Australia: Melbourne's Urban Consolidation

971 Words2 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Introduction and background on urban sprawl

Urban consolidation refers to a diverse set of policies intended to make more efficient use of the existing urbanised areas instead of developing non-urbanised land, thus limiting urban sprawl. The recent publication of the Melbourne 2030 plan indicates that Melbourne is adopting an urban consolidated direction for further development. This has raised many debates over whether it is the right plan. There are two sides to this complex argument. People in favorite suggests that urban consolidation offers a range of solutions to pressing urban problems socially and environmentally, for example it reduces car use and provide better access to facilities, whilst the other point of view argues that urban consolidation has its limits in terms of consumer preference, land capacity and could actually bring negative social and environmental impact to the city.

This paper argues that urban consolidation should not be the focal point for future development in Melbourne. I will present this augment from 4 different environmental and social perspectives, which include urban consolidation limits green space, lack consumer preference, restricts freedom and rebuts that sprawl development is not necessarily bad for traffic.

In a social sense, consumers prefer low-density developments. Low density means more space and better standard of living. There are apartments available in every city for those who prefer them. However, many people choose to live in detached homes. Nobody forces people to buy house at outer suburbs (Holcombe 1999). Developers build those houses because that is where people want to live. Why? The answer is simple, those houses offer better space and comfort compare to living in the confine inner city. Many have suggeste...

... middle of paper ...

...ctivity centers in the Los Angeles only account for 17.5 percent of the area’s total employment. Most people both live and work in the suburbs and the average commute for individuals in the Los Angeles area is only 20 minutes (Gordon & Harry 1989). Traffic reduction stems primarily from a decision to drive (Engwight, 1992), a factor not easily adjustable by urban planning alone.

It is clear that urban consolidation can not solve the range of urban problems. It presents new dilemmas as it does not provide sufficient green space, limits people’s freedom, many people do not like living in an urban consolidated environment and it could potentially increase people’s time traveling out of the city. Planners must consider all these factors when assessing urban consolidation potential. Failure to do so could result in descent to achieve efficient, urban development.

Show More
Related

  • Changes due to Urban Renewal in Pyrmont-Ultimo

    1105 Words  | 3 Pages

    Finally in 1991, the federal government initiated a ‘Better Cities Program’ which aimed to make Australian cities sustainable and more liveable. It encoura...

    Read More

  • Impact of Urban Renewal on the Sydney Suburb of Pyrmont

    1210 Words  | 3 Pages

    The suburb of Pyrmont on the shores of Sydney Harbour has been transformed by the processes of urban renewal into a thriving cosmopolitan residential area, an efficient and sophisticated business centre, and a popular recreational and tourist hub. Through my own observation of the Pyrmont area, I have seen how the painstaking urban planning efforts for the area have come to fruition, and a focal point of the Harbour foreshore created as a result of this.

    Read More

  • Summary: Urban Renewal

    1126 Words  | 3 Pages

    Many factors and geographical processes, the foreshore of Sydney Harbour has constantly faced changes in land use which has effected the environment, social communities and the economy in both positive and negative ways. Urban decay, urban renewal, urban consolidation and gentrification are the geographical process that are involved in the changing gland use around the Sydney Harbour foreshore. These geographical processes are what changes the land use from being used as industrial, residential and commercial which then impacts the economy, social communities/ public, the environment and the stakeholders.

    Read More

  • Globalization And Anti-Gentfication Of City Of Toronto

    1111 Words  | 3 Pages

    According to Lehrer, U., & Wieditz, T. (2009), Toronto saw a massive population growth in a period of thirty years due to the extensive construction of high-rise condominium towers which led to the city being divided into three distinct cities: “city of the rich, the shrinking city of middle-income households, and the growing city of concentrated poverty.” According to the article the division is caused by the development of condominiums as the new form of gentrification which displaces the poor people and focuses to attract the higher-income people to the area.

    Read More

  • Affordable Housing Proposal

    1116 Words  | 3 Pages

    Joseph Alcock reiterates that a “lack of affordable housing can be a barrier to a strong reliable economy” (9). High housing costs can influence where businesses and corporations decide to locate, which will affect the local economy. First-time homebuyers will most likely shy away from moving to Orange County because of these high prices on homes. In addition, many people leave after graduating from local college and universities because families probably not want to continue paying a lot for their own homes. These youthful passage level specialists drive neighborhood economies. On the off chance that they can't stand to live in the area, nearby economies will endure. An absence of affordable housing can push zone specialists to settle outside of the territory, bringing about longer drives, expanded movement blockage and contamination, diminished efficiency, and a reduced personal satisfaction for the area. An absence of reasonable rental housing confines the capacity of tenants to put something aside for an initial installment on a home, which restricts their capacity to in the end get to be property holders and assemble individual riches through housing appreciation. An absence of affordable housing improves the probability of vagrancy. An absence of reasonable housing has brought about congestion and critical increments in family unit and group stress. An absence of affordable housing causes families to live in substandard dangerous

    Read More

  • Urban Sprawl: The American Nightmare

    1568 Words  | 4 Pages

    to fund public programs or make general improvements throughout the community. Urban sprawl is expensive not only on people’s wallets, but is taxing on their health, the environment, their relationships. The.. After examining all of the problems associated with urban sprawl it is hard not to question how America lost the genuine communities of old and adopted the new community of

    Read More

  • Essay On Pyrmont

    1419 Words  | 3 Pages

    Urban consolidation is the process of increasing the amount of medium to high density housing in areas that already have urban infrastructure in place. ( Pearson, 2014)

    Read More

  • Analysis Of 'Thinking Resilience'

    1050 Words  | 3 Pages

    Who hasn’t seen the critical examples of overpopulation that are always depicted with large cities, tall buildings and many people? It is a common thought that cities are the cause of air pollution and are in no way thought of to be sustainable or as having a smaller footprint than those residing in rural zones. Yet, this chapter shows that the criticisms have no bearing when it comes to cities and rather, cities are better in terms of stronger economies, those who live in cities have smaller families, and the more the city is developed the lower the level of poverty (unlike rural areas which shows to have a higher level of poverty). The misconception that cities are actually overusing resources and contributing to environmental degradation is not the case. The chapter cites that this is not so, it is rather “industries and commercial and industrial enterprises (or corporations) and middle and upper income groups with high consumption lifestyles.” (56) These wealthier people who want to live more luxuriously, often live on acres of land with multiple cars, thus do not often reside in the city. The chapter continues to list the positive roles of cities, for example, “lower costs per household and per enterprise for the provision of piped, treated water supplies…collection and disposal of human wastes.” (56) Another positive is the efficient use from recycled waste, also a smaller demand for land relative to the population in cities. The fourth advantage is listed as more efficient heating techniques, and fifthly, a greater use of public transportation. The rich culture found in cities is also cited in the chapter. It concludes with the need for “good governance,” whereby the goals are met and cost is not past onto others, without it the cities are left to be sources of pollution, sickness, and waste

    Read More

  • Juxtaposition In The City

    1265 Words  | 3 Pages

    Location, location, location -- it’s the old realtor 's mantra for what the most important feature is when looking at a potential house. If the house is in a bad neighborhood, it may not be suitable for the buyers. In searching for a house, many people will look at how safe the surrounding area is. If it’s not safe, they will tend stray away. Jane Jacobs understood the importance of this and knew how cities could maintain this safety, but warned of what would become of them if they did not diverge from the current city styles. More modern planners, such as Joel Kotkin argue that Jacobs’s lesson is no longer applicable to modern cities because they have different functions than those of the past. This argument is valid in the sense that city

    Read More

  • New Urbanism

    1246 Words  | 3 Pages

    New Urbanism, a burgeoning genre of architecture and city planning, is a movement that has come about only in the past decade. This movement is a response to the proliferation of conventional suburban development (CSD), the most popular form of suburban expansion that has taken place since World War II. Wrote Robert Steuteville, "Lacking a town center or pedestrian scale, CSD spreads out to consume large areas of countryside even as population grows relatively slowly. Automobile use per capita has soared, because a motor vehicle is required for nearly all human transportation"1. New Urbanism, therefore, represents the converse of this planning ideology. It stresses traditional planning, including multi-purpose zoning, accessible public space, narrow street grids for easy pedestrian usage and better placement of community buildings. Only a few hundred American communities are utilizing this method of planning, but the impact is quickly growing in an infant field dominated by a few influential architects and engineers.

    Read More

  • City or Suburban Life?

    945 Words  | 2 Pages

    In light of today’s economy, cost is one of the leading factors in making a decision on where one lives. Housing in most metropolitan areas can be very expensive and offers little living space versus lower cost of rent and more square footage in suburban areas. When renting a studio in the heart of many cities, you are likely to pay as much if not more than renting a one possibly two bedroom apartment in some surrounding suburban areas. For home owners property taxes can be a huge determinant as well. In Illinois for example, the property taxes are amongst some of the highest in the nation and both city and suburban home owners are paying top dollar regardless of their location. Additionally, urban areas are often riddled with excessive sticker and parking fees along with the looming threat of tickets, tows and the occasional boot. Many suburbs also have assessments and sticker fees but usually pale in comparison to that of the inn...

    Read More

  • Melbourne Urban Development

    1948 Words  | 4 Pages

    History of Settlement & Urban Development - Melbourne The area around Port Phillip, where Melbourne is now located, was the home to the indigenous Kulin people, made up of several different groups of original Australians, whose ancestors had lived in the area for an estimated 31,000 to 40,000 years. The Kulin lived by fishing, hunting and gathering, and made a good living from the rich food sources of Port Phillip and the surrounding grasslands. John Batman, a successful farmer in northern Tasmania, desiring more grazing land, entered Port Phillip Bay on 29 May 1835 and after exploring the area decided it would be a good place for a settlement and he entered into a treaty with the Kulin to take 600,000 acres. John Batman Attempts to

    Read More

  • STATEMENT OF PURPOSE: M.S. City planning.

    886 Words  | 2 Pages

    Indeed, many global cities face compelling urban planning issues like urban sprawl, population, low density development, overuse of non-renewable natural recourses, social inequities and environmental degradation. These issues affect the cities themselves, the adjacent regions and often even globally. The resulting ecological footprint upsets the balance in adjacent rural and natural areas. Unplanned or organic development leads to urban sprawl, traffic problems, pollution and slums (as evident in the case of Mumbai city). Such unplanned development causes solid waste management and water supply to fall inadequate. Urban sprawl gives rise to low density development and car dependent communities, consequently leading to increased urban flooding, low energy efficiency, longer travel time and destruction of croplands, forests and open spaces for development.

    Read More

  • The Natural History Of Urbanization By Lewis Mumford Summary

    1007 Words  | 3 Pages

    Sociologist … explained that open pattern of suburb is because of seeking environment free noise, dirt and overcrowding that are in the centre of cities. He gave examples of these cities as St. John’s wood, Richmond, Hampstead in London. Chestnut Hill and Germantown in Philadelphia. He added that suburban are only for the rich and high class. This plays into the hands of the critical perspectives that, “Cities are not so much the product of a quasi-natural “ecological” unfolding of social differentiation and succession, but of a dynamic of capital investment and disinvestment. City space is acted on primarily as a commodity that is bought and sold for profit, “(Little & McGivern, 2013, p.616).

    Read More

  • Urbanization Problems and Sustainable Development

    1366 Words  | 3 Pages

    A general situation of urbanization trend in developing countries and developed countries is increasing. In 18th Century only 3% of the world total population lived in urban areas but as projected in 2000 this number will increase at above 50% (UN as cited in Elliot, 1999, p. 144). According to UN (as cited in Elliot, 1999, p.144), it is figured that the total urban population in developing countries has increased from approximately 400 millions people in 1950 to approximately 2000 millions people in 2000. At the same time, total urban population in developed countries is double...

    Read More

More about Australia: Melbourne's Urban Consolidation

Open Document