Alice in Wonderland

1214 Words3 Pages

In the 1951 Disney movie, Alice in Wonderland, Alice falls down a rabbit-hole while chasing a White Rabbit with a waistcoat and ends up in Wonderland. It is a place where animals talk and logic no longer exits. In the original work by Lewis Carroll, Alice grows internally and has control over her surroundings in Wonderland. She learns how to wear the crown of adulthood by finally knowing her identity in the end. Although Disney’s version imitates the same adventure as the original, Alice’s character’s identity does not develop. In the opening scene, Alice desires something beyond orthodox. This is showed by her lack of interest in her studies and longing for a world in which everything would be “nonsense.” She is a curious child. Deborah Ross argues that Alice expresses the usual idealistic desires: “to escape boredom (with lessons), to satisfy curiosity (about the white rabbit), and above all, to exert power” (Ross 57). However Alice does not know exerting power is difficult when the world is consumed of “nonsense”. Thus she has different qualities that contributes to her vague identity. She believes life would be different in her world. Also Disney strives to reveal Alice’s incentive of Wonderland by introducing pictorial wonders such as singing flowers and surrealistic insect, making it seem as a dream. The movie progresses in the same route as Lewis Carroll’s book by focusing on her immature thinking of Wonderland. When Alice falls down the rabbit hole by curiosity to pursue the Wonderland, she encounters characters that questions her identity. One main example was the dialogue with the Cheshire Cat, who tells her everyone in the neighborhood is mad. Alice speaks Carroll's line, "But I don't want to go ... ... middle of paper ... ...She cannot pursue her progressive dreams of her identity. She has to adopt respectable behavior in every circumstance, in contrast to support of creative thinking of Wonderland. She calls for help during a time of conflict in contrast the original Alice’s confident and spirit. Alice in both versions has no level of toleration for difficulties. However Carroll’s Alice becomes more determined and self-reliant as she travels through her identity, which was wonderland. She states when she comes back home “what a wonderful dream it had been” (Carroll 98). Alice knew where she belonged because of Wonderland. Disney’s Alice just wanted the dream to end and be free from the madness of herself. Unfortunately Wonderland never taught Alice a lesson about her individuality. Instead the whole 95 minutes of Wonderland was just a comedic dream without meaning.

Open Document