Clinical Interview

1025 Words3 Pages

Introduction

All students see their teacher as a master of their subject, that they can answer any

question. Teachers are considered experts, or those who have a deep understanding of the

content. They have organized connections of information and are able to recollect information

quickly. The students are seen as the novice, ready to learn and are starting to make connections

what they are learning.

What is a Clinical Interview? According to Long and Ben-Hur (1991), “a clinical interview is an exchange between two or more people in which the interviewer seeks to elicit information from the interviewee about how the latter thinks and learns.”Answers given during the interview can help teacher address student misconceptions and …show more content…

Novices:
Jumping to conclusions without exploring what makes sense (Wieman and Adams,2008)
Tending to memorize new ideas rather than integrate them. (Wieman and Adams,2008)
Missing “obvious” cues that should trigger a new line of thought.(Wieman and Adams,2008)
For example, if an expert and a novice were both to make a concept map on a similar topic, they would be very different. Concept maps differ from expert and novice. According to Vanides, J., Yin, Y., Tomita, M., & Ruiz-Primo, “ when an expert creates a concept map, it is typically an elaborate, highly integrated framework of related concepts. Highly sophisticated maps show highly integrated knowledge structures, which are important because they facilitate cognitive activities such as problem solving.”
Teachers should be experts in their subject field. Novice students need help from an expert to learn about concepts in a meaningful way.
About the Interview I interviewed an expert teacher from Little Rock School District. This teacher has taught science for more than 10 years. The novice I interviewed was a freshman from the University of Arkansas at Fayetteville. I asked them questions about cells and cell types. I tried to focus on plant cells, animal cells, and cell size. I used visuals to help the interviewees think about the sizes of the …show more content…

This interview shows how experts differ from novices and misconceptions about cell size. The interview can show what a student knows and doesn’t know. A teacher could use this information and help the students learn it while addressing misconceptions. They can build on the concepts the students already know and work with the preconceptions they have. A good way to help organize student information is through concept maps. According to Vanides, J., Yin, Y., Tomita, M., & Ruiz-Primo,“concept maps provide a unique graphical view of how students organize, connect, and synthesize information. As a result, concept mapping offers benefits to both students and teachers.”Concept maps can be used to help novices make connections in their learning and is a good tool in teaching expert thinking. A teacher could create concept maps on different types of cells (taxonomy) or the different parts of the cell and how they work/connect with each other.
According to Vanides, J., Yin, Y., Tomita, M., & Ruiz-Primo, concept maps give students an opportunity to:
(1) think about the connections between the science terms being

Open Document