Case Study Of The Monte Confurco

969 Words2 Pages

The Monte Confurco was a fishing vessel, flying the flag of Seychelles. Its owner was the Monteco Shipping Corporation, a company registered in Seychelles. In August 2000, the Monte Confurco left Port Louis (Mauritius) to engage in long-line fishing in the Southern seas. On 8th November 2000, the Monte Confurco was apprehended by the crew of a French surveillance frigate Floréal in the exclusive economic zone of the Kerguelen Islands in the French Southern and Antarctic Territories. The Monte Confurco was escorted under the supervision of the French navy to Port-des-Galets, Réunion. The Master of the vessel was charged and placed under judicial supervision. On 22 November 2000, the district court of Saint-Denis, Réunion, noted that among other …show more content…

The alleged offence committed in the present case relates to the conservation of the fishery resources in the exclusive economic zone (illegal fishing of toothfish). It was argued that the only offence committed by the Master of the vessel was his failure to notify its entry into the EEZ of the Kerguelen Islands and the tonnage of fish it carried on board, and that the vessel did not fish in the said zone. The Tribunal then applied various factors to the present case, (gravity of the alleged offences, range of penalties imposable under French law, value of the Monte Confurco and of the fish and fishing gear seized). The Tribunal found that the bond of 56,400,000 FF imposed by the French court was not reasonable pursuant to article 292 of UNCLOS. The Application concerning the allegation of non-compliance with article 73, paragraph 2, of UNCLOS was admissible and the allegation well-founded. The Parties were in disagreement whether the Master of the vessel was in detention. The Tribunal noted that the Master was not in a position to leave Réunion and considered that, in the circumstances of the case, it was appropriate to order the release of the Master in accordance with article 292, paragraph 1, of

More about Case Study Of The Monte Confurco

Open Document