How attitudes towards studying children have evolved

1138 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Childhood as a social construct

This assignment intends to identify how attitudes towards studying children have been evolving over time, whilst also identifying three key principles which should be aspired to when implementing such research. A range of theoretical perspectives and methodologies shall also be explored with examination on children’s roles and their involvement being evident throughout.

Researching children is in no way a new phenomenon however there has been a considerable shift in paradigm which has led to increasing amounts of research being carried out ‘with’ children rather than ‘on’ children (Christensen and James, 2008). This could be because of the growing interest in children’s rights to participate (James and Prout, 1997), which as suggested by O’kane (2008) occurred in the late 1980’s. However it is difficult to determine whether this shift in paradigm occurred as a result of natural changes in researcher’s attitudes or as a direct result of new legislation (2008). As at a similar time, in 1989, the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child (1989) (UNCRC ) was enforced, giving children the right to participate and be heard in matters affecting their lives. This difficulty is evident by Schaffer (1990) suggesting developmental theories have strongly influenced policies thus indicating, as researcher’s knowledge on children and childhood develop attitudes and policy change. In contrast O’Kane (2008, p.125) states “changes reflect an acknowledgement of children’s rights”.

Views on childhood have and still continue to change (Waller, 2009). The contemporary view that children are empty vessels (Skinner, 1974) is being disregarded as children are no longer perceived as passive recipients in an adult world (O’Kane, 2008...

... middle of paper ...

...exist as if the researcher were to allow the cost to the individual to be weighed out by the benefit towards society (ref) the whole study would be compromised with both the researcher and their research losing validity in the eyes of others (Green, 2003).

In conclusion this assignment has identified that attitudes towards studying children have and still continue to change, although it is evident attitudes are still dominated by a western perspective and some changes have been more embraced than others. The findings within this assignment support the view that children now have a participatory role within research, however it also identifies that participation is only possible if the researchers fully embrace children as competent beings and aspires to the key principles of consent, listening and responding to children and adheres to ethical codes of conduct.

Show More
Related

  • The Changes of Canadian Children Since the 1800's

    1810 Words  | 4 Pages

    The world has experienced many changes in past generations, to the present. One of the very most important changes in life had to be the changes of children. Historians have worked a great deal on children’s lives in the past. “While we try to teach our children all about life, our children teach us what life is all about.”- Author Unknown

    Read More

  • Content Analysis and Ethnographic Research in Decoding Children’s Understanding of Friendship

    1416 Words  | 3 Pages

    Research in any given area can yield many different results despite having the same aim. Varying results of separate studies may be due to different circumstances and conditions that surround them. Both Bigelow and La Gaipa and Corsaro differed in their conclusions (Brownlow, 2012). However, both had a similar aim in as much as they wanted to research how children understood friendship. By contrast, how and whether previous studies influenced them differed. The work of Bigelow and La Gaipa was not rooted in any background or tradition of research. They carried out their work in 1975 and at that time most studies about children had centred on attraction. Therefore, the work that they did was among the first of its kind. In addition to being an original piece of research, it also had validity because subsequent individuals carried out similar work. One such person was William Damon with the research he did in 1977 (Brownlow, 2012). Damon was also studying children’s friendships and as a conseq...

    Read More

  • Child Welfare Policy in Canada

    1047 Words  | 3 Pages

    Maybin, J. &Woodhead, M. (2003). Childhoods in context. Southern Gate, Chichester: John Wiley & Sons Ltd

    Read More

  • John Bowlby's Attachment Theory

    2463 Words  | 5 Pages

    ...even years parents must give informed consent as the child may not have the cognitive ability to understand what is being asked of them’ Institute of Medicine (2004 cited in Keenen and Evans, 2010:78). There are also incentives for the child which should be fair and not excessive. The idea of deception means that certain studies may require the researcher to hold back certain information however the researcher must show that such deception is necessary and justifiable. An important ethic is confidentiality where records of research should be kept in such a way to ensure participant confidentiality. However if some information reveals the child’s welfare is at risk then parents should be informed. Finally there is dissemination in early years practice the child is often too young to understand research findings so a summary should be given to the child’s parents.

    Read More

  • Childhood as a Social and Historical Construction

    2111 Words  | 5 Pages

    According to Philippe Aris a famous sociologist who studied childhood saw it as a social and historical construction (Montgomery 2009) he believed childhood did not really exist until the sixtieth century before that children had been treated as small and inadequate adults (Penn 2008). Sociologist Rinaldi also believed that it is society and different times in history that created childhood (Neaum 2010) Mayall believes children lives are lived through childhoods constructed for them by adults understanding of children and what children are and should be (Kehily 2009) a sociologist who has a different idea would be James and Prout 1990 who believe childhood is both ...

    Read More

  • Childhood Observation Essay

    714 Words  | 2 Pages

    One of the children (George) created a map, that did not look like a physical representation of the children outdoor area, when his partner asked what he was drawing he explained he was using his imagination. The ‘water represents the big children’s playground, our area is the island, the dotted line is where we have to find the word treasure, that’s hidden under the X!’ George’s partner Pedro looked puzzled and asked me why he was doing it wrong. I explained that George was not doing it wrong, it is his interpretation of his outdoor area, and this is how he imagines it. This allowed me to be reflexive and flexible as a researcher, and to ensure at all times the child’s voice was being heard, and that I was not shaping the research to the outcome I wanted. I also thought this was a lovely example of children’s imagination. The child’s outdoor area can represent a number of things to them as expressed through George map. As adults we will never think how children do, or how we once did (Christensen, 2004). Child lead learning and child participation is increasingly being valued, as reflected in the literature. The map-making activity was a superb way to extend the pupils critical thinking, contributing to their communication and language development. Examples from my observation reflect the impact the

    Read More

  • The Social Construction of Childhood

    2204 Words  | 5 Pages

    While all societies acknowledge that children are different from adults, how they are different, changes, both generationally and across cultures. “The essence of childhood studies is that childhood is a social and cultural phenomenon” (James, 1998). Evident that there are in fact multiple childhoods, a unifying theme of childhood studies is that childhood is a social construction and aims to explore the major implications on future outcomes and adulthood. Recognizing childhood as a social construction guides exploration through themes to a better understanding of multiple childhoods, particularly differences influencing individual perception and experience of childhood. Childhood is socially constructed according to parenting style by parents’ ability to create a secure parent-child relationship, embrace love in attitudes towards the child through acceptance in a prepared environment, fostering healthy development which results in evidence based, major impacts on the experience of childhood as well as for the child’s resiliency and ability to overcome any adversity in the environment to reach positive future outcomes and succeed.

    Read More

  • Early Emotional Child Development

    2349 Words  | 5 Pages

    The child has not been perceived like an individual until the work of eighteen century philosophers Locke and Rousseau, who expressed their thoughts on paper about the child's ability to interact with the surrounding world (Cunningham, 1993). The research on child development has commenced followed by the observational work of changing behaviours in organisms by Charles Darwin.

    Read More

  • Ethical And Conduct Research With Vulnerable Groups

    752 Words  | 2 Pages

    This essay will contain a critical discussion of ‘vulnerability’, and whether it can ever be ethical to conduct research with vulnerable groups. This essay will look into anonymity, confidentiality and informed consent and why it is important to use these when conducting research. It will also discuss safety and risk for researchers and the participants to ensure the research is carried out without harm. This assignment will concentrate widely on ethics and vulnerability in relation to children.

    Read More

  • History of Childhood

    2203 Words  | 5 Pages

    ...he notion of childhood has changed throughout time and that conception of how a child should act or be over the decades has turned into an ideology of child-centeredness. He believes that once the established childhood began to emerge, its ideals and surroundings started to change in society too. However, Bob Corbett (1985) states that if childhood was a creation made by Society and children acted as they were expected to, the new concept of childhood would change how children acted and make them act as society presently wanted them to act. During the Romantic period a new concept of childhood arose, this was the key factor do determine this modern approach which emphasized the innocence and the individuality of the children, giving relevance to the way how children from both gender should be educated and the way parents should approach and treat their children.

    Read More

  • Social Reproduction in Society

    1000 Words  | 2 Pages

    Wells, Karen C.. "rescuing children and children's rights." Childhood in a global perspective. Cambridge, UK: Polity Press, 2009. 168-169. Print.

    Read More

  • Essay On Disappearance Of Childhood

    2698 Words  | 6 Pages

    There are proponents of the debate that childhood is disappearing which will be discussed in this section which include Postman (1983), Elkind (1981) and Palmer (2006). In considering these points of view which are mostly American, one must firstly set in context what is meant by the disappearance or erosion of childhood. This key debate centres on Postman (1983) who wrote “The disappearance of childhood” which is a contentious book about how childhood as a social category which is separate from adulthood is eroding. He defines a point where childhood came into existence, which was treated as a special phase in the middle ages based on the work of Aries in his book “Centuries of childhood” (1962, cited in Postman 1983). According to Postman, a major influence on how childhood was perceived differently to adulthood was the invention of the printing press and literacy in the mid sixteenth century. That is to say children had to learn to read before the secrets of adulthood in particular sex and violence was available...

    Read More

  • The Concept of Childhood Innocence

    1554 Words  | 4 Pages

    Abstract In this essay, I intend to explain how everyday lives challenge the construction of childhood as a time of innocence. In the main part of my assignment, I will explain the idea of innocence, which started with Romantic discourse of childhood and how it shaped our view of childhood. I will also look at two contradictory ideas of childhood innocence and guilt in Blake’s poems and extract from Mayhew’s book. Next, I will compare the images of innocence in TV adverts and Barnardo’s posters. After that, I will look at the representation of childhood innocence in sexuality and criminality, and the roles the age and the gender play in portraying children as innocent or guilty. I will include some cross-cultural and contemporary descriptions on the key topics. At the end of my assignment, I will summarize the main points of the arguments.

    Read More

  • Stages of Development: Middle Childhood

    2364 Words  | 5 Pages

    Wertlieb, Donald. "Child." World Book Advanced. World Book, 2011. Web. 16 Aug. 2011.Retrieved from http://www.worldbookonline.com/advanced/article?id=ar110700&st=middle+childhood+development&sc=1#h4

    Read More

  • Why Are Parents Unintentionally Coercing Children To Participate In Research

    1122 Words  | 3 Pages

    Adults are obligated to respect children’s rights to participate in research, but in doing so it is imperative that adults are not unintentionally coercing children into participation. Adults and researchers must be aware of the power imbalances that are active during the research process and to do everything they can to equalize these imbalances. Researchers need to give children the tools they need to know that participation is voluntary and that they may withdraw their participation at anytime. Researchers also need to emphasize that there are no wrong answers and children are allowed to express their opinion and answers freely.

    Read More

More about How attitudes towards studying children have evolved

Open Document