A Song In The Front Yard And The Other Wife

723 Words2 Pages

I chose to compare “The courage that my mother had” by Millay, “A Song in the Front Yard” by Brooks, and “The Other Wife” by Colette. They all on some level deal with gender roles and give examples of women who do not completely fall in the cult of domesticity.
All three works of literature contain women who are strong, yet still considered beautiful by their peers. In Millay’s poem rock and granite personifies the mother when “rock from New England quarried; now granite in granite hill” is stated. Millay uses the repetition of granite to emphasize the characteristic as strength as well as help the reader understand the mother is now under a tombstone. Although the mother is being referenced as strong she is also depicted as feminine. When Millay writes “the golden brooch my mother wore” she alludes to a rare, …show more content…

In all the conflict is somewhere along the lines of one woman desiring the life or characteristics of another woman. Even though these women have “golden brooches”, “front yard” privilege, and a new husband, they crave dauntlessness, waywardness, and independence. For example Millay uses a paradox to express that the golden brooch is valuable, yet it could easily be done without. Instead the daughter in this poem craves her mother’s courage since she is have a difficult time with her mother’s passing. In Colette’s story although the new wife, Alice, is the one with the husband, seeing the ex-wife makes her envious. When Alice notices “the woman in white...resting against the back of the cane chair…with an air of satisfied lassitude” the reader understands Alice craves the poise and contentedness of the ex-wife. Alice even goes on to describe the ex-wife as “this superior”. In Brook’s poem the young girl explicitly states she “want(s) a peek at the back where it’s rough and untended.” She describes Johnnie Mae and kids from the back yard as having “wonderful fun” and craves the freedom that Johnnie Mae

Open Document