More handpicked essays just for you.
Comparing and contrasting v for vendetta and 1984
Comparing and contrasting v for vendetta and 1984
Comparing and contrasting v for vendetta and 1984
Don’t take our word for it - see why 10 million students trust us with their essay needs.
The dystopian novel “1984” and the movie “V for Vendetta”, share a variety of differences and similarities alike.
Both have a totalitarian government in which have absolute power over politics, religion and human rights. Extensive speech, critical thinking, thoughtful writing, and voice of opinion has either been restricted or limited in
1984’s Oceania and V for Vendetta’s future London. The protagonist in both novel and film have “resisted” to their government. However, the methods used to employ their “rebellion” are quite different. In 1984 a much more subtle approach is used rather than V for Vendetta's anarchistic like attack. Although their strategies may be different, the goal of overturning the government is clear. In both works , the government is depicted a totalitarian government. Control and power over its citizens is evident in 1984. “Power is in tearing human minds to pieces and putting them together again in new shapes of your own choosing.” Big
Brother uses manipulation of language in order to limit expression. If one can't express feelings through language or literature than self-expression is suppressed.
In 1984 , Big Brother wishes to eliminate “Oldspeak” or standard English with Newspeak which is a much diluted and simplified version. If the terminology isn't there, then the result would impact all literature that the common man comprehends. That being stated, people wouldn’t be capable of rebellion since they don't know what it is .
In “
V for Vendetta “ Fear became the ultimate tool of this government”. Adam Sutler is able to create a constant fear factor in the citizen’s mind by filtering everything that the media broadcasts. The attack on Old Bailey and Jordan Tower was named a “terrorist” act. V was l...
... middle of paper ...
...nto believing that sex is only a duty to the party. The Inner Party’s goal is to remove such pleasure from the act to completely erase basic human instinct. Only having intercourse to increase party members. “Fulfill their duty to the Party” as Winston’s wife said. Which is why when Winston met Julia , their disobedience sparked his resistance even further. Discrimination amongst homosexuals is shown in V for Vendetta as Valarie Page was sent to resettlement camps due to her sexual preference. All in order to control the lives of every individual. 1984 and V for Vendetta are much alike. Both portraying a dismal future. One can take it as a joke or a wake up call. There is a time to revolt the higher power. “People shouldn't be afraid of their government.
Governments should be afraid of their people.” Illiteracy and ignorance are the downfall of our human society.
In the book “1984” by George Orwell, Big Brother has the power to decide what is real and what is not. The citizens of Oceania are told not to use their own knowledge to gather facts or information, but to get their information from Big Brother, and the party. This show that the party has great control over its citizens. Big Brother’s power can decide what is real and what is not.
In “1984,” Orwell portrays Winston’s secret struggle to undermine the totalitarian rule of Big Brother and the Party in Oceania. The different government agencies, such as the Thought Police and Ministry of Love, exercise unrestricted totalitarian rule over people. Winston actively seeks to join the rebellion and acquire the freedoms undermined by the Party. On the other hand, Heinlein’s brief narrative, “The Long Watch,” depicts a contrasting struggle championed by Dahlquist against the power hungry Colonel Towers and the Patrol. In his struggle to prevent the total domination of the world by the Patrol, Dahlquist chooses to sacrifice his life. Le Guin’s “The Ones who walk away from Omelas,” illustrates a communal form of injustice tolerated for the benefit of the entire city but necessitating the inhumane imprisonment of a child. He portrays the ambiguity of human morality and the individual struggle to determine right from wrong. The authors address social change and power in different ways, reflective of their individual perceptions. Hence, in each narrative, the author illustrates the individual’s role in effecting social change and the conditions under which such change becomes possible.
The Struggle for Power in 1984, Fahrenheit 451, Invisible Man, Julius Caesar, and Lord Of The Flies
The perfect society always exist in one form or another in everyone’s minds. The only problem with this is that no one ever thinks about the negatives of these societies. Comparing and contrasting this book and movie will show us how great and how terrible these places really are. The book 1984 and the movie Minority Report, have many striking differences as well as similarities. These differences and similarities can be seen throughout the setting, main characters, and themes in both 1984 and Minority Report.
Within both the Brave New World by Aldous Huxley and V for Vendetta it can be concluded that the leaders of the governments included in both are some of these people. They have their own ways more often than not unethical and violent put in place in an effort to obtain the power to which the crave so very much. Also, they have their own methods to discourage those against them whose agenda may contradict with their own, again the methods are often unethical. Both Governments operating within the book Brave New World and V for Vendetta use a plethora of different things to manipulate those lower in society than them. A constant method in both A Brave New World and V for Vendetta includes some sort of crooked or manipulated law enforcement. Also, in both the information given to the media outlets and general public by the government is usually coerced or twisted in order for the government to make themselves look better or to hide
In 1984 and V for Vendetta, the different behaviours of the anti-heroes, Winston and V, illustrate their approach to attaining freedom from the totalitarian government. George Orwell’s 1984 and James McTeigue’s V for Vendetta use the anti-heroes’ behaviour to identify their approach to their cause—liberation from the totalitarian government. For example, Winston is the typical citizen who rebels against the government in a quiet and peaceful way, whereas V is a revolutionist in an excited and violent way. This comparison helps classify the key behaviours, which explains the different approaches the anti-heroes took towards liberation.
The 1984 community provided many ways to surveill its citizens, one being The Thought Police The Thought Police were undercover operatives who hid amongst everyday citizens, and could be found at any given time or place, to monitor people for thoughtcrimes against the party. The problem with this was the fact that “A few among of the Thought Police moved always among them, spreading false rumors and marking down and eliminating the few individuals who were judged capable of being dangerous” (Orwell 62). The people of Oceania knew that Thought Police were always around, but could never know which certain individual or individuals were actually one of them. This caused them to be suspicious of everyone and focus on not committing any violations. Along with telescreens, “You had to live - did live from habitat that became instinct - in the assumption that every sound you made was overheard, and except in darkness, every movement scrutinized” (Orwell 6). Although not every single citizen can be watched at every moment, they never know exactly when they are being watched. Therefore causing most of them to always follow the rules especially when every...
Ultimately, common ideas found in the novel 1984, totalitarianism, surveillance, and lack of privacy are also ubiquitous in modern society and government. Big Brother and modern day government have been able to control its citizens through surveillance equipment, and fear all for a little more power. There is much to learn from such an undesirable form of society much like the one of Oceania in 1984. Examining Big Brother government closely, alarming connections can be made to real-world government actions in the United States and the cruel world within Orwell's book.
Aldous Huxley 's Brave New World, George Orwell 's 1984, and Anthony Burgess ' A Clockwork Orange all present a distinct, multi-faceted dystopia. Elements of the human psyche are exploited in order to preserve each civilization. Any threat of defiance is thoroughly investigated and the three governments engage strategies to handle them. Although the customs and laws are different in the respective societies, each demonstrates the extremes of behavior, the power of conditioning, and the innate need to belong.
The fictional world of 1984 is best described as bleak. In the aftermath of the fall of capitalism and nuclear war, the world has been divided among three practically identical totalitarian nation-states. The novel takes place in London, which has become a part of Oceania, the nation state comprising the Americas and western Europe. A state of perpetual war and poverty is the rule in Oceania. However, this is merely a backdrop, far from the most terrifying aspect of life in 1984. Oceania is governed by a totalitarian bureaucracy, personified in the image of Big Brother, the all-knowing/ all-seeing godlike figure that represents the government. Big Brother is best described as a "totalitarian socialist dictator, a political demagogue and religious cult leader all rolled into one." So great is the power of Big Brother that the reader is unsure whether he actually exists or is simply a propaganda tool of the government. The party of Big Brother, Ingsoc (English Social...
When viewed by most people, V for Vendetta is just another film about rebellion. To others, it’s a wakeup call to do something about their government and fix the country; even if no one acts on their wakeup call. The two main questions viewers may ask are, why is it so easy to relate and root for a terrorist? And why would the government be fine with a movie that calls them out in multiple ways?
“…sex attains meaning in social relations, which implies that we can only make appropriate choices around sexuality by understanding its social, cultueral and political context.” (Quote: 9293 jeffrey weeks)
Authority was used as a form of intimidation between the working class societies and to keep society from corruption. The authority figures mentioned in the book and film were the thought police, “Big Brother”, and the tele. The thought police were in charge of capturing the people who did things that were forbidden and against the laws of the government. Some of the laws that the society couldn’t go against were having impure thoughts, overthrowing the government, and not loving or believing in “Big Brother”. In which committing these crimes are punishable by death. Authority was used to conform and control society.
Identity, in today’s society, is often taken for granted. We have the ability to be anything we wish to be and act in any way we wish to act, but in the 1984 novel by George Orwell, identity is not taken for granted because it does not exist at all. Winston Smith, the narrator, lives in a dystopian society based on the idea of totalitarian government rule. This government is known as Big Brother. In order for Big Brother to stay in power, a few things are necessary: identity cannot exist; everything and everyone must be uniform; the past must be controlled in order to regulate the present; and the people must constantly be practicing the ideas of Newspeak and Doublethink, a form of control the government holds over the people.
Ve for Vendetta and From Fly-Girls to bitches and hoes, both highlights the most crucial and painful aspects of people in United States. The oppression of government and racial discriminations are to the two bitter realities, which have been spotlighted in both text. The essay will thoroughly explore the similarities and differences in terms of fundamental issues and essential components.