John Barker's Ancestral Lines: A Catalogical Analysis

1471 Words3 Pages

When it comes to an anthropologists’ written works, such as ethnographies, they tend to focus on certain topics. These topics vary depending on the anthropologist and their research. Some topics are more prevalent than others as they appear frequently and connect to other concepts. In John Barker’s book, Ancestral Lines: The Maisin Of Papua New Guinea And The Fate Of The Rainforest, it is apparent that kinship and reciprocity and exchange are the most crucial concepts as they are vital to Maisin culture and their everyday lives. Among all the other concepts mentioned in his ethnography, Barker spends a significant amount of time explaining kinship. Traditionally, kinship has been viewed as being associated with biological blood ties with …show more content…

Strong ties and alliances are built up when people’s offspring get together, but there is something else that keeps the two bound together. It all has to do with reciprocity an exchange. Reciprocity is the act of presenting something to an individual with a belief that they also give something in return (Toner 2015: 39). It is essentially the exchange of something between two individuals, though it can have more implications beyond giving things. As Carrier states, “exchange can also create relationships of kinship” and that “some argue that exchange is a key to social life” (Carrier 2010: 272, 274). These statements also ring true in Maisin culture and everyday …show more content…

To illustrate, reciprocity can be helpful in resolving conflict and fix a relationship. In the film “Ongka’s Big Moka”, Ongka used reciprocity to make amends and hopefully avoid conflict with the neighbouring village after a recent death. He gave a wild pig and a branch from a plant. (Nairn 1974). Gift giving can also commence relations or show a person’s interest or disinterest in having a relationship. During Barker’s stay he experiences and sees the three different types of reciprocity: generalized reciprocity, balanced reciprocity, and negative reciprocity. In his encounter with a ‘regular visitor’ he learns of marawa-wawe, a form of generalized reciprocity when he received a gift ‘out of love’ (ibid: 50). This form of reciprocity is given in hopes of forming a friendship and depending on how one responds it can either keep it going or make them appear as if they are complete strangers. Barker learns this when dealing with his friend Rufus as he would quickly give a ‘gift’ back to him. Thus, he unknowingly demonstrated a negative form of reciprocity, which is done quickly and holds little trust in the other party (Barker 2016: 56). So instead of seeming friendly it appeared as though Barker wanted nothing to do with Rufus. All of these exchanges contain meanings that are important to the Maisins’ lifestyles and relationships

More about John Barker's Ancestral Lines: A Catalogical Analysis

Open Document