Brownies, by ZZ Packer

1193 Words3 Pages

In the short story “Brownies,” author ZZ Packer uses the narrator, Laurel, to explore the tensions that exist between belonging to a community and maintaining individuality. While away at camp with her brownie troop, she finds herself torn between achieving group inclusion and sustaining her own individualism. Although the events of the short story occur at Camp Crescendo, Packer is able to expand (and parallel) this struggle for identity beyond the camp’s walls and into the racially segregated society that both the girls and their families come from. Packer is exploring how an individual’s inherent need for group inclusion consequently fuels segregation and prejudice against those outside the group across various social and societal stratums.

Although unaware of the catalytic events that have occurred until much later in the story, Packer explicitly makes us aware from the first paragraph that Laurel and her troop not only share a cohesive group identity but that part of this unity is based around their obvious racial difference from the all-white group, Troop 909. The aggressive tone in this passage illustrates that there does not need to be any outright confrontation between the two groups; the conflict is already there as Troop 909 is “doomed from day one” (Packer, 185). Even before their arrival at camp, the group dynamics are inherently formed around race which subsequently leads to segregation, something that has only been reinforced throughout their lives in Atlanta’s suburbs. Because their total separation from the white community most likely stems from socioeconomic factors, it becomes clear that Laurel’s troop and community is on the “have not’s” side of the spectrum, fueling their prejudice and ignorance toward Troop...

... middle of paper ...

...op and within her black community to explore how racism and hate can be transferred. Although Laurel is aware that the name calling probably did not occur, she still decides to go along with her troop to attack Troop 909, reaffirming her inclusion to the group but not agreeing with the justification. After reflecting on her father’s experience with the Mennonites’, she begins to understand that her troop’s justifications have the same roots as her father’s. While none of the girls in Laurel’s troop have been harmed in any way by Troop 909 nor directly discriminated against by any other white person, they still perceive that there is a racially motivated interpersonal and cultural conflict. Bewildered by the realization of this self-perpetuating cycle of racism and segregation, Laurel realizes that “there was something mean in the world that I could not stop” (194).

Open Document