Analysis Of Choice Words By Peter Johnston

968 Words2 Pages

Introduction
Chapters 1-4 of the book “Choice Words” written by Peter Johnston discuss how language is a powerful teaching tool. The author provides examples and explanations of how what teachers’ say and do not say could have a positive or negative impact on their student’s literate lives. The author says “Children, in their own ways, teach us about the language of our classrooms. We have to ask what discursive histories have made it possible for them to say what they say” (Johnston, 2004, p.3). In my opinion, this translates as what teachers say in the classroom shapes their student’s language, thoughts and impacts their development of agency. For example, the author talks about a little girl in the first grade that says her father is going …show more content…

In some of my classes, those subjects were occasionally used as a punishment. For example, a teacher would say, “if you don’t stop talking you will have more writing for homework”, or “since no one is listening, maybe we should stay inside and read instead of going out for recess”. These phrases subconsciously delivered the message that reading and writing is something you should not want to do or should not look forward to. In addition, reading and writing were referred to as work instead of a fun activity. Johnston (2004) said, “telling children they can have free choice time, but first we have to finish our reading, positions reading poorly simply by using the words “have to.” (p.9)”. This statement shows how reading is presented as something required and must be done before getting to the fun stuff. This exactly describes what happened in many of my grade school …show more content…

In some classrooms, teachers’ subconsciously use their language to establish negative relationships with literacy. For example, some teachers use reading and writing as a punishment or reference it as work instead of fun. Johnston (2004) said “ the way a teacher talks can position students differently in relations to what they are doing, learning, or studying” (p.9). In my opinion, this means that language has the power to influence student’s perception. Therefore, what teachers say and how they say it impacts how students feel about themselves and the world. But, some teacher may not realize how their words and tone towards literacy influences how children feel about it. In general, I think children in urban schools need to be exposed to language and literacy experiences that are positive and engaging. Instead of using reading and writing as a consequence, it could be used as a reward, or make it an option during free time just like any other fun activity. In general, I believe some teachers subconsciously use language to create negative relationships between students and literacy, but if teachers would be more mindful of the undertone of their language, children would perceive literacy differently (Johnston,

Open Document