Comparing John Locke and Thomas Hobbes

1267 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Compare and contrast Hobbes and Locke's views of human nature and the role of government: what are their differences

The formation of government is one of the central themes for both Hobbes and Locke. Whether or not men naturally form a government, or must form a government, is based on man’s basic nature. According to Hobbes, a government must be formed to preserve life and prevent loss of property. According to Locke, a government arises to protect life and property. Governments are born of inequality and formed to administer equality.

Hobbes goes into a lot of detail concerning man’s interactions with one another including ways in which man can seek to live "together in Peace, and Unity" (page 69). However, Hobbes focuses on the interactions of man seeking the same goal. In any system of limited resources, "Competition of Riches, Honour, Command, or other power enclineth to Contention, Enmity, and War: Because the way of one Competitor, to attaining of his desire, is to kill, subdue, supplant, or repell the other" (page 70).

	Hobbes also deals with the qualities which man possess, and how they affect a man’s basic nature. Man who is charismatic leads others to confide in him. Charisma combined with military ability causes men to follow others as leaders. Those who think of themselves as leaders, the "Men that have a strong opinion of their own wisdome in matter of government, are disposed to Ambition" (page 72).

	According to Hobbes "Nature hath made men so equall, in the faculties of body, and mind; as that though there bee found one man sometimes manifestly stronger in body, or of quicker mind then another; yet when all is reckoned together, the difference between man, and man, is not so considerable" (page 86-87). Furthermore man tend to see himself as wisest in matters, whether or not others may do things better, and that there is no great sign of equal distribution, "than that every man is contended with his share" (page 87).

Hobbes and Locke consider the formation of government from man’s own nature, whether or not government is formed because man is a social animal or if government is formed to preserve society. According to Locke, man must not "think that all government in the world is the product only of force and violence, and that men live together by no other rules but that of beasts" (page 1). "To understand political powe...

... middle of paper ...

...bes compares the laws of nature versus human law by defining the laws of nature as those things that are fundamentally part of us and dictate our behavior and actions when there is no human law to do so. Human laws are imposed by men who recognize their own natures and freely give up some of their rights so that others will do the same. Any stable society of civilized men must come to this point, or fall into destruction from within.

As for Locke’s state of "perfect equality", "all men are naturally in that state, and remain so, till by their own consents they make themselves members of some political society" (page 10). When that happens, men give up some of their free rights for others of protection and guarantees of safety and property, and thus a government is born.

In conclusion, although a government should protect life and prevent loss of property, these protections are not guaranteed. Competition and crime is still a problem even though a government exists. Even today, throughout the world, inequalities still exist. Although governments exist there is still no guarantee of equality or that every life and all property will be protected.

Show More
Related

  • analysis Thomas Hobbes?s claim ?a state of nature is, or would be, a state of war of everyone against everyone.?

    1426 Words  | 3 Pages

    In order to truly understand the logic behind Hobbes’s claim, we must first understand his point of view of human nature. The key element in Hobbes’s view on human nature was the importance of desires. Unlike many other philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle, Hobbes had a different approach to desires. He believed desires were real motive behind human behaviors. (Leviathan, p119) What motivated human actions were not virtues such as wisdom as Aristotle and Plato would claim, nor was it a sense of duty as Cicero would say. It was rather simple desire. Hobbes did not see desire as a harmful feeling, which must be avoided. He rather thought of it as a positive part of human nature, which could drive a person to achieve more and more.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Aristotle And Thomas Hobbes

    1762 Words  | 4 Pages

    Thus, Hobbes asserts that societies are not natural and that men are not social and/or political animal. He argues that political communities and states are not natural. The state, according to Hobbes, is just a way for men to live with other men and escape a state of nature in which he lives in perpetual fear of death. Thus, the state of nature is one of extreme individualism. Hobbes argues that all men are equal in the way that any man can kill another man. There is a war for the acquisition of limited resources and since all men are considered equal, each person can hope to get what he wants. However, this “equality” creates competition since when two people both want the same thing, the opposing parties become enemies. This can be see in Chapter 13 of Leviathan when Hobbes asserts that “every man is an enemy to every man” (87). Hobbes continues in that same paragraph to claim that sometimes, men may come together to achieve a common goal but this association in not motivated by cooperation, but out of self-interest. Each man is hoping to gain something out of this relationship. Therefore, the alliance is not real since each individual is driven by self-interest and there is no way to enforce whatever agreement the parties involved have agreed upon. Additionally, each man still fears the other as there is no guarantee that the

    Read More

  • Comparison of Thomas Hobbes and John Locke: Human Nature

    1373 Words  | 3 Pages

    Mental prowess depends on experience and as men mature they gain knowledge, thus equalizing intellectual faculties. Therefore, all equal men must share in the same desires. All men seek to achieve pleasures and try to avoid dangers, thus desire motivates their actions. Hobbes’ second premise says, “All the voluntary actions of men tend to the benefit of themselves” (Hobbes 91).... ...

    Read More

  • An Analysis of Thomas Hobbes' Leviathan

    2075 Words  | 5 Pages

    Something else that Hobbes made clear in The Leviathan that, similar to himself, all men desire peace. After making this statement, he must justify why, if in fact all men desire peace, they often find themselves in a state of war. This brings about the point that, by nature, all men desire to be better and superior to the men that surround them. However, if all men are created equal, then how can one man be better than all the rest? The answer lies within the equality of man himself. If every man has the means and the ability to acquire what he wants, then when two men that are in close contact with each other desire the same thing, a conflict is inevitably going to arise. There are two motivations for men to seek objects, power, wealth etc. One of these motivations is to preserve ones life. When seeking to preserve ones life, a man will seek only what he needs to survive and he will neglect the luxuries of life that are, in reality, unimportant when one is seeking to maintain ones life. Also, when one seeks to maintain ones life, one will attack and, if need be, kill anyone who threatens their life. In addition to that, when one se...

    Read More

  • Importance Of Conflict Management In Healthcare Management

    1174 Words  | 3 Pages

    Management is needed to support and coordinate the services that are provided by an organization and the healthcare system is no different. Healthcare management involves the provision of leadership and direction to organizations that deliver professional health services. Health care organizations are complex and management is required to provide leadership, supervision and coordination within the organization (Griffith, 2000).

    Read More

  • Sri Lanka Tour Analysis

    1740 Words  | 4 Pages

    Sri Lanka is an island located in the Indian Ocean with a population of 22 million inhabitants. Unlike some other industrialized countries, Sri Lanka is without the tradition of tourism (Spencer, 2014). Early travel was principally a religious undertaking to the historical shrines and travel was strictly domestic and very limited. It was only during the British Colonial era that tourism found its first expression in Sri Lanka (SLAAED, 1994). Luxurious rest houses and hotels were constructed during this period to cater mainly to the English visitors. Soon after, there was recognition of the rich heritage and indigenous culture that Sri Lanka contained and by the mid-1980’s Sri Lanka had embarked on a course of having its sacred and historic

    Read More

  • Hobbes And Locke Similarities

    939 Words  | 2 Pages

    In the difference is that for Hobbes the creation of a government is to protect ourselves, while Locke said to protect the people natural rights. While they also disagree in the government power where Locke agree and believe that the power could be limited while Hobbes doesn’t, in other words, Hobbes believes in a monarchy where people basically do not have the freedom, while Locke believes we can throw the government away if we don’t like

    Read More

  • Hobbes' Perspective on the State of Nature

    857 Words  | 2 Pages

    English philosopher Thomas Hobbes version of the state of nature is the condition of mankind and their natural sense. He argues that we are by nature equal in body and in mind. These equalities along with other human traits cause everyone to naturally and willingly fight; thus also reacting in a manner to band together in order to protect themselves from one another. Hobbes compared this behavior of the “state of nature” to the civil war.

    Read More

  • The Ugly Truth of Plastic Surgery

    1232 Words  | 3 Pages

    Plastic surgery is becoming a trend world-wide because humans can never be fully satisfied in terms of looks. There is always something that people critique about themselves physically. People are so caught up in the hype of achieving physical perfection that they deviate from acknowledging the fact that plastic surgery has negative effects on self-esteem, long-term effects on health, wastes money, and can be life-threatening.

    Read More

  • Hobbes Vs Locke

    1132 Words  | 3 Pages

    John Locke and Thomas Hobbes each advocated tenets of human nature and government during the seventeenth century. Hobbes and Locke has many similarities which makes them somewhat special. Of course they both were important philosophers, but they both had something to do with the Social Contract theory. The Social Contract Theory started right after the English Civil War. The Contract Theory describes a wide set of theories that try to explain the ways in which people form states to maintain social order. Not only did Hobbes want to know why we need a government Locke did also. They both wondered what life would be like if people didn’t have a government, so they both wanted to have an agreement in which both sides agree to something in order to reach a shared goal. Like Hobbes, Locke believed this would lead to a state of nature with no rules, no one in charge, and no way for people to protect their

    Read More

  • The Dangers of Plastic Surgery

    1506 Words  | 4 Pages

    Plastic surgery is becoming a widespread pandemic in the United States. More and more people everyday are electing to take this surgery which, for many people, is an unnecessary change to their body. People in this country and around the world need to realize the dangers and consequences of choosing this surgery. In the United States, there should be increased restrictions on plastic surgery because it would help people better understand the risks and stop some from taking the unnecessary surgery due to the associated health risks.

    Read More

  • The Dangers of Cosmetic Surgery

    1097 Words  | 3 Pages

    Society has indoctrinated men and women to believe that in order to be considered “beautiful” you must look like the images on television, billboards, and magazines.

    Read More

  • Hobbes And Locke Essay

    1409 Words  | 3 Pages

    Hobbes and Locke were both investigating why governments were formed in the first place, and the

    Read More

  • Thomas Hobbes Leviathan Essay

    924 Words  | 2 Pages

    He argues that no judgments or consequences can be made without government based on his idea that all of mankind is a product of the environment. In other words, justice and injustice does not exist before a government is created to say what is right and wrong. Hobbes’ view of equality suggests that men have no restraint and are likely to act out in violence. All of mankind exists in equality, where every man only looks after himself. The aspect of selfishness of man is revealed in his views. Thus, Hobbes states that once government has restricted some of man’s rights, conflict would ultimately be retrained, for mankind’s

    Read More

  • Cosmetic Surgery - Worth the Risk? Argumentative Persuasive Essays

    1710 Words  | 4 Pages

          People considering plastic surgery should be informed of all the risks. They should not be concerned with trying to live up to society's standards and by the price of the operations. They should most be concerned with the real price, their

    Read More

More about Comparing John Locke and Thomas Hobbes

Open Document