Musee des Beux Arts by W.H Auden and Anne Sexton´s To a Friend Whose Come to Triumph

825 Words2 Pages

Greek mythology had always been an interest of mine. The poem Musee des Beux Arts by W.H Auden and Anne Sexton’s To a Friend Whose Come to Triumph are both based on the myth of Icarus both poet based their poetry on a painting by Pieter Brueghel on The Landscape of The Fall of Icarus. W.H Auden was enamored by Brueghel’s painting that he wrote about it. Anne Sexton’s poem was a poetical response to William Butler Yeats poem’s To a Friend Whose Work Has Come to Nothing

Both Auden and Sexton’s poems are based on life. Audens’s Poem leans more about the indifference of others sufferings in which offers a pragmatic vision of the ways innocence and passivity is one and the same. Sexton’s poem leans more on seizing the day, taking chances, and living in the moment. The outcome of the poems is similar but the message that both poet tries to convey are different.

Auden used simplistic and descriptive languages as imagery, for example on line 4 In Auden’s poem, “While someone else is eating or opening a window or just walking dully along;” he layered multiple occurrences on top of another, creating portraits of everyday life. The “Old Masters” that he had eluded in the second line of the poem is the “Old Masters” of the art world. The rest of the poem is in reference to Pieter Brueghel’s painting “The landscape with the fall of Icarus”. Its allusion comforts and gives a specific image to the readers. This poem was written in free verse with no metrical pattern. The reference to “Old Masters” and museums and old paintings creates a tension with the simple language and mundane qualities of Auden's form. The disparity between the two is an intentional move, one intended to demonstrate how even simple subjects and language can be pa...

... middle of paper ...

... First, she instructs the reader to "Consider Icarus"(1). Next, she commands with an exclamation to, "Think of the difference it made!"(4) and to "Admire his wings!" From this diction, we find she is quite earnest in her mindset, and eager for the reader to understand her point of view. Finally, when she says, "Who cares...""(12) shows that Icarus' experience was, to Anne Sexton, completely worth the price that he paid.

While Anne Sexton obviously thought Icarus was admirable for his risk-taking, I think this opinion is atypical. After all, the author intended this to be a lesson; Icarus was the one who disobeyed his father. He deserved to drown; he had been informed of the consequences before. The flight was a method of escape, not a pleasure trip. I think most people, contrary to Anne Sexton's point of view, would side against Icarus and his defiant ways.

Open Document