Compare And Contrast Hamlet And Hamlet

1167 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Comparison of hamlet play and the movie

When comparing the written story of Hamlet, by William Shakespeare, and the video representation by director Franco Zeffirelli, noticeable differences make each version unique. Reading Shakespeare 's version of Hamlet cannot have as strong of an impact as Zeffirelli 's representation because of a weak protagonist, dull scenery, and comparably subpar exposition. The characterization in both works presents a different interpretation of personalities as well as interpersonal relationships between players. Having a visual translation of the scenery helps to create a picture of where the story is actually taking place. Shakespeare 's structure of Hamlet isn 't bad, however, the reader of this play could benefit from the extra scenes of the film and more detail within conflicts that the personas endure at Elsinore Castle. The largest character difference is seen in Hamlet himself. In the original play, Hamlet comes off as being a sad man that whines about his situation. Shakespeare 's story perseverates on a sulking Hamlet. In contrast, Zeffirelli 's Hamlet is strong, regardless of his melancholy. He possesses a …show more content…

In Zeffirelli 's view, the King and Queen cannot keep their passionate hands off of each other and their actions make the observer perceive them as disgusting and immoral. Claudius and Gertrude seem rather plutonic in Shakespeare 's Hamlet. On the other hand, the characterization of Polonius in both the written and visual works is quite similar. He is portrayed as a spineless sycophant to King Claudius and Queen Gertrude in both versions of Hamlet. Readers of Shakespeare 's original play will have the same reaction to Polonius ' demise as someone watching the Zeffirelli adaptation. The nosey, "do-gooder" Polonius should not have been meddling in other people 's business. In addition, both translations of Hamlet portray Ophelia as being vulnerable and

Show More
Related

  • Comparing Polonius In Mel Gibson's Hamlet And David Tennius

    575 Words  | 2 Pages

    Hamlet is a play by Shakespeare that tells a story of desired revenge. King Hamlet dies and Hamlet comes home to find his mother interested in someone else and King Hamlet comes back as a ghost. One of the minor characters but has an important role is Polonius, an old wise counselor of the king. He is also the father of Ophelia and as most fathers he is loving and loves his daughter. Two film versions of the play that seem to display Polonius quite differently are Hamlet by Mel Gibson and David Tennant. Polonius is portrayed different in three areas of the films, his ability to listen, ability to focus, and his compassion.

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Lion King And Hamlet

    1302 Words  | 3 Pages

    The main characters in both The Lion King and Hamlet are perceived in the same way by the audience as they share many of the same character traits and personalities. The original

    Read More

  • Lion King vs Hamlet

    1136 Words  | 3 Pages

    In Hamlet, The new king Claudius is able to gain respect from the kingdom. He even steals the love of Hamlet’s mother Gertrude. The old king’s councilor, Polonius, becomes Claudius’s councilor and his best friend. He helps Claudius keep an eye on Hamlet and tries to keep him from finding out anything about his father’s death. Polonius believes that if he helps Claudius that he can make life better for himself and for his daughter and son. But in the end, his actions get him slayed, drive his daughter to insanity, and eventually set...

    Read More

  • Compare And Contrast Lion King And Hamlet

    977 Words  | 2 Pages

    Shakespeare & Disney Characterization The Lion King and Hamlet both feature princes. Hamlet is the prince in the Shakespeare play named after him. Hamlet is very indecisive and this is shown throughout the play. Hamlet wants to avenge his father by killing his uncle but, when he is presented with an opportunity to do so while Claudius is confessing his sins.

    Read More

  • Comparison Of Hamlet And Claudius

    997 Words  | 2 Pages

    king of Denmark and he will do anything to stay that way. His wife Gertrude

    Read More

  • Franco Zeffirelli's Hamlet for Today

    1803 Words  | 4 Pages

    ...e a version of Hamlet which was not seen in Shakespeare's day. Primacy and recency would dictate that Shakespeare's audience would, in some way, concentrate on Fortenbras, whose presence begins and ends this play. Shakespeare's Hamlet is a man with friends who is much more secretive, and conniving than one might think today. His Hamlet is tactful in his plans, but without tact interpersonally. Zeffirelli's audience is forced to concentrate on the plight, and character of Hamlet, who is direct, and hostile, but a tactful loner when the time is right. Zeffirelli accomplishes this diversity while remaining loyal to his source by maintaining a solid screenplay with a continuous flow supporting his own take on the story. In short, Zeffirelli's Hamlet is both a loose and a loyal interpretation of its source, which is, for today's audiences, a Hamlet in its own right.

    Read More

  • Essay on the Manipulation of Polonius and Ophelia in Hamlet

    998 Words  | 2 Pages

    The main plot of Shakespeare's Hamlet centers around Prince Hamlet's desire to repay King Claudius for his evil deeds. Around this central action revolve the stories concerning the minor characters of Polonius and Ophelia. Though they do not motivate Hamlet's actions towards the King, these characters act as forces upon Hamlet himself, trying to spur him to do things he does not want to do. Both Polonius and Ophelia try, unsuccessfully, to manipulate Hamlet into a place of inferiority.

    Read More

  • Polonius And Ophelia's Relationship Analysis

    809 Words  | 2 Pages

    Shakespeare is a master of words, in that he is able to make a reader really think about what he is actually trying to say both as a whole (i.e. the entire play) and in the individual poetic dynamics of the play (i.e. metaphors, diction). He does so brilliantly in one of his most famous plays, Hamlet. The play itself is filled with complex internal dynamics, while at the same time the characters in Hamlet have several complex internal dynamics themselves as well. Throughout the play we are constantly on the edge of our seat, waiting and anticipating what or where Shakespeare is going to take us next. What struck me throughout the play was the relationship between Polonius and his daughter Ophelia. Through Hamlet, and thus through Polonius and Ophelia’s relationship and diction, Shakespeare is able to express to us the flawed ways in which relationship between father and daughter can be and consequently are acted out upon.

    Read More

  • Modern Hamlet: Branagh And Almeregar's Hamlet

    1474 Words  | 3 Pages

    Hamlet is a classic play that has been performed, filmed, and read millions of times since its birth four hundred and fifteen years ago. These portrayals vary from the basic performances of Shakespeare’s time to high-tech revivals that remodel Claudius’ seizure of the throne as a sly boardroom takeover of a prospering tech-company. Each of these adaptations takes artistic liberties, a collaboration or conspiracy among director, screenwriter, and cinematographer, which changes not only the details but also the era and locale. Both Branagh and Almereyda’s versions retained the original name, and some of the dialogue, yet couldn’t be more opposite in their portrayal of “The Tragedy of Hamlet”. Each depiction has quirks that modify Shakespeare

    Read More

  • Comparing Shakespeare's and Zeffirelli's Hamlet

    1657 Words  | 4 Pages

    Hamlet prince of Denmark by William Shakespeare is probably one of the most studied fictional pieces in history. It has become the very pinnacle of literature, and despite the commonality of the play there are many renditions that offer a different artistic interpretation. One rendition, in particular is Franco Zeffirelli’s 1990 film translation starring Mel Gibson as Hamlet. Shakespeare’s original Hamlet follows the heartening life of young Hamlet in which he is often portrayed as a whiney young man that spends his time moping around the castle teetering on the brink of insanity. Zeffirelli’s departure from the norm brings to light a different side of the character that is often overlooked in mainstream productions. Choosing to create a visual Hamlet and heavily cut text has lead to some attention-grabbing changes in the plays structure. Franco Zeffirelli’s film is significantly different with the play. For example, he added the funeral scene at the beginning. He uses a different order with the scenes and parts of scenes, most long speeches are cut, and sometimes gives one characters lines to another. Even though these changes could offend the devoted Shakespearean researcher, they mainly are there to build up the action and cut down the plot.

    Read More

  • Compare Hamlet And Oedipus

    1275 Words  | 3 Pages

    "To be, or not to be: that is the question" (Shakespeare 1750). "Human beings have no part in the craft of prophecy" (Sophocles 1582). Both quotes are part of famous plays. Although the plays appear to be completely different they do have some similarities such as containing a tragic hero. A tragic hero is a character that makes a mistake and eventually leads to their defeat. A tragic hero usually contains at least 5 characteristics such as a flaw (hamartia), reversal of fortune (peripetia), character 's actions leads to a reversal, excessive pride, and the character 's fate is greater than what they truly deserved. Hamlet and Oedipus are both great examples of what a tragic hero is because they both contain flaws, reversal of fortune, and

    Read More

  • A Comparison Of Hamlet And Kenneth Branagh's Hamlet

    1613 Words  | 4 Pages

    Different adaptations of William Shakespeare’s works have taken various forms. Through the creative license that artists, directors, and actors take, diverse incarnations of his classic works continue to arise. Gregory Doran’s Hamlet and Kenneth Branagh’s Hamlet bring William Shakespeare’s work by the same title to the screen. These two film adaptations take different approaches in presenting the turmoil of Hamlet. From the diverging takes on atmosphere to the characterization of the characters themselves, the many possible readings of Hamlet create the ability for the modification of the presentation and the meaning of the play itself. Doran presents David Tenant as Hamlet in a dark, eerie, and minimal setting; his direction highlighting the

    Read More

  • Free Hamlet Essays: Hamlet's Numerous Problems

    1059 Words  | 3 Pages

    Hamlet's problem is not exact; it cannot be pinpointed. In fact, Hamlet has numerous problems that contribute to his dilemma. The first of these problems is the appearance of King Hamlet's ghost to his son, Hamlet. Hamlet's morality adds a great deal to his delay in murdering the current king, Claudius. One of Hamlet's biggest drawbacks is that he tends to think things out too much. Hamlet does not act on instinct; however, he makes certain that every action is premeditated. Hamlet suffers a great deal from melancholy; this in turn causes him to constantly second guess himself. The Ghost is the main cause of Hamlet's melancholy. Also, Hamlet's melancholy helps to clear up certain aspects of the play. These are just a few of the problems that Hamlet encounters throughout his ordeal.

    Read More

  • Modernizing Hamlet: Michael Almereyda

    1014 Words  | 3 Pages

    There have been numerous remarks of William Shakespeare’s most celebrated drama Hamlet. Almereyda managed to make Hamlet a theoretical play, into an intense, action-driven movie without losing much of the initial tragic atmosphere of the original play. The play Hamlet focuses strictly on the state of Denmark on the original Elsinore castle, however Michael Almereyda was able to modernize the movie to New York City. In many ways I think that the modernized version of Hamlet is easier to appreciate but in review that diminishes the play’s “greatness,” in my personal opinion.

    Read More

  • A Comparison Of Hamlet And Michael Almereyda's Hamlet

    1559 Words  | 4 Pages

    Michael Almereyda’s movie adaptation of Shakespeare’s Hamlet brings about a new perspective through its performance. The movie adaptation, Hamlet (2000), retells the original play in a modernized setting, bringing out various different elements of characters, which highlights a new reading of these characters as individuals, and a newfangled reading of the play as well. Throughout the movie, Ophelia and Gertrude, the woman-leads, are advanced in a progressive manner compared to the original play. In particular, Gertrude from Hamlet (2000) is noticeably altered from Hamlet, the play. This new interpretation of Gertrude and the play created by the movie adaptation advances the position of Gertrude as a woman, as well as motifs of incest, misogyny,

    Read More

More about Compare And Contrast Hamlet And Hamlet

Open Document