Comparative Analysis: Aguilera's 'Beautiful' vs Beyoncé's 'Pretty Hurts'

575 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: What's the influence of Social Media on body image

Christina Aguilera's "Beautiful" is a song/music video that was meant for a much broader audience verses Beyoncé's "Pretty Hurts" which was meant for a more feminine audience that brought up subjects of anorexia,starvation,body modifications,and self-esteem. "Beautiful" was meant for more of a wider audience such as those dealing with body image,sexuality,and gender identity. There are little to few similarities when I comes to these two female pop stars. it's obvious one could be seen that they're dealing with a self image or self-esteem

Beyoncé "Pretty Hurts" has more of a connection with pageants, modeling, and advertisement depictions of Women versus what it takes for them to be this way. while Christina Aguilera's "Beautiful" has the …show more content…

By showcasing her personal involvement with them. This possibly gives more attraction towards the subject to come to mainly dealing with the pageant girls and issues that they have to deal with such as eating the cotton balls so the stomach pains won't make them suffer on stage and how they have to be a certain height and weight , how they had to talk and wave in a certain way. Though these two videos show lots of involvement with current body issues that may manifest in many women these days. They do have their differences such as Christina's concepts of beauty could possibly be a little bit more different and more widespread she could possibly be thinking of more issues. Even though based on the time that the video came out which was more of a later date so it was a very risky to actually bring in the LGBTA+ within the music video. Beyoncé video "Pretty Hurts" does more on magnifying the issues that may manifest in people today as in the concepts of the beauty like being that skinny , tall , blonde and having clear skin. Like how they might affect girls today or anyone who has a more feminine attribute. they're both wonderful individually themselves and do bring up a lot of subjects even if they may differ or best each other in certain ways , the songs do bring up good points and should help someone who is

Show More
Related

  • Comparing Chicken Fried By Zac Brown Band And Living Room By David Yezzi

    1283 Words  | 3 Pages

    The song does have good rhyme scheme, which is a very important poetic element. Zac Brown band writes, “Well I was raised up beneath the shade of a Georgia Pine / and that's home you know / sweet tea, pecan pie, and homemade wine, where the peaches grow…” (5-7). Every other line rhymes with the previous. This is a good poetic element to have, considering rhyme is commonly related to many great songs and poems. This does not make up for the lack of other poetic elements, and the simplicity of the writing. The differences between the two pieces is still very vass. The two pieces have two totally different objectives, which makes them have different writing styles. Claire Dederer writes “Song lyrics do a fine imitation of poetry, but they’re not quite the same thing. Lyrics are a vessel, designed to hold a singer’s voice. Poetry is its own solid object” (Bad Poem, Great Song). To some, the dilemma is cut and dry, songs just can’t be poetry.

    Read More

  • Suffering, Sacrifice and Punishment under the Tyranny of Beauty

    539 Words  | 2 Pages

    What woman doesn't want to be beautiful? Women want to please and will go to extreme measures to achieve the beauty ideal. Over the centuries, women have mauled and manipulated just about everybody part - lips, eyes, ears, waists, skulls, foreheads, stomachs, breasts and feet - that did not fit into the cookie-cutter ideal of a particular era's ideal of beauty and perfection. Women have suffered, sacrificed and punished themselves under the tyranny of beauty.

    Read More

  • Analysis Of Sociological Scavenger Hunt

    2145 Words  | 5 Pages

    Objectification of women and misogyny is a common trend in song lyrics, but it is often socially accepted and further perpetuated. Finding a song in which the roles are reversed and a woman depicts a man as a sex object is incredibly difficult because when women try to break norms in the music industry, they are often criticized. In “Blah Blah Blah” by Kesha, she reverses the typical gender roles in song lyrics by objectifying men. Kesha has her own struggles within the male-dominated music industry because her producer sexually abused her and trapped her into a record deal. However, Kesha lost her court case, which illuminates gender issues within the music industry and the larger society. In 2010 when Kesha’s songs were popular, people weren’t aware of her battle with her producer. Instead, her lyrics classified her as more of a party figure and people even saw her as “trashy.” This song

    Read More

  • Robin Thicke And Pharrell Song Analysis

    485 Words  | 1 Pages

    In " Blurred Lines" by Robin Thicke and Pharrell it talks about how a men humiliates a women.This song talks a about sexiest men and how he caresless about womens rigths or feelings, this song made alot of people angry becaause of how it talks about women.This song actually compares womens rigths and feelings to animals

    Read More

  • Caillat's Song Compare And Contrast Essay

    1490 Words  | 3 Pages

    The video promotes a realistic portrayal of women while undermining negative societal expectations put to those women. Furthermore, the message behind it, one calling people to accept themselves and to not feel the need to strive towards unreachable goals set by the media, can be applied to the lives of not only women but men as well. While the song was obviously meant for women, it is still holds the important message for people of any gender, age, or race to understand that being true to and learning to accept one’s self can only lead to positive

    Read More

  • Drag Music Video Analysis

    1905 Words  | 4 Pages

    Some can be dancers, comedians, events hosts, models, DJs and so much more but I’m just here to talk about drag queen singers. This essay will talk about the production of a drag queen music video and what has to be done to change the appearance of the artist and also depict the meaning of two music videos.

    Read More

  • Full House Role Model

    529 Words  | 2 Pages

    Natasha and Olivia represent an entire generation of young girls and women that have a certain niche. "Do you love fashion and beauty? Do you sing? Is that something you're passionate about? Then get out there! You have a voice, use it," Natasha and Olivia seem to say with each video. They inspire the young girls and women who desire to enter the world of fashion, beauty, and music. They tell these young girls and women that the world is their's, and no one is stopping them. With each video upload, another young girl and woman knows that she can do it, and she won't give up. Meet the daughter of Candace Cameron Bure and the daughter of Lori Loughlin, aren't they

    Read More

  • Rap Music: Negative Attention Towards Women

    629 Words  | 2 Pages

    Rap artists’ using women in an offensive way in the lyrics and videos is something that has recently been taking affect. Many decades ago, rappers did not rap about women the way rappers

    Read More

  • Stuart Hall's What Is This Black In Black Popular Culture?

    1124 Words  | 3 Pages

    As it opens with imagery reminiscent of the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina in New Orleans, an event that devastated the black communities in the areas affected. The delayed assistance in New Orleans by the U.S. government stirred some controversy that led many to question how much America really cares about its black communities. Nonetheless, Beyoncé’s video is full of imagery that is associated with black culture, including historical references to black communities in the south. But what is really important about “Formation” are the lyrics. With lyrics like “My daddy Alabama, Momma Louisiana, You mix that negro with that Creole make a Texas Bama” and “I like my baby hair with baby hair and afros, I like my negro nose with Jackson Five nostrils,” Beyoncé is undoubtedly declaring her pride for her blackness as well as defending her child Blue Ivy who has always been scrutinized for the way her hair looked. Thus, this song is obviously geared toward the Black community which is obvious due to the lyrics and the imagery in the music video. To put it plainly, this song is a proclamation of Black pride and shouldn’t be thought of in any other way. However, after performing it at the Super Bowl people of other ethnicities became aware of the song and became offended by her performance as well as the lyrics. Controversy arose as people pointed out her backup dancers were dressed similarly to the Black Panther

    Read More

  • Body Image Definition Essay

    647 Words  | 2 Pages

    Media: are the main sources of news, entertainment and promotional messages. For example: television, newspapers magazines and radio.

    Read More

  • Beauty And Racism In Western Society

    1952 Words  | 4 Pages

    The way a woman was perceived as beautiful has changed so much even over the last 50 years as I have discussed previously. If we look at Marilyn Monroe and compare her to Tyra Banks, who has made it her passion in life to stretch the definition of beauty (Pozner, 2013) the difference is uncanny. Marilyn Monroe is the most acclaimed sex icon of the 1950’s and she was not astonishingly slender. Meanwhile Tyra banks up until a couple years ago had always been immeasurably skinny. Women nowadays are required to be excessively skinny, toned, tall, and have flawless skin if they want to fit into the “most beautiful” column. Although Tyra Banks presumably believes that she is an exceptional advocate for young girls in the media, she is also delivering a skewed image of self-love through her show, America’s Next Top Model (Pozner, 2013). Every woman on that show either fits the media’s standard of an ideal woman, or they are ridiculed/questioned. The media is making it impossible to achieve such high standards. Even for black women, there is the stereotype that they have to have huge behinds and appear to be super ghetto like Nicki Minaj; even she received cosmetic surgery to enhance her bust and rear, as well as slimming her waist. She did all these things to appease her viewers. It is impossible for women to achieve these different standards

    Read More

  • A Child Called It Analysis

    1200 Words  | 3 Pages

    Domestic violence, the connotation of the two words immediately invokes images in everyone's mind. Two songs will be discussed in this paper, these songs relate directly to the issue. The first song is “A Child Called ‘it’” by Buckcherry, released in 2008 on the Black Butterfly album. The second song is “Im ok” by Christina Aguilera, released in 2002 on the Stripped album. Buckcherry’s song, is based on a true story of a child that was abused by his mother. Similarly, Christina Aguilera’s song talks about her women who is being abused, you can tell this from the beginning of the song when she sings, “my father's fist would put her in her place.” Both of these songs directly talk about domestic violence and

    Read More

  • Informative Essay: The Perfect Body Image

    484 Words  | 1 Pages

    The Perfect Body In today's society, women are obsessed with having a specific body type to make others find them attractive. They want to feed the society’s body type expectations. What is a perfect body? Does it even exist? However, advertising, boyfriends, and family members often make women feel that skinny bodies are perfect bodies.

    Read More

  • Misogyny In Hip Hop Culture

    1271 Words  | 3 Pages

    The Pop music is also one of the most famous genres among the young generation. Sexism in this field is subtler than Hip -Hop and expressed differently. The common theme of most Pop songs is about love. In these songs the mention of sex is less indirect as more euphemism are utilized. Many of the love songs sung by men use possessives nouns when referring to women. Furthermore, many songs use the allure of sex in women. They showcase women being the gatekeeper of sex, for which the men are seeking the key for. Do female song writers also indulge in this sexism? if so then how? Yet, many of the female song writers unknowingly abet sexism in this genre by showing their desperate yearning for men’s attention. They portray themselves helpless for the man’s love and victimize themselves to be dependent on the man with a certain

    Read More

  • Music Video Analysis: If I Were A Boy

    1150 Words  | 3 Pages

    It has been played in many other countries and is listed in many major hit charts in those countries. It became one of her best-selling singles. Beyoncé has been singing about women’s independence since she was in the hit group “Destiny’s Child”. Many of her songs support women’s lifestyle and keep cheering up girls with her powerful and expressive vocals (Armstrong). In addition to her songs and lyrics, her beautiful appearance fascinates many female audiences and influences from teenagers to grown-ups as if she was a role model. A negative side of the video is that the video gives the impression that men are always to be blamed and women are always “victims” of the relationships, which is not

    Read More

More about Comparative Analysis: Aguilera's 'Beautiful' vs Beyoncé's 'Pretty Hurts'

Open Document