Vitry has some biblical context as well; however, it seems to be more about a personal argument.
In either case, both pieces agree with the concept of a motet because although this music style was more expected to be heard in churches, it started as a composition of secular

Open Document