Supporting Keegans Interpretation of Haig Historians often differ greatly with their opinions on Field Marshal Haig and how successful he was during the Great War. John Keegan is a modern historian very much in favour of Haig. Keegan is quoted as saying Haig was an "efficient and highly skilled soldier who did much to lead Britain to victory in the First World War". In recent years most historians have begun to accept that Haig was not nearly as bad as the seemingly common view of him as
The Significance of the Liberal Election Victory of 1906 “A quiet, but certain, revolution, as revolutions come in a constitutional country” was how Lloyd George hailed the election victory of 1906. The significance of the Liberal election victory of 1906 is that it laid down solid foundations to provide the welfare state we have today. It also saw the rise of the Labour Party, giving the working class its own political voice. The results of the 1906 election were literally a reversal
This shows that not everyone agrees with Lloyd George's view that Passchendaele was a senseless campaign. Dr Gerard De Groot also says, "Some have suggested that is another man had been in charge they could have saved thousands of lives. I simply don't think this would have been the case". Many other historians have also echoed this feeling about Haig and Passchendaele and its worth as a whole. Overall most of the sources agree with Lloyd George that Passchendaele was a senseless campaign
Lloyd George's Policies How did Lloyd George become an outdated asset in 1922 from a wartime hero in 1918 in the space of four years? Lloyd George’s own policies and his dependence on the conservatives did play a part in his political decline; however this alone didn’t account for his failure and fall. A range of events, issues and reactions played a pivotal part in his downfall. Before 1918 LG had long been the most dynamic Liberal minister, he injected energy into the Liberal party to
The Failure of Lloyd George "I am just a beetle in a glass case". This was Lloyd George speaking during the peacetime coalition and basically refers to the amount of problems he was faced with. We know he had many problems, and we know that he dealt with the important ones badly but why did he eventually resign? Was it the fact that he was a prisoner of the Conservatives? Was it because of his part in the decline of the Liberal party? Or was it just Lloyd George himself? For me, it would
Why Women Did Not Gain the Vote in 1914 In 1914 women could work as highly respected members of society. They could be teachers, moulding the minds of future generations, doctors or nurses caring for the sick and injured and of course mothers possibly the most important role in society. Yet, they had no say in how the world around them was run. This essay will explain why women were blocked from the right to vote, why their say was disregarded, and why they were seen as inferior, in early
Tom Gatenby To what extent did the Conservatives lose the election rather than the Liberals win the election? “The election of 1906 was a significant watershed in the political history of Britain” Kenneth Owen Fox The election of 1906 was a landside victory for the Liberal Party. This is due to many factors, it could been influenced by the manifesto of the Liberal Party, or perhaps even more strongly the failure of the Conservative Party to unify on such reforms as the Tariff Reform
Honor in No One Writes to the Colonel and Chronicle of a Death Foretold by Garcia-Marquez Every culture in the world has its own unique set of values that they adhere to in life. The most important value to people is their honor. Honor is a very important factor in a person life that they will stop at nothing to make sure it is not lost. This endless pursuit of keeping honor can causes both positive and negative effects to a society. The reason honor is a main driving force in a person's
The Reasons for the Liberal Election Victory of 1906 The Liberal election victory of 1906 was due to key issues that the Liberals manipulated to their favour whereas the exhausted Conservatives barely defended their actions. This election victory was on the back of Unionist dominance that had spanned a decade driven by three key issues: "the crown, the church and the constitution." After the Second Boer War in South Africa, everything began to go wrong for the Unionists who then found their
Winston Churchill was perhaps one of the greatest public speakers in history. Some of the best speeches have come from being in life or death situations, Winston was known best for this. His small sound clips like, “this was their finest hour”, and “this is not the end. It is not even the beginning of the end. But it is, perhaps, the end of the beginning”, encourage his troops and his people that they will win this war and will overcome the greatest odds. Although Churchill told many speeches
Why Lloyd George Fell from Power in October of 1922 Lloyd George became Prime Minister in 1916 with the ‘great war’ to deal with. Much was expected from him very quickly. He headed up a coalition made up of predominantly conservatives, also the ‘New Liberals’ and a few labour members. The liberal party was split between the Asquithian Liberals and the Lloyd George followers that joined the coalition. It was inevitable that this coalition would be very difficult to keep under control as it
Churchill: Leader and Statesman Wilson Churchill was a leader that was not afraid to stand in the front, with all the answers in hand and had a trail of willing followers. “He was the lion who roared when the British Empire needed him the most.” Elected into the parliament at merely the age of 25, he began his political career as a statesman in the House of Commons. He later was promoted to serve as First Lord of the Admiralty, Minister of Munitions, Chancellor of Exchequer and finally became
“How important was the role of women during world war 1” The early rush of volunteers and later the conscription of men led to a shortage of manpower on the home front. Women, already working in munitions factories were encouraged to take on jobs normally done by men. This was the start of major social change. Before the war, women had been content to stay at home to bring up the family and do domestic work. It was considered unbecoming for a woman to work. During the war it was considered unpatriotic
Idealists on both sides vowed that a disruption like this should never repeat. So The Treaty of Versailles was the way to maintain peace among nations. So, in January 1919, President Woodrow Wilson of the United States, Georges Clemenceau of France and Lloyd George, Prime Minister of Britain who were otherwise known as the ^Big Three^ and representatives of twenty nine other victorious nations met in Paris to draw up a peace treaty. The Treaty of Versailles, which was based on Wilson^s
coursework I will try and justify whether or not Haig deserved these titles. Q2. During the time when Haig was Field Marshall, people held different opinions on the way he commanded his men at the front line. The prime minister at the time, Lloyd George, believed that Haig was not a competent Field Marshall due to the fact that he was not gaining much ground given the time he had had and the casualties that were rising. On the other hand, fellow Generals and Marshall's who had worked with
different because they are opposite opinions which are referring to the Battle of the Somme but they are written by the same person which was Lloyd George. The two sources however were very different from each other. Source I was written by Lloyd George on the 21st of September 1916 when he visited the battlefield with Sir Douglas Haig. It says that Lloyd George was the secretary for the War at this time of the Somme he was the war leader from 1906-1916. Source J is very negative about the Battle
David Lloyd George's promise of social reform was not met and the lack thereof resulted the Liberals decline in popularity. His failure to provide social reform and in fact his implementation of cuts such as in the case of the Geddes Axe where spending cuts of £86 million were proposed notably in education and health undercut Lloyd George's promise of a ‘land fit for heroes’. Because of these economic problems high
economic effect of the war on the different Allied nations led to different intentions at the Conference. To evaluate the opposing goals of nations at the conference, the contrasting views of Woodrow Wilson’s Fourteen Points and the goals of David Lloyd George and Georges Clemenceau at the Conference will be assessed. Social devastation was also a factor in the decisions made at the conference, as will be evaluated through death and casualty rates of both sides involved in the war, as recorded by the American
Four” incorporated the President of the United States, Woodrow Wilson, The Prime Minister of Great Britain, David Lloyd George, the Prime Minister Of France, Georges Clemenceau, and the Prime Minister of Italy; Vittorio Emanuele Orlando. The most influential figures in the debate were Prime Minister David Lloyd and Prime Minister Georges Clemenceau. Woodrow Wilson requested simple peace, David Lloyd demanded safety and protection from Germany, but Clemenceau eagerly wanted money to pay for all the destruction
not to lose makes the whole system of war ruthless.1 David A. Andelman and Margaret Macmillan agreed that at the peace conference issues at stake were of such that individual nation represented want to know the way out of the war before anarchy was capitulated, but also to gain an upper hand on the victims or less privileged of war. Considering individuals like the prime ministers of Britain and that of France, Clemenceau and David Lloyd George respectively, with their main decisions as when can they