Susan Farrell in her, “Fight vs. Flight: A Re-evaluation of Dee in Alice Walker’s ‘Everyday Use’” writes in response to Alice Walker’s short story Everyday Use. Farrell’s article is published by Newbury College in spring of 1998 in Studies in Short Fiction (179). Farrell in her article writes to argue that although Dee is inconsiderate and egotistical—supporting what she is arguing against— to a certain degree, she offers a way for a modern African American to manage with the harsh society that is, in a few ways more substantial than that described by Mother and Maggie— which is her thesis (179). Most people who have read Walker’s short story Everyday Use are prone to agree that the character Dee is ‘shallow,’ ‘condescending,’ and ‘manipulative,’; …show more content…
however, Farrell argues that way of viewing the story is a “far too simple of a reading of the story” (179). In the middle of the article, she heavily claims that Mama in Walker’s story portrays and percepts Dee to be some sort of goddess in the short story: “thus, Dee seems to attain almost mythic stature in Mama’s imagination as she and Maggie wait for the as-yet unnamed ‘[Dee]’ to appear” (Farrell 180). Then at the later end of her article, she goes to talk about the evolution of the mother, how she becomes more like Dee, from a person who does nothing against the oppression to someone who stands up against. Farrell says that the mother is “behaving more like Dee, with her refusal to back down, her willingness to stand up for herself [. . .], Dee, despite her outward obnoxiousness, has taught Mama something about fighting back” (184). Farrell in her article gives extensive amount of evidence from other writers, who are also critiquing Walker’s story, to support her thesis, but her language seems a little too strong and harsh to all those who share different view from her; although she goes off topic and dedicates an entire page to a different story by Walker, nonetheless, she was successful in conveying her message . The author uses many pieces of evidence to prove her views and succeeds in providing her sources.
She seems to have a good understanding of the story and has done a fair share of research to prove her point. She re-evaluates Dee from a different perspective and makes reasonable points; additionally, she uses myriads other writers to back her view of Dee with credible sources. She has included a reference page and she seems to have experience in this field considering she has worked many other stories, as well. The article is well organized and it makes sense but she brings of Walker’s Meridian and gives one page summarizing what happens in that story just to make one simple connection. Farrell brings up that short story to relate Dee and Maggie, “Meridian shares much in common with Maggie” (184). A point which could be made in a sentence or two, she decides to commit an entire page. Farrell’s thesis is very clear and readers can understand that she is playing the devil’s advocate by arguing against all who dislikes the character Dee. She blatantly states that “I will argue that this popular view is far too simple” and is simply based on just feelings alone rather than logic and reasoning (179). Throughout the article, her thesis is supported through by more than just her thoughts alone. One read of the thesis and the reader can easily say that this author is supporting Dee rather than just say she is selfish. She also gives reasons as to why Dee is the way she is rather than just stating that the saying side is
wrong. Although Farrell seems a bit harsh with her points, she is successful in persuading the readers by giving evidence from both the short story and other authors and using credible sources. She makes an interesting argument stating that Dee’s actions are justifiable because she is trying to protect herself from society, and not trying to be selfish on purpose. Her arguments are logical and valid because she not only disagrees with but provides why she disagrees. This article is worth reading because she has a very different perspective on the character.
No matter where one is from or where one finds themselves today, we carry with us in some way or another a specific heritage. Certain events and circumstances can lead to someone trying to forget their heritage or doing everything in their power to preserve that heritage. Alice Walker’s “EveryDay Use” was published in 1973, not long after the civil rights movement, and reflects the struggles of dealing with a heritage that one might not want to remember (Shmoop). Alice Walker is well known as a civil rights and women’s rights activist. Like many of her other works she uses “Everyday Use” to express her feelings on a subject; in this case African American heritage. Through “Everyday Use” it can be seen that Alice Walker has negative feelings about how many African Americans were trying to remove themselves from parts of their African American culture during the time of the short story’s publishment. This idea that Walker was opposed to this “deracinating” of African Americans coming out of the civil rights
Her views and attitude are similar to how I would act if I were in her shoes. I can't say I would be as patient as she is, but for the most part, I related to her. I looked forward to see what she would do next. I haven't anything negative to say about this book, and I would definitely recommend it to anyone who is open to read a fun book. WORKS CITED Butler, Octavia E. "Parable of the Sower."
Point of View in Alice Walker's Everyday Use. Alice Walker is making a statement about the popularization of black culture in "Everyday Use". The story involves characters from both sides of the African American cultural spectrum, conveniently cast as sisters in. the story of the. Dee/Wangero represents the "new black," with her natural.
Everyday Use by Alice Walker is a short story about how people get caught up in the superficial value of material things, and the jealousy this desire causes. In this short story Dee, the eldest daughter, was always ashamed by the way she lived during her childhood years. As she was educated more and more, her feelings of hatred for poverty and ignorance grew intensely. After she finished college her abhorrent feelings grew immensely, and she tried to take advantage of those less educated than her.
“Everyday Use” is a story based in the era of racial separation between communities of diverse ethnicity. “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker merely scratches the surface of racial heritage and the elimination of previous ways of living. This discontinuation of poverty driven physical labor shines through Dee as she grows to know more of her heritage throughout her years in school. An example of this is when Dee changes her name; this is an indication of Dee/Wangero wanting to change her lifestyle after the harsh truth she is hit with while going to school. Dee learns about the struggles of African Americans during this time, which changes her view on the unforgiving reality of her family’s lifestyle. In “Everyday Use”, the author opens the mind
"Theme Summary of “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker : The Role of African -American Traditions." Welcome to ArticleMyriad.com! Web. 14 Apr. 2011. .
Alice Walker is an author who grew up in an environment with violent racism along with poverty. As a result of her surroundings and lifestyle, it made a permanent influence on her writing. Being a black woman, born and raised in Georgia, the majority of her stories have to do with African-American heritage. Most of her stories are centered on black individuals or families in the south. In 1972, Alice Walker published “Everyday Use” in a collection of short stories. In “Everyday Use”, Walker tells the story of a mother and her two daughters’ different thoughts about their heritage and their individualism as a culture. Through the characters of Dee, Maggie and the Ms. Johnson, Walker expresses the different sides of culture and heritage; each of which has different viewpoints and qualities of life. Even though the three women are a part of an integral family, their outlooks of life are very different. To further the understanding of the irony of the story, Walker breaks down the major characteristics into the point of view, characters, theme, and the setting.
During the civil rights movement many people often struggled with their identity, who they were, and what they believed. There was a conflict amongst the African- American community, a conflict between the old world and the new world, the world before civil rights and the new world of equality amongst all. In Alice Walker’s, “Everyday Use”, Dee struggles with who she was, who she is and who she want to be. Dee’s mother, Mrs. Johnson, is the narrator who represents the old world, while Dee represents the new American culture. Walker uses Dee’s hyphenation to show how hybridity, or being made up of two or more cultures, causes a struggle of assimilation among people. After attending college Dee sees herself as being of a higher social class than her mother and Maggie, her sister, which causes major problems within the family’s makeup. Soon this forces Dee and Mrs. Johnson to make decisions that suggest assimilation occurs within Dee and that she is no longer a true family member. Alice Walker’s “Everyday Use” focuses on the oppressed and the oppressor to critique the notion that the only to path to happiness is to give up ones hybridity.
Alice Walker’s “Everyday Use” is a short story about an African American family that struggles to make it. Mama tries her best to give Maggie and Dee a better life than what she had. In Alice Walker’s short story “Everyday Use,” Dee is the older sister and Maggie is younger. Dee is described as selfish and self-centered. Maggie is generous, kind, and cares the family’s history together. She would go out of her way to make sure that her older sister, Dee has everything she needs and wants. Maggie is also willing to share what she has with her sister. Maggie is also shy and vulnerable. Mama is the mother of Maggie and Dee. Mama is fair and always keeps her promises to her children. Hakim-a-barber is the boyfriend
In Alice Walker’s short story “Everyday Use” is about a girl named Dee that is
Growing up in the late 60’s as an African American in the South, Alice Walker has had to withstand many of the oppressions black people faced at the time. Her direct experience with the torment of being prejudiced by her skin color and the national movements against this, have been the fundamental basis to the themes in her writings. In her story “Everyday Use,” she depicts the different understandings of culture between a literate daughter, Dee, and her mother and sister who have not been educated and yet live a traditional simple life together. Through a series of events the author explores the adverse views on heritage among the younger and older generations of African-Americans. Within the historical context, it was time where Blacks were raising awareness and striving to ascertain their personal identities through movements like the “Black Power,” “Black Nationalism,” and “Black Pride” which sought to retrieve their African origins and reject their American heritage. Nevertheless, that is precisely what the author criticizes in her story, saying that they cannot simply reject their true nature disrespecting their real ancestors to embrace a culture they barely know.
Gaiman, Neil. Farrell, Susan. "Fight vs. Flight: A re-evaluation of Dee in Alice Walker's 'Everyday Use.'" eLibrary Curriculum Edition. Proquest, May 1998. Web. 2 Apr. 2015.
Everyday Use, written by Alice Walker is a short story narrated from the eyes of the character Mama. The author uses cultural symbolism throughout her work to tell the tale of struggle between a mother and her two daughters. The tale unfolds at Mama’s house during the Civil rights movement in the late 1960’s and early 1970’s when African Americans were struggling to define themselves and their heritage, the dialog shows conflicting views of how their culture should be appreciated as Mama and Maggie enjoy a visit from Dee. Clear evidence of cultural and contextual symbolism is displayed through: two quilts, Mama’s yard, a fire, a butter churn, and education. The main characters are Mama, who describes herself as "large, big-boned woman with rough, man-working hands" (paragraph 5), Maggie who was burned in a house fire and bears scars on a large portion of her body, Mama attributed her to “a lame animal, perhaps a dog run over by some careless person”(paragraph 9), and Dee was the educated sister that went to a fancy school, who was said to be “lighter than Maggie, with nicer hair and a fuller figure”(paragraph 10), education and skin color were both symbolic of finer things in the era this story was written in. In Everyday Use, readers discover through the main characters, Mama, Maggie, and Dee that perception and appreciation of heirlooms and cultural heritage can be as colorful and variant as the contrast in their skin. We discern a struggle between a mother and two daughters, discovering that education does not equal happiness, and proper tribute to things cherished by all should be left to those who possess them.
The author of “Everyday Use,” Alice Malsenior Walker, is a writer and a civil rights activists. Born on February 09, 1944 to sharecroppers Willie and Minnie Walker in Eatonton, Georgia. She was the youngest of her eight siblings- five boys and three girls. Blinded in one eye at the age of eight by one of her siblings awarded her a “rehabilitation scholarship” to Spelman college in Atlanta, Georgia. Growing up witnessing the history of oppression of her people, and with her college education she became a civil rights activist who wrote short stories on the subject matter. (cite). Her story “Everyday Use” is a good example of how a writer writes what they know through their own experiences. “Everyday Use” published in 1973(cite), can paint mental imagery of what
In Alice Walker’s short story “Everyday Use”, from the psychoanalytical perspective, the three women in the story represent the tri-part division of the mind, evidenced by their actions and the descriptions of each within the story. Together, each tri-part illustrates what was, a black woman’s status in society, and the mental disturbances she faces as glimmers of social integration granted her an opportunity to elevate herself to a higher class, at the cost of her identity. Mama embodies the role of the super-ego. As the narrator in the story, it is through her eyes that the reader both judges and labels the character of her two daughters, and this is based on her own learned ethics. Dee embodies the Id; her role as an antagonistic foil to Maggie, represents the disturbance of impulses untamed. Lastly, Maggie embodies the ego; the conscious self, and is battered by the aggressive nature of the Id in her sister Dee and restricted by the morals taught and reiterat...