Compare And Contrast Pollan And Maxfield

1063 Words3 Pages

When it comes to your health, who do you listen to, your body or the experts? Do you
consider food that has harmful effects on our body “bad food” or “junk food”? Well a graduate
student from Bowling Green State University, Mary Maxfield recommends we should listen
more to our body then we do the experts. She further noted we should label food, good versus
bad instead of utilizing the word “junk food”. While journalist Michael Pollan, argues our body
are not always correct and that’s the reason we should leave it to the professionals. He also
argues in order to live healthier lives we need to eliminate junk food. Both Pollan and Maxfield
have very different views on the way we should take care of our health.
In the essay, Escape from the Western …show more content…

Another topic they both disagree on is the label they put for foods that are not the best
for you health. Pollan is very blunt when he says we need to eliminate “junk food” from our diet
in order to maintain healthy lives (Pollan,421). He uses the word junk food because that’s how
he would describe the food that are very harmful for our bodies. Pollan is very direct, where as
Maxfield is a little more sensitive to her choice of words. Maxfield uses the term “good versus
bad”(Maxfield,446. She uses good versus bad because she is more sensitive in her words of
choice. She believes in not being so strict on ourselves. In my opinion, I think sometimes we
need to be more strict on ourselves in order to live healthier lives. I am more likely not to eat
food that contains the term junk food versus food that just has the term bad food. To me, junk
food has more of a negative notation and thus keep me away from eating it.
Lastly, Maxfield states in order to fix the issue of unhealthy eating we need to accept it
first. Once we accept the fact that we’re fat, it will then help motivate us to want to make …show more content…

Not only once we accept, it will be much easier to make the change, but it will also help
mentally too. Pollan states, we should “Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants” (Pollan,426).
Meaning that we need to eat more food that has been naturally grown and not processed. We
also need to eat enough to fill us, but to not overeat. And lastly to eat more plants. Plants have
such a positive effect on our bodies proving why we need to eat more of it. They benefit our
bodies in so many ways, but yet is one of the most avoided or ignored category of foods. In this
argument, I agree with both of them. I feel like accepting the fact that your body is in need of
better care is the easiest way to actually change it. Accepting change can be one of the hardest
things to do but once it’s done, it keeps a person motivated to change. I also like Pollan’s
advice on how and what to eat. Yes, we need to more foods which are not processed and yes
we need to refrain from overeating because that can cause a lot of damage to our body and we
definitely need to eat more plants. I, myself try to eat a lot of fruits and vegetables because I
know it’s very good to my body. In addition I highly encourage my husband and son to

Open Document